harbifilmizle.com cheap levitra 20mg azithromycin without chlamydia irtech.com.pl anaheimangelsjersey.com happydeal4u.com does cialis last 72 hours avnai.com calendarfly.com seroquel and seizure threshold estrace sperm estradiol architect tamsulosin viagra priligy uae vrlaksaraytransfer.com in ivf does stopping estradiol cause bleeding ampicillin dosage in killing sperms doxycycline pneumonia dogs 1 side effects of levaquin 500 tinidazole fever enlarged ovaries clomid michaelgahler.de pregnant after taking duphaston and clomid taking wellbutrin with adderall esomeprazole 20 mg vidal coming off dostinex priligy buy online europe w3asia.com hnxxldb.com lasix water pill for dogs melanievotaw.com voltaren 25 mg tablets how to get high on gabapentin side effects of prednisone tamoxifen in dmso seroquel cerotti can one treat vulvodynia with ciprofloxacin tablets vente cialis europe wellbutrin eq baufinanzierung-aktuell.com prednisone side effects in women imajji.com is cialis covered by bc buy paxil online uk gabapentin monotherapy epilepsy milodi.net mobic medication uses tinnitus side effects of metronidazole uso de cytotec embarazo 7 semanas ventolin buhar makinesi paroxetine upset stomach vardenafil nedir what if i took antibiotics before i knew i was pregnant mycities.com.au daylu antibiotics 3000 mg 90 lb dog telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide brand name which to take first terconazole or metronidazole aborto cytotec 11 semanas embarazo does losartan cause erectile dysfunction myghsy.com fish oil paxil arizonaequinerehab.com in welchen l?ndern ist viagra rezeptfrei erh?ltlich sertraline 50 mg bijsluiter why do drug addicts take phenergan and nurofen warfarin cyp2c9 extreme x viagra double dose acyclovir venta de cytotec en cordoba capital ketoconazole hepatitis feet pain lipitor drug side effects cialis online wiki do augmentin kills bad breath acyclovir ng tube strattera works wonders adiconsult.pl mrw-2012.pl where are the place of apani adalat information on drug tamsulosin taking more than one dose of diflucan hedleyenterprises.co.uk hashtonim.com dosing for lasix drip anaheimangelsjersey.com cpt code for albuterol sulfate inhalation solution starlix 120 mg kullan?±m ??ekli how to get oestradiol gel in myanmar vintagevideo.co.uk bumetanide over furosemide fluconazole dosage for stubborn yeast infection levofloxacin 500 mg tablets metformin nifedipine interactions finpecia howdotofound side effects backboneitgroup.com lasix and drinking water 2016filmleri.org diflucan normal dosage metformin dosage 48 93 does clomid helps the eggs to mature side effects of lowering synthroid 0798hx.com glucophage medications mediatrax.com finasteride buy online cipla finasteride tablets uk amoxicillin mg kg pediatric clomid pregnancy and hiv how long until cipro leaves body baclofen swallowing difficulty yellowmag.co.uk celticdan.com hastings-print.co.uk propranolol 160 mg anxiety increased thyroxine level false positive how does bactrim ds help respiratory problems fungsi obat diovan 160 mg safe to use metronidazole with gabapentin what mineral is critical to the synthesis of thyroxine doxycycline hyclate side effects anxiety propranolol sa 80 mg capsule kamagra 4 wingandnut.com how to manage diarrhea when on glucophage how much is cialis one a day alatnj.org blog.fiberwire.ca sildenafil price india adiconsult.pl how to use cytotec to abort can you buy fluoxetine online prednisone side effects in men weight gain can i take levoflox with augmentin best price for metronidazole costco 500mg dogs misoprostol uk online levitra sale thailand avastan.pl zithromax monodose 250 mg cpr 4 celibar.pl melanievotaw.com streetstylesinfo.com lasix with a pe finasteride price in delhi getting pregnant first round clomid wbstaffing.pl ciprofloxacino para la otitis kamagra 2si bir arada can benadryl help erythromycin allergic reaction mister-button.com insideinsights.net fungsi hervis acyclovir metronidazole benzoyl peroxide power v8 viagra ingredient adas-israel.org zoloft rx prolonged release tamsulosin capsules price increasing topamax dosage albuterol sulfate accidental ingestion can you buy cialis in brazil tamsulosin sandoz nebenwirkungen teen prednisone support groups thyroxine online australia why cold on clomid after ovulation hbtaoxian.com voltaren dolo extra 25 mg pastillas cytotec en monterrey when i take levitra i feel warm baclofen tabs para q sirve en esp misoprostol cytotec 200 mcg jinlongcheng.net topamax and lexapro combination why take proventil before advair orlistat structure doxycycline zyrtec rendezvous allegra hotel adelaide address centergaz.pl glucophage hypoglycemia lisinopril anorexia nightanddaysoireeanimation.com occasional prednisone use fruehstuecks-club.net what if you get pregnant on spironolactone viagra legal mexico can u take dayquil with zoloft baclofen vergiftung upperbe.it cfr linezolid resistance how old do you need to be to take viagra hlahlaaung.com andiescafenapavalley.com harelitasarim.com plavix patent can i drink flagyl during my menstruation alprazolam and ketoconazole nijkerkerveen.com what is flagyl 200mg used for cheapest viagra online guaranted obat singulair 10 mg gabapentin used get high allergic reactions to fluconazole does wellbutrin affect creativity celexa and weight gain in women amoxicillin dosage for 6 yr old metformina eg 1000 what is tamsulosin 0.4 mg used for cipro oral for ear infection metoprolol nedir como conseguir viagra sin receta en buenos aires supplino 500 mg metronidazole 500 mg bp can you take panodol with famciclovir tablets pfizer viagra cost in india ibizaglobalradio.com uso del enalapril captopril en los neonatos finasteride en haaruitval propranolol convertion to nadolol healthylifestyleart.com mikezielinski.com does augmentin work for strep revista 10 minutos relojes cipro 500mg ringworm njxdxx.com hasta cuantas veces puedo usar cytotec bruises while on paxil heartsdirect.co.uk how much dose buspirone sell for abundantgraceandcharm.com furosemide liquid dosage for cats can i take 15mg of norvasc azithromycin dihydrate chemical structure leberzirrhose und viagra ciprofloxacin 250 for dog dosage ear infection doxycycline for an ear infection rizatriptan generic date metoprolol and leg swelling can i get my dogs thyroxine online how many days does diflucan stay in your system ubat medroxyprogesterone 50mg 5 day course prednisone side effects mirtazapine valerian interaction bemalingsplan.com celebrex tabletas plm bdxmen.com does canada have a generic form of benicar adalat bugiardino leobakx.com zoloft electric shock sensations aap ki adalat feroz where can i get a sample of female viagra aciclovir contraceptive pill sildenafil precio en mexico backboneitgroup.com finnparanoids.org argylls.co.uk dosage of bactrim for uti glucophage with hmr on pill bluelight baclofen bactrim in nasal side effects viagra price bahawalpur in pakistan lahore how much does plavix cost with discount card finasteride 1mg buy online donde conseguir cytotec en cali 283858.com wowhomes.biz como se toma el montelukast doxycycline brown teeth viagra prescription costs clomid for men and amount of ejaculate ciprofloxacin 4th generation michaelgahler.de clomid post steroid use mikezielinski.com can ciprofloxacin affect your menstrual cycle no1fl.com does 25mg sertraline work unpyme.org.pa wineworldseries.com buy generic singulair no prescription how much is fluoxetine without insurance kegunaan obat nizoral salp njxdxx.com cytotec cuantos meses puedo tomar websitedesignportcharlotte.com vrlaksaraytransfer.com finpecia dosage viagra ?ber paypal kaufen can you take zyrtec at night with singulair buy prednisone rowcmoadreders wellbutrin prices generic generic brand of zyprexa leaflet flagyl vaginal tablets fluconazole available ireland uzdrowisko-ewa.pl methocarbamol and colitis olanzapine generic price uk can metronidazole help herpes iheartjonahbees.net ketoconazole price in india can you shoot gabapentin 100mg and get high shelf life of flagyl cymbalta versus lovan doxycycline and esophageal ulcers napachamberfoundation.com furosemide do i have to take forever 50 mg doxycycline suspension cats bupropion xl availibility in pakistan took clomid but no period irtech.com.pl levaquin side effects dairy nicetouristanbul.com mediatrax.com annsweddings.com.au cheap elavil whartisthebestin is dog prednisone the same as human prednisone can you get high off prazosin towns20.com does erythromycin go out of date amoxicillin 500 in mankind montelukast tablete propecia cause testicular pain missed period side effect of diet pill metoprolol succinate generic price lisinopril react with carvedilol augmentin trattamento nursing responsibility of lasix tamoxifene ed effetti collaterali super tetra tetracycline kesan busy-autokary-wynajem.pl ingrdients in generic levitra atorvastatin medicinenet nortriptyline valerian root combination break off tiny pice of remeron weight gain remeron 7.5 mg more sedating amlodipine and atenolol hplc arilarotokiralama.com houseontheisland.com aciclovir equine sarcoids how fast should cipro work on uti price propecia propak sklepy-zoologiczne.pl sony tv adalat serial efectos viagra y alcohol fertin clomiphene citrate how to use running henrycavillfan.org can i take clomid50 mg n the same time i take m2 tone meloxicam 15 mg reviews mobic meloxicam. 7.5 mg la thuoc gi where can i buy naproxen sodium hydrocodone and celexa high ck lipitor alhafeer4dev.sy street name for lexapro pills effects crushed zyprexa sildenafil high blood pressure zovirax 400 mg for posion ivy dental extraction prednisone tamsulosin hcl 0.4mg how to avoid over erection ciprofloxacin mg dose babahaber.net he discovered erythromycin 0798hx.com alhafeer4dev.sy topamax para que sirve how to discontinue wellbutrin xl bmmpm.com internetowe-szkolenia.pl amoxicillin dosage for a 19 lb dog cialis working by weight chest pain prednisone prank viagra in drink anti inflammatoire celebrex 200mg cialis professional vs cialis super active acyclovir eosinophilia what is cymbalta 60 mg used for premarin 625 upd315.com vbtube.com bactrim ip 272 dosage for uti viagra prices phuket western-showline.de donde puedo comprar misoprostol en san luis potosi azithromycin ear drop dosis amoxilin bwt bisul walmart 10 mg gram lipitor generic price melanievotaw.com does walmart sell clopidogrel bisulfate by perscription seroquel numb lips lexapro 5 mg for 17 year old boy bisenconsulting.com buspar not working anxiety how much does propecia cost uk leukopenia olanzapine does clomipramine give you discoloured teeth bactrim herpes alendronate sodium 10 mg doxycycline for dogs ear infection vibramycin baownbeuv without prescription wingandnut.com mytime99.com viagra in veterinary medicine philippines making nitroglycerine meastcompany.com gabapentin 600 do drug addicts buy propecia mas caida prozac for ocd reviews amoxicillin 875 mg dosage seroquel 25 metoprolol and high cholesterol levofloxacina en fiebre tifoidea uzdrowisko-ewa.pl allegra pastori huaxzw.com does blue cross blue shild cover viagra wonderlandae.com before how much time i take the levitra dexamethasone 20 mg po hillsidesanctuary.com njxdxx.com zoloft online pharmacy mebletmd.pl taking cytotec at 3weeks pregnancy dosage amiodarone 0.5 mg min uniquesarawak.com how quickly will paxil work cialis maximum allowed dose process of thyroxine formation and release mspnor.com lipitor 600 escitalopram generic available huffington arinijayapress.com cymbalta lexapro interaction nightanddaysoireeanimation.com amiodarone side effects harbifilmizle.com cialis 72 hour side effects w3asia.com asylum-booksandgames.com anything comparable to viagra overthecounter tab metronidazole 400mg neurontin settlement vuongminh.com cialis generic overnight state united id-protect.org mehmetaliguven.com sousyakai.net can topamax cause sinus infections benefits of quitting diovan will tamoxifen stop my periods drug class of tetracycline napabusinessadvantage.com is methocarbamol 750 mg addictive variamedia.com.pl augmentine suspension pediatrica michaelgahler.de uniquesarawak.com by xenical in mississauga doxycycline calcium following a tick bite levitra price walmart generic cipro 500 mg flagyl 1 gram 40 mg prozac weight loss contraindicaciones del xenical metformina alcohol 21editore.com acyclovir tablets price in india aap ki adalat sushilkumar shinde lipitor v zarator nexium cold hands thyroxine effects on menstrual cycle escitalopram in europe im-still-learning.com can ciprofloxacin be taken without food accutane bowel symptoms how long is cipro good after expiration date doxycycline bloody stools is iv flagyl and iv potassium compatible pediatric dosage of ventolin marcas de sildenafil en colombia can you take celebrex and tylenol at the same time lexapro 10mg weight loss cost how much does viagra what is proscar used to treat feeling flagyl running in viens is it dangerous viagra 600mg muslim-academy.com dutasteride rowcmoadreders cost best generic viagra canada wholesale con clomid quando avviene l ovulazione coreg 6.25 and zoloft 50 mg obat priligy hopemedicaleducation.com amitriptyline works migraines what does liquior do to fluconazole vizioescort.com what antidepressants are like wellbutrin metro2034.pl azithromycin did it work mooboos.com association-secours-sante.cm normal lasix renal scan zoloft time to get out of system cymbalta 5 days

Rome's Zenit News

 Fecha: 2013-02-27

* * *

The European Court of Human Rights (the Court) has issued several judgments on abortion, especially in recent years since the fundamental ruling of the Grand Chamber in A. B. and C. v. Ireland of 2010. In those cases, the Court found violations of the European Convention on Human Rights (the Convention) in specific situations where the life or the health of the pregnant woman was endangered, or when the pregnancy was the consequence of a rape. The purpose of this article is firstly to identify the rationale of the Court on the matter of abortion, and secondly to observe how it applies to the vast majority of abortions practiced, i.e. “abortion on demand”, also called on request:  abortions that are not justified by a matter of health, life or rape, but by the free will of the woman.

Through its various rulings, the Court explicitly declared that abortion is not a right under the Convention: there is no right to have an abortion (Silva Monteiro Martins Ribeiro v. Portugal) or to practice it (Jean-Jacques Amy v. Belgium). The prohibition per se of abortion by a State does not violate the Convention, (Silva Monteiro Martins Ribeiro v. Portugal see also the case of the first two applicants who unsuccessfully complained of the prohibition of abortion on demandinA. B. and C. v. Ireland), but States can allow it for the sake of competing rights guaranteed by the Convention, i.e. the life and the health of the pregnant woman. In other words, it can be said that the Court tolerates an abortion if it is justified by a proportionate motive protected by the Convention.

It is uncontested, even by the promoters of a right to abortion, that there is no direct or indirect right to abortion on demand or for socio-economic reasons in any international or regional treaty, including the European Convention on Human Rights (Ch. Zampas and J. Gher, “Abortion as a Human Right…” p. 287). Abortion on demand is illegal in three out of four countries in the world. When the Convention was drafted, abortion on demandwas widely recognised as a crime (Brüggemann and Scheuten v. Federal Republic of Germany§ 64). It is true that the absence of right does not creates a prohibition and vice versa, but legal arguments supporting that abortion on demanddoes not hurt the Convention do not resist the analysis. When applying the reasoning and the case-law of the Court to such claims of abortions, they fail to find any justification under the Convention.

In cases where abortion is legal, the Court has established that its legal framework shall adequately take into account the different legitimate interests involved. The Court has stressed several times that if and:

“once the state, acting within its limits of appreciation, adopts statutory regulations allowing abortion in some situations”, “the legal framework devised for this purpose should be shaped in a coherent manner which allows the different legitimate interests involved to be taken into account adequately and in accordance with the obligations deriving from the Convention” (A. B. and C. v. Ireland § 249; R. R. v. Poland § 187;P. and S. v. Poland§ 99; see also Tysiac v. Poland, § 116).

This wording became the principle underpinning the regulation of abortion by the Court. Therefore, States are free as to decide to allow or not abortion, but once the national legislator decides to legalise it, the Court can assess its legal frameworkby looking whether in the specific situation at stake a fair balance was struck between the various rights and interests involved in the issue. As the Grand Chamber said simply, “It is also clear from an examination of these cases [of the Commission and Court] that the issue has always been determined by weighing up various, and sometimes conflicting, rights or freedoms” (Vo v France § 80). In synthesis, once a State decides to allow abortion, its “margin of appreciation is not unlimited” “as to how it balances the conflicting rights”; then “the Court must supervise whether the interference constitutes a proportionate balancing of the competing interests involved” (A. B. and C. v. Ireland §§ 238; 237).

The Court has already identified a number of those “different legitimate interests involved” such as the legitimate interest of society in limiting the number of abortions (Odièvre v. France§ 45), the interests of society in relation to the protection of morals (Open Door and Dublin Well Woman v. Ireland§ 63; A. B. and C. v. Ireland  §§ 222-227). The Court has also identified a number of rights guaranteed by the Convention that can be curtailed by an abortion, in addition to the right to life of the unborn which status is still not clearly defined.  One may think that the only Convention right affected by an abortion is the right to life of the unborn child. This is not the case, otherwise, how could be justified the limitations of access to abortion, such as the prohibition of sexist or late-term abortions? Those rights are article 3 and 8. The Court applied to the unborn the prohibition of torture in Boso v. Italy, and the right to respect for family life to the “potential father” in X. v. the United Kingdomand to the potential grand-mother in P. and S. v. Poland. There are also other rights curtailed in specific situations, in particular the freedom of conscience of health professionals (Tysiac v. Poland § 121; R. R. v. Poland § 206) and of medical institutions (Rommelfanger v. FRG). The matter of the rights of disabled people in regard to wrongful birth (K. v. Latvia) and wrongful life cases (M. P. v. Romania) is also currently before the Court.

As shown in its case-law, for the Court, abortion should have (at least apparently) an objective motive that may outweigh the various competing rights and interests affected by the procedure and guaranteed and recognised by the Convention, namely the protection of the life and of the health of the pregnant woman.

Examining the Court’s case-law, it appears that the Court has never admitted that the free-will or the autonomy of the woman could, on its own, suffice to justify an abortion. No right to abortion stems from the right to personal autonomy; as it was reaffirmed recently in the P. and S. v. Poland,case, the Grand Chamber of the Court “has held that Article 8 [guaranteeing personal autonomy] cannot be interpreted as conferring a right to abortion” inA. B. and C. v. Ireland (§ 214). Therefore, while abortion on demand finds no justification under the Convention, it affects rights guaranteed by the Convention and interests recognized by it. The curtailment of those rights and interests by abortion on demand is not balanced with, and justified by any competing right guaranteed by the Convention. Consequently, abortion on demand violates the Convention, although it represents the vast majority of all abortions performed. This violation by the State is even more flagrant when we do not only consider the negative obligations of States under the Convention not to take life, but also the positive obligations to protect and support life, the pregnant women and family life.

Logically, regarding abortions that are not on demand, their necessity and proportionality with their cause and aim should be established in order to respect the Convention (A. B. and C. v. Ireland§ 249; R. R. v. Poland § 187;P. and S. v. Poland§ 99).

The only way for the Court to conclude that abortion on demand would not violate the Convention would be to declare that the unborn child is not a person, and, in addition, to renounce to offer protection to the other rights and interests affected by the abortion. For that the Court would have to push the unborn into a legal gap. If, on the one hand, the Court allows States, withintheir margin of appreciation, to determine in their internal order “when the right to life begins” (Vo v France § 82), on the other hand, the Court since Brüggemann and Scheuten v FRG (§ 60) and R. H. v. Norway(p. 167) has always refused to exclude the unborn from the field of application of the Convention and to declare that he/she is not a person within the meaning of the Convention. In Vo v France, the Grand Chamber said “that it is neither desirable, nor even possible as matters stand, to answer in the abstract the question whether the unborn child is a person for the purposes of Article 2 of the Convention”, and added that “itmay be regarded as common ground between States that the embryo/foetus belongs to the human race” and that he/she “require[s] protection in the name of human dignity” (§ 85). As Judge Jean-Paul Costa explained “Had Article 2 been considered to be entirely inapplicable, there would have been no point – and this applies to the present case also – in examining the question of foetal protection and the possible violation of Article 2, or in using this reasoning to find that there had been no violation of that provision” (Separate Opinion in Vo v France §11).

At first glance, people may think that abortion on demand is acceptable under the Convention because the Court has not yet condemned a State for permitting it. It is so only because of the general toleration of abortion in Europe, because the direct victims of abortion never had the chance to survive and to complain before the Court, and because the opponents to abortion have not been recognised as victim (Borre Arnold Knudsen v. Norwayand X. v. Austria). Until now, only the pregnant women have been able to successfully complain, as victims, for difficulties in access to legal abortion, for malpractice or physical complications of abortion (Csoma v. Romania). Regarding the father, the Court has recognized that “as a potential father… he could claim to be a victim” of the abortion practiced on his unborn child (Boso v. Italy, see also X. v. the United Kingdom). The reason why the Court found no violation of the father’s rights is only because in those cases, abortions were declared aimed at preserving the mothers’ health, and therefore justified and proportionate in the eyes of the Court. Judge Jean-Paul Costa noticed acontrario: “It would have had to reach the opposite conclusion had the legislation been different and not struck a fair balance between the protection of the foetus and the mother’s interests. Potentially, therefore, the Court reviews compliance with Article 2 in all cases in which the “life” of the foetus is destroyed” (Separate opinion in Vo v France § 13). The Court also recognized under article 8 that “the interests and life prospects of the mother of a pregnant minor girl are also involved in the decision whether to carry the pregnancy to term or not” (P. and S. v. Poland§ 109), therefore, a potential grand-parent can also have locus standi.

Possibly, one day a father or grand-parent of an unborn child will complain before the Court and succeed to save the life of their child. All that such a father or grandparent has to do is to fax a letter to the Court under article 39 of the Rules of the Court, requesting it to take urgent and interim measures in order to avoid the realization of a serious and imminent risk of breach of a fundamental right. All they have to do is to request that the rights to life (art. 2) and to physical integrity and dignity (art. 3) of their unborn child or grand-child be preserved, and that their right to family life (art. 8) be protected. The relatives of the unborn child could successfully obtain from the Court an order to suspend the procedure of abortion, if they demonstrate that this abortion is not justified by a proportionate motives guaranteed by the Convention; they may also inform the Court that they are ready to rear the child. This procedure has never been used yet to stop an abortion, but it could be an effective way to save lives. It would be in continuity with the original meaning of the Convention and with the Court’s own case-law.

So far, the Court has stayed on the edge, refusing to throw the unborn child out of the scope of the Convention, and refusing to let him “naked”, without any legal protection. So far, the Court has gone as far as it could to tolerate abortion without nullifying the human beings before their birth. Currently, abortion advocates are repeatedly demanding the Court to jump this gap and to throw the unborn out, in the name of human rights.

It is still time for the Court to hold its mission to protect every human being, especially the weakest. It is true that people, at least in Western countries, do not really care for the life of the child before birth; maybe simply because we are out of danger: we do not face anymore the risk of being aborted. We care much more for the human rights that we may be deprived of. However, abortion on demand is nothing else than the domination of the born over the not-yet-born. One can say that it has its own legitimacy, but this legitimacy is only one of violence, even if we call this violence freedom; it should not be covered up with the legitimacy of human rights.

Most Popular