Curb on ordaining
deacons
Vatican concerned about preparations
Bishop Felipe Arizmendi Esquivel of San Cristóbal de las Casas, in the troubled
Mexican state of Chiapas, has announced that—at the request of the Vatican—he
will stop ordaining members of local Indian tribes to the permanent diaconate,
until some Indian men become priests.
The San Cristobal diocese has
seen dozens of Indian men ordained as permanent deacons, in a campaign that
former Bishop Samuel Ruiz Garcia
saw as an effort to “put a native face” on the Church. The Vatican had expressed
misgivings about the number of Indian deacons, noting that there had been no
priestly ordinations from these ethnic groups. The large number of deacons,
Vatican officials worried, could create the impression that a new clerical class
was being created. There were also some concerns about the extent to which the
Indian men had been adequately prepared for their ministry.
Bishop Arizmendi emphasized that
the new policy—which calls for a halt to the ordination of permanent deacons—is
not intended to discourage Indian men from priestly vocations. On the contrary,
he said, “we need more priests . . . from all the different ethnic groups
existing in the diocese.”
On April 6, Bishop Arizmendi
ordained a priest from the Tzotzil tribe, and conferred the temporary diaconate
on another Indian candidate for the priesthood. He remarked, “They are men
belonging to their own people; they have not renounced their blood, their
communities, or their traditions.”
Bishop Arizmendi promised that “once we have a significant number of native
vocations for the priesthood, we will resume ordaining permanent deacons,
because there is nothing wrong with that.” But he reminded the people of Chiapas
that “to this date—even with the new priest—we only have two native priests.”