seroquel xr atypical antipsychotic zovirax cream and breastfeeding smpc misoprostol can ciprotab be use for tonsilities allopurinol indocin buy 500 mg doxycycline online without prescription day 8 zoloft estrace thin lining is wellbutrin like amphetamine benazepril katzen propecia reviews women penile yeast infection persists after prescription montelukast stada 10mg viagra eciwlcodkedefe no prescription valtrex 500 mg cost what dosage does cialis come in can i give phenergan and lortab elixir for toddler inderal 40mg k faiday biotech ciproflacin for sinus infection isoptin tabletta tamoxifeno y tiroides ciprofloxacin vs breastfeeding generic cialis vs real cialis cialis generika rezeptfrei per ?berweisung meloxicam 15 mg side effects para que es 90 buspirone hcl 5mg tadacip 20 buy buy kamagra jelly viagra generic 100mg buy should nexium taken morning night flagyl generic equivalent respiratory side effects of plavix para que sirven lenovostregel con estradiol a horses what are the benefits of metformin dose of hydrochlorothiazide trazodone price walmart strattera without adhd how much does micardis 40 mg cost chinese viagra alternatives viagra side effects alcohol augmentin duo forte price india cipro aja napa lexapro and buspar sildenafil actavis is it the same as viga the problem with socialism thatcher internet sticker minipress kl neurontin veterinary dosages ciprotab side effects amoxicillin medreich how do i take clomid capsule can you take nexium and drink alcohol how do you know he is.taking viagra diet pills with ephedra over night from on line ph escitalopram disturbo ossessivo compulsivo pregnancy and clomid symptoms ciprofloxacin and tanning beds viagra zoll schweiz clomid 2x per dag septra mg compare cipro levaquin baclofen alcohol forum nexium mups 20 mg health buy england finasteride does walmart sell clopidogrel bisulfate by perscription what is the purpose of taking prednisone est ce que clomid marche bien acyclovir fever blister does 80mg of paxil make you sleepy. lisinopril impurity f generique du cialis 10mg gibt es stromectol in holland desogen increased libido generic propecia bertibarots viagra price comparison chart en barranquilla donde se consigue priligy terbinafine vs tolnaftate lipitor hoe innemen strongest dosage of prednisone 20mg for poision sumac does benicar have street value prednisone in dogs and incontinence how much does a 20 mg yellow capsule of cialis cost sildenafil pfizer kokemukset kamagra oral jelly alibaba adverse reactions for lasix pentru ce se foloseste augmentin flomax effects on liver amoxicillin bitter taste in mouth aromatase inhibitors vs tamoxifen can amoxicillin affect the nuvaring does trazodone 50 milligram help with pain viagra 50mg tablets free delivery about levitra drug efectos malignos del viagra very little bleeding after taking misoprostol is it safe to take zofran in the third trimester tamoxifen effect on uterine lining for pregnancy augmentine 500mg for boils price of generic lexapro drop do you become dependant on viagra grapefruit juice and glucophage prednisone for sudden sensorineural hearing loss buspirone hcl 15 mg tablet what ised for mayo clinic trazodone hydrochloride dangers of lisinopril cymbalta hunger pains celebrex kidneys diflucan leaves system doxycycline for mrsa in urine chloromycetin palmitat 25 mg ml kaufen how much time to active viagra 100mg zithromax 4 comprim?s en une seule prise alternative to nizoral beating prednisone weight gain montelukast sodium in 3rd trimester of pregnancy can doxylamine succinate be taken with antidepressant regenpure shampoo for prescription uk log p of atorvastatin calcium paroxetine price without insurance ciprofloxacin iv price metronidazole and chlamidia trachomatis ciprofloxacin for hospital acquired pneumonia can i take fluconazole with adderall bactrim ds cut half cuanto necesito para fincar una casa how does spironolactone work for hirsutism tamoxifeno causa depressao new formulation of metformin tamoxifeno baja libido can a woman with fibroid take zovirax after delivery ciprofloxacin prospect anm buy xenical online in europe no prescription can you buy viagra at a mexican drug store ciproxin cistite 500 order clomid howdotofound tadalafil ati can spironolactone help with weight loss remeron 5mg prednisone for ms patients amoxicillin and skin rash levofloxacin mode of plavix lowest price seroquel deadly how can ciprotab be taken cytotec farmacia tucuman treatment of paroxetine withdrawal fluconazole for nail fungus in men cialis pills pink bactrim ds ear pain i am nervous about taking diflucan 150 spironolactone side effects sore nipples viagra with hot water buspirone generic for is all prednisone the same augmentin stomaco pieno tamoxifen ratiopharm 20 mg tabletten dog ate 250mg terbinafine ciprofloxacin 1a farma accutane cardiac side effects metronidazole religious upset how does amoxicillin taste can you take two 25mg viagra instead of one 50gm quetiapine contraindications atrial fibrillation generic estradiol patch cost does cialis become more effective with longer use international drug mart viagra phenergan to treat vertigo lisinopril joint muscle pain metoprolol 25 mg tabl viagra precio usa pink viagra wiki zyprexa en overgewicht itching while taking bactrim does valtrex come in liquid form buspar for occasional use augmentin inainte de nastere medical store of cialis in delhi disilden sildenafil 100mg metformin ttc long term effects of taking neurontin how long for cialis 20 to begin doxycycline and keppra atorvastatin tablets product monograph pdf male actor in cialis and sugar commercials how much amoxicillin for tooth abscess cost para q es el bactrim forte does zoloft mess you up how to enhance the effects of cialis pregnancy birth risks to taking zoloft dose dependant macam diuretik tipe lasix ventolin nebules and pregnancy bactrim sibo wellbutrin overdose amount mg anastrozole vs tamoxifen pct celecoxib and myocardial infarction viagra maximum castellano poison ivy coming off prednisone finasteride coupe 4 buy accutane germany nebenwirkung von nexium mups taking keflex with penicillin allergy abilify efficacy depression acyclovir ointment otc in canada is metronidazole 500 mg good for uti 3000 mgs of seroquel and alcohol valsartan 80 mg tab hamstring pain with cialis mirtazapine 7.5 mg side effects plavix authorized generic doxepin vs celexa composition nd antidote of lasix can you take amoxicillin if you have a mold allergy cost of valacyclovir hydrochloride rite aid fluconazole prescription free cialis australia 20mg palpitation after viagra how long take synthroid during day reducing zoloft medication buy kamagra jelly uk dose of bactrim for cellulitis cost nexium mexico aeromonas hydrophila ampicillin use of estrace cream side effects of cipro and metronidazole on dogs does clomid give you a period propranolol equivalent dose metoprolol is doxycycline 100mg the same for pets and humans amoxicillin and breastmilk supply whats cheaper than viagra alternatives to lisinopril cough furosemide in renal is plavix hard on a cats stomach para que serve o rem?dio aciclovir cancer caused by tamoxifen low dose accutane adults amoxil and coumadin interaction prozac upset stomach cytotec abortion eua celexa and diphenhydramine lethal dose of lipitor how long do side effects from stopping celexa last naproxene 250 mg prix para que sirve la pastilla adalat cc how to take zoloft for pe lasix and decreased kidney function buy levitra online 24 hours what is t4 thyroxine free can i take vitamin e with propecia lisinopril side effects gagging does tamoxifen cause iron deficiency viagra. bulk. com clopidogrel bleeding does augmentin work for strep prednisone steroid rashes 100mg clomid and progesterone day 14 paxil effects on ocd and depression cardizem cd 360 generic quetiapine cost per pill quetiapine xl bnf finasteride for cats does alcohol reduce effectiveness of cialis street name of seroquel lipitor migraines when is best days to take clomid tamsulosin making me pee more urgently prednisone and aloe vera paxil 20 mg sad evista 5 years cymbalta dosage and administration kamagra online bestellen forum recours collectif premarin creme clomid ovaio multifollicolare allegra 180 mg has aspirin lescol vs lipitor flomax for peg tube olanzapine sugar free when does prednisone acne go away letrozole clomid ovulation voltaren rapid100mg. verapamil 6440 buy cheap ivermectin naprosyn sr 750 mechanism of action of atorvastatin in epilepsy cost of acyclovir in pakistan accutane month 2 30 mg how many days until cipro clears up chlamydia nsaid and zoloft ciprofloxacin och pc allergi viagra kaufen ohne rezept ?sterreich how can i lose weight on prednisone how much dom quetiapine would kill me. sarpogrelate clopidogrel diferen?a atenolol e propranolol gabapentin beta 600mg celexa and unisom sildenafil presentacion y dosis contraindicaciones del sildenafil en diabeticos what parasites are treated with flagyl nizoral shampoo price mercury drug buy sildenafil st. maarten ivermectina en perros golden order cymbalta online no prescription amoxicillin pediatric drops in philippines canada cialis finasteride renacidin precio can you take singulair and benadryl together trazodone hcl 50mg tab can i snort it is flagyl safe during first trimester pregnancy wellbutrin and adderall side effects buy albuterol sulfate nebulizer avodart side effects joint pain clopidogrel tad 75 mg france lawsuits involving abilify fluconazole 150 mg work for oral thrush metformin 500 mg novo folic acid and synthroid powdered viagra recipe nizoral 1 percent for acne accutane acne after zoloft finally kicked in tamoxifen citrate for gyno amoxicillin infant dosage ear infection is acyclovir cream over the counter efeito colateral do lipitor posologia do tadalafil prednisone 4mg dose pack oily hair while on accutane levaquin fever side effect purple triangle pill like viagra for sale amoxicillin squirrel dosing rash por tomar bactrim singulair precio fluconazole actavis 150 mg price in ireland efek obat aspen fluconazole untuk fitiligo lipitor fiyati inderal neurontin lamisil generic form do fish oil effect lisinopril can lamisil treat jock itch esomeprazole magnesium nexium azithromycin and staph aureus how long does it take erythromycin to get rid of acne ciprone tab side effects to buspirone zyprexa side effects orgasm septra d for acne kamagra franchise in uk herbal remedies for lisinopril prednisone steroid buy online cipro ear drops generic fungsi raloxifene metformin induced nephropathy zoloft and eye twitching amoxil in gum infection cytotec famille cialis and argenine whats thhe difference between inderal and prinivil how to prevent erectile disunion flagyl lyme dosage propranolol variceal bleeding buy online zoloft low potassium on lanoxin compuestos quimicos del aciclovir benefits of taking 2 levitra pills el misoprostol es de venta libre en estados unidos nexium esomeprazole 20 mg adalah can synthroid crushed female viagra yahoo benicar 40 coupon medroxyprogesterone detox voltaren 50mg icontrindicaziioni dcis without tamoxifen adalat meaning in english formula del medicamento bactrim

Palin Family Values and the Abortion Debate

Abortion activists and media analysts in awe with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to give birth to her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry her baby's father.
by Joan Frawley Desmond | Source:

Perhaps the most absorbing element of this election season is the spectacle of abortion activists and media analysts grappling with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to spare the life of her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry the father of her unborn child.

As a group of talking heads on television expressed their amazement at the state of the Palin household, I thought of William May, my moral theology professor at the John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, and his penchant for poking holes in the tortured logic of abortion advocates. May could nail the source of abortion supporters’ present discomfort in a nanosecond: Palin’s family choices directly challenge arguments that justify abortion as the “lesser evil.”

Since the ’60s, reproductive rights activists have presented abortion as perhaps the best solution for the scourge of teenage pregnancy, inner-city poverty, gender inequality, and the suffering experienced by disabled infants and their families. But May didn’t buy those arguments: “If abortion is the ‘lesser evil,’” he used to tell our class, “then the alternative — keeping the baby — constitutes the ‘greater evil.’ But how can that position be proved?”

The answer is that it’s impossible to prove that abortion constitutes the “lesser evil.” Catholic moral theologians like May have labored for years to explain both the logical inconsistencies and the moral dangers of the “lesser evil” argument. Now, the Palin family is providing an assist.

Basically, the “lesser evil” argument seeks to weigh, or commensurate, the good and evil consequences of two opposing moral choices.

But May and others argue that this exercise is like comparing apples and oranges. With abortion, the decision is made to terminate nascent human life in order to avoid a worse outcome. According to this equation, bringing the baby to term will produce such disastrous consequences that the good of preserving human life is outweighed by the overwhelming burden of sustaining it. But no abortion advocates have offered an analytical model that will support this utilitarian calculation. In fact, this balancing act is not a precise scientific evaluation, but a reflection of personal beliefs and experience.

The “lesser evil” argument also reveals a scary indifference to the moral evil inherent in the choice to destroy innocent human life. Many pregnant women, unwed or not, can be overwhelmed by the scandal, financial and logistical demands, and threats to personal freedom posed by the arrival of a new child. This argument implicitly assumes the mother can predict the future, and that it will be bleak if her child is brought to term. But this, too, cannot be proved. The future, as we all know, is woefully, or gloriously, unpredictable.

In fact, the “lesser evil” position depends on scary scenarios that can distract the would-be mother from the fundamental moral principle at issue: “You shall not do evil that good shall come of it.”

There was a time when every American child learned that “the ends don’t justify the means.” But since the ’60s, that moral aphorism has been under sustained attack, both within and without the Church. Long before self-described Catholic politicians challenged traditional teaching on abortion, the Church was roiled by the eruption of theological dissent on the morality of married couples using contraception.

The rejection of Humanae Vitae (The Regulation of Birth) depended on a steady stream of sympathetic portraits of married couples struggling to achieve financial and emotional stability by spacing births. Contraception was the “lesser evil.”

During the debate on Humanae Vitae, dissenting theologians advanced two additional arguments to justify the use of contraception. Moral relativism remained the most popular argument — times had changed, and moral absolutes no longer applied. The second argument has been described as the “fundamental option”: “Good” people can occasionally violate moral absolutes without endangering their souls. Good Catholics could contracept, as long as they remained loving parents and spouses. Since then, similar arguments have been employed to justify abortion, sidestepping the decisive way evil actions shape our character and future moral choices.

The three lines of theological dissent pose logical and moral problems. But May also liked to expose the blind spot at the heart of any rejection of moral absolutes. The arid “lesser evil” equation that sentences the unborn child to death ignores the endless possibilities of a human choice that embraces the great good of preserving life.

As Pope John Paul II often noted, the Ten Commandments provide the absolute limit beyond which human behavior cannot descend. But the Decalogue sets no limits on human transcendence. Christians navigate their temporal existence with the aid of a Church that offers the truth that sets us free.

When abortion is off the table, the search for true solutions begins — tightening the household budget, proposing marriage, offering the child for adoption to a childless couple. Catholic moral teaching drives human creativity, inspiring real fruitfulness.

Once declared a settled political question, abortion keeps resurfacing at the center of the political stage. In part, that’s because the debate over abortion is not just about the unborn person’s right to life. It’s also about how we should embrace the vast possibilities of our vocation to love as Christ loves us. How we should live in this world.

Many Americans, Republicans and Democrats will be drawn to the drama of the Palin family. And while neither they nor we know what the future holds, we share their hopes. And who knows? Maybe this election will consign the “lesser evil” argument to the dustbin of history. Professor May would applaud heartily.

Marylander Joan Frawley Desmond writes for a variety of publications on religious and cultural topics.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular