can i take meloxicam 15mg and ibuprofen 800 nursing implications for gabapentin does taking levothyroxine cause hair loss taking synthroid ephedrine atorvastatin generics for stomache problems aciclovir ranbaxy fass flagyl and silver sertraline hcl 100 mg cost bupropion 100 mg and urine smell cialis funguje what is the target cell of thyroxine difference in viagra 50mg vs 100mg lisinopril 40 mg high metformin sebagai obat diet lemon juice and viagra pregnant twins first round clomid what is the difference between 50 mg and 100 mg viagra can i take zinc when can you drink on augmentin can i take warfarin with viagra dexamethasone for dogs dosage injection 8 lb dog augmentin 1g during pregnancy lipitor generico intercambiable can i take claritin amoxicillin voltaren taking synthroid normal thyroid does doxycycline cross the blood brain barrier side effect viagra men paroxetine merck index clozapine injectable form side effects from short term prednisone use portable avec mobicarte pas chers how long to take doxycycline for blepharitis reviews about prednisone maxalt 10 mg dosage instructions seroquel dyskinesia coming down off paxil functional groups vardenafil clonidine and suboxone together pfizer viagra 100mg price beli cytotec di mana high white blood cell count and prednisone zoloft drug ratings how safe is ondansetron in pregnancy propranolol chinese clomid e gravidanza gemellare utbhogta adalat productos que reemplazan al viagra will amphetamine salts and buspar heighten effects review propecia 4rx orlistat vs lipobind azithromycin off label cipronex cena apteka zithromax medline which companys having azithromycin tablets how much are clomid treatments in australia zithromax 2g single dose glucophage xr diferencia glucophage metronidazole kills sperm what is medroxyprogesterone 10mg used for clonidine 0.1mg patch what it use for amitriptyline street price ritemed metformin 850 mg for pcos treatment terbinafine pills ebay viagra nin etkisi zoloft starts working immediately can flagyl cause black stool in dogs cialis in urdu azithromycin cause sore throat composition du propranolol street value prescription antidepressants overdose of atorvastatin how to come off finasteride success without finasteride long does daily cialis take work gabapentin sciatic nerve dog can you take celebrex and tramadol together cialis c80 dose finasteride made me sterile hoe werkt olanzapine ativan tamoxifen can i take topamax and depakote at the same time metformin dosage how to take us product information otc singulair periactin 8mg kroger viagra pharmagaba for gabapentin withdrawal do you take zithromax side effects from generic lexapro levothyroxine 50 mcg weight loss where to buy clomid for women with pcos how do i know if zoloft is right for me viagra online bestellen sicher what drug is most similar to cymbalta cipla azithromycin 500 mg dose for gonorrhea which works better propecia or avodart propecia for men south africa adalat reactii adverse does fluconazole interact with biotin how much an estrace cream cost in canada tardive dyskinesia wellbutrin augmentin sulfamidico septra bacterial coverage can you use amoxicillin to treat strep throat mg of celexa sildenafil citrate tablets companies do not use lamisil spray on the nails or scalp. xenical comprar rj too much hydrochlorothiazide cymbalta dosage 100mg lexapro pepto bismol clomid menopur ivf zyprexa 5 mg foglietto illustrativo how long does it take fluconazole 150mg to work painful ovulation while on clomid buy clomid cost acyclovir zoster keratitis telmisartan 80 mg bring cough tadalafil 20 mg pay by wire will viagra make you fully hard colchicine 0.6 mg ??„??·??­ neurontin does not work presentacion del tadalafil doxycycline dosage rxlist cialis sublingual tabs cheap albuterol 3 el nexium sirve para la diarrea ciprofloxacin dosage for uti metronidazole dosage for pericoronitis metronidazole 500 mg antibiotic for dogs expiration when does zoloft begin working fluconazole dosage thrush low dose elavil for headaches from concussion can yu use clomid with one kidney cost of zyprexa extended release terbinafine uk informacion sobre valacyclovir viagra for premature ejactulation buy kamagra in leeds uk does ciprotab tablet good for pregnant person call viagra generic plavix and muscle and joint pain does lexapro ever stop working gabapentin after amputation what does remeron 7.5 mg do disulfiram pregnancy how much does celebrex cost in canada neck pain with cymbalta lasix 80 mg side effects clomid lower shbg sildenafil enfermedad pulmonar cost of cialis vs viagra lamisil cream side effects liver dextromethorphan hydrobromide 20 mg clopidogrel 75mg design azithromycin 250 mg for mastitis disulfiram implantacja lamisil vs lotrimin ringworm is it true that flagyl pills can do an abortion can i take indegestion luiqid with erythromycin how long does zithromax take to work for chlamydia amoxicillin trihydrate at walgreens quetiapine fumarate seroquel xr prednisone burst is bloating a symptom of taking metronidazole aciclovir dorom 5 crema how much does naproxen 375mg cost can i come off singulair 5mg chewable cipro 500mg for 3 days cymbalta nausea and pot diferencia entre ciprofloxacina y claritromicina how many women had twins on clomid can buspar work right away propecia 0.25mg eod clomid 150 mg success rate pcos obat apa dexamethasone should prednisone make you tired orlistat tablet reviews can taking cipro cause yellow urine what is ciprolex revatio online bestellen nifedipine treatment raynauds ritzatriptan benoate with cymbalta finasteride vs avodart cuales son las contraindicaciones del viagra diflucan and dexilant are neurontin and lyrica the same prednisone effect on kidney function does spironolactone decreased libido lexapro lamictal interactions cyp2c19 genotype plavix clomid maschio o femmina finasteride ricrescita dysphoria abilify does clomid cause period late spironolactone loading dose valium vs buspar atarax y pastillas anticonceptivas where is the best price to buy plavix in barry co mi sale generic levitra 10 mg olanzapine in diabetes how to counteract viagra can cephalexin make you fail a drug test allergy to amoxicillin in toddlers zoloft for stomach problems singulair pill dosage can i take zoloft and maxalt atarax onmeda contraindications while taking diflucan zovirax online apotheke treatment chlamydia doxycycline bactrim ds tendonitis gut preis singulair 5 mg 100mg iv ciprofloxacin price in philippines stopped finasteride and nothing happened prednisone side effects levitra generico em farmacia is topiramate tab 50mg gluten free discount price on viagra combitic global caplet cialis nexium sulfur composicion de lamisil crema prednisone prickly heat que efectos causa el viagra en una mujer cialis for hypogonadism propecia tablets reviews erythromycin ophthalmic ointment 0.5 teaching pregnancy does erection last with viagra after buspar sleep paralysis proscar baratos sin receta nombre comercial del seroquel can men take viagra pink pill austell erythromycin generic proventil levonorgestrel 150 mcg etinilestradiol 30 mcg precio lexapro and low dose aspirin can you take a diflucan every 48 hours cardura 3 mg buy cialis hk walmart seroquel xl price augmentin 1000 mg yan etkisi metronidazole cost cvs how much does citalopram cost uk strattera wellbutrin ritalin apakah amoxilin 500mg aman utk ibu hamil achat atarax 100 get bactrim out of system thyroxine pills online what if some girl drinks viagra fatigue and prednisone taper amoxicillin and trying to get pregnant can nexium cause leaky gut low dose lexapro 5htp buspar high or not augmentin 875 mg dose sertraline bp monograph how to mix olanzapine order baclofen online seroquel xr 600 mg cellulitis levaquin dose nexium sandoz how many pills come in 20mg of lexapro bactrim psychosis escitalopram angst amoxicillin 3g sachet sf is quetiapine allowed in thailand fungsi obat levofloxacin 500 mg how much should nexium cost ciprofloxacin for perianal abscess what happens if u drink on citalopram hbr 20 mg allegra weight loss proscar 2.5mg tamoxifen reduces risk breast cancer isotretinoin side effects mood waarvoor dient mobic lisinopril hctz and extreme sun exposure can you get a buzz from sublingual zofran prescription drugs propranolol obat kuat cialis malang shingles acyclovir dose probiotics and wellbutrin xl cialis pharmacy india buy trazodone online no prescription prednisone treatment only for cats side effects adalat oros 30 en el embarazo what is the cephalexin 500mg for lamisil side effects sore throat paxil withdrawal without side effects buy viagra in shopko what happens when man take viagra first time septra dosage for utiside effects pill nexium 40 mg zovirax tablet price mercury drug fushing viagra how to use clomid on your own azithromycin absetzen 4 weeks of lexapro withdrawal in elderly hydrochlorothiazide lower potassium misoprostol y embarazo bula de medicamentos nizoral why is my viagra not working informacion de cymbalta en espanol will erythromycin treat pink eye lexapro price india can plavix raise blood sugar zocor synthroid pediatric dosing chart septra kamagra oral jellies order viagra without rx online bactrim ds side effects shaking will you trip if you take 8 verapamil verapamil 240 mg side effects bactrim palpitations how safet is finasteride bactrim no rx zoloft libido side effects can men take metronidazole 400mg estradiol level 500 lipitor vs simvastatin side effect amoxicillin b.p 500mg how its work clonidine dosage for 4 year old plavix approved fda norfloxacin metronidazole use in animals clomid 150mg success rate can you take motion sickness pills with topamax seroquel ahdistus if you stop gabapentin suddenly does it cause withdrawl hexenschuss voltaren retard tabletten allegra sabadell residencia per gent gran indomethacin every 4 hours interaction between alcohol and ciprofloxacin dose for augmentine to elder montelukast side effects increased urination uk bnf how long till celexa is out of my system drank albuterol feel light headed bactrim vs cipro which one has less side effects levitra with dapoxetine overnight does citalopram help anxiety and opiate withdrawls cialis work after ejeculation zoloft and tmj paxil low grade fever plavix generic prices fexofenadine price comparison omeprazole metformin interaction escilopram oxalate and duloxetine tamsulosin women methocarbamol ortoton? how long will 10 mg seroquel stay in your system indocin 25 mg high cephalexin yellow skin lasix vs. furosemide neurontin hair loss lawsuits prozac 60 mg ocd combination of bupropion and lithium gamit ng cytotec viagra long term side effects on men fertility how does augmentin affect norethindrone albuterol sulfate inhalation solution for free cialis with dapoxetine nicosia viagra online nexium cortisol can cocaine mixed with viagra cause a severe headache medroxyprogesterone 2.5 mg abilify doesn work adalat 45 can you drink alcohol while taking strattera do you have to be perscribed viagra zyban duration finasteride 5 mg pcos dutasteride ganarpelo oral antibiotics dat cure kidney is lexapro any good prednisone 20 mg tapering schedule

Palin Family Values and the Abortion Debate

Abortion activists and media analysts in awe with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to give birth to her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry her baby's father.
by Joan Frawley Desmond | Source:

Perhaps the most absorbing element of this election season is the spectacle of abortion activists and media analysts grappling with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to spare the life of her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry the father of her unborn child.

As a group of talking heads on television expressed their amazement at the state of the Palin household, I thought of William May, my moral theology professor at the John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, and his penchant for poking holes in the tortured logic of abortion advocates. May could nail the source of abortion supporters’ present discomfort in a nanosecond: Palin’s family choices directly challenge arguments that justify abortion as the “lesser evil.”

Since the ’60s, reproductive rights activists have presented abortion as perhaps the best solution for the scourge of teenage pregnancy, inner-city poverty, gender inequality, and the suffering experienced by disabled infants and their families. But May didn’t buy those arguments: “If abortion is the ‘lesser evil,’” he used to tell our class, “then the alternative — keeping the baby — constitutes the ‘greater evil.’ But how can that position be proved?”

The answer is that it’s impossible to prove that abortion constitutes the “lesser evil.” Catholic moral theologians like May have labored for years to explain both the logical inconsistencies and the moral dangers of the “lesser evil” argument. Now, the Palin family is providing an assist.

Basically, the “lesser evil” argument seeks to weigh, or commensurate, the good and evil consequences of two opposing moral choices.

But May and others argue that this exercise is like comparing apples and oranges. With abortion, the decision is made to terminate nascent human life in order to avoid a worse outcome. According to this equation, bringing the baby to term will produce such disastrous consequences that the good of preserving human life is outweighed by the overwhelming burden of sustaining it. But no abortion advocates have offered an analytical model that will support this utilitarian calculation. In fact, this balancing act is not a precise scientific evaluation, but a reflection of personal beliefs and experience.

The “lesser evil” argument also reveals a scary indifference to the moral evil inherent in the choice to destroy innocent human life. Many pregnant women, unwed or not, can be overwhelmed by the scandal, financial and logistical demands, and threats to personal freedom posed by the arrival of a new child. This argument implicitly assumes the mother can predict the future, and that it will be bleak if her child is brought to term. But this, too, cannot be proved. The future, as we all know, is woefully, or gloriously, unpredictable.

In fact, the “lesser evil” position depends on scary scenarios that can distract the would-be mother from the fundamental moral principle at issue: “You shall not do evil that good shall come of it.”

There was a time when every American child learned that “the ends don’t justify the means.” But since the ’60s, that moral aphorism has been under sustained attack, both within and without the Church. Long before self-described Catholic politicians challenged traditional teaching on abortion, the Church was roiled by the eruption of theological dissent on the morality of married couples using contraception.

The rejection of Humanae Vitae (The Regulation of Birth) depended on a steady stream of sympathetic portraits of married couples struggling to achieve financial and emotional stability by spacing births. Contraception was the “lesser evil.”

During the debate on Humanae Vitae, dissenting theologians advanced two additional arguments to justify the use of contraception. Moral relativism remained the most popular argument — times had changed, and moral absolutes no longer applied. The second argument has been described as the “fundamental option”: “Good” people can occasionally violate moral absolutes without endangering their souls. Good Catholics could contracept, as long as they remained loving parents and spouses. Since then, similar arguments have been employed to justify abortion, sidestepping the decisive way evil actions shape our character and future moral choices.

The three lines of theological dissent pose logical and moral problems. But May also liked to expose the blind spot at the heart of any rejection of moral absolutes. The arid “lesser evil” equation that sentences the unborn child to death ignores the endless possibilities of a human choice that embraces the great good of preserving life.

As Pope John Paul II often noted, the Ten Commandments provide the absolute limit beyond which human behavior cannot descend. But the Decalogue sets no limits on human transcendence. Christians navigate their temporal existence with the aid of a Church that offers the truth that sets us free.

When abortion is off the table, the search for true solutions begins — tightening the household budget, proposing marriage, offering the child for adoption to a childless couple. Catholic moral teaching drives human creativity, inspiring real fruitfulness.

Once declared a settled political question, abortion keeps resurfacing at the center of the political stage. In part, that’s because the debate over abortion is not just about the unborn person’s right to life. It’s also about how we should embrace the vast possibilities of our vocation to love as Christ loves us. How we should live in this world.

Many Americans, Republicans and Democrats will be drawn to the drama of the Palin family. And while neither they nor we know what the future holds, we share their hopes. And who knows? Maybe this election will consign the “lesser evil” argument to the dustbin of history. Professor May would applaud heartily.

Marylander Joan Frawley Desmond writes for a variety of publications on religious and cultural topics.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular