This December 12 the
Catholic Church celebrates the feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe. The image of Mary appeared on the
Tilma, St. Juan Diego’s cape made of maguey plant fibers, in 1531, and can still be seen in Mexico
City. The Mexican Center of Sindonology a couple of years ago donated a copy
of the Tilma to the Diocesan Commission of the Shroud (Turin). The response from Giuseppe Ghiberti,
President of the Commission, and from Bruno Barberis, Director of the International Center of
Sindonology, was one of genuine gratitude. The Commission decided in a recent meeting to keep the
precious replica in the church of the Holy Shroud.
Those who visit this church and behold side by side the two most studied relics in the world may ask
themselves if they really believe in them. Are these images authentic evidence of the miraculous, or
are they just pious paintings for credulous Christians? Although worldwide discussion may never
settle these issues, further consideration of what is known about the Tilma and the Shroud may be
enough to convince individuals one way or the other.
An account of the six apparitions of Our Lady of Guadalupe 9-12 December 1531 is no secret. She told
Juan Diego to have the Bishop build her a church on that hill. Bishop Juan de Zumárraga asked for a
sign to make sure the middle-aged native wasn’t making things up. When Juan Diego collected roses in
his tilma, he was confident that fresh flowers in the winter would be convincing enough. As he
unraveled this garment and let the roses fall to the floor in front of the Bishop, Mary imprinted
her image on the Tilma, which to this day can be seen in the Basilica built at the spot the Blessed
The miracles, however, do not end there.
The plant fibers tilmas are made of wear out after fifty years, but the Tilma of Our Lady has
endured 480 years. For 116 years it was left unprotected from smoke, dust, heat, humidity, and
continual contact with hands and other objects. Not even the accident in 1791, when muriatic acid
fell on the Tilma, nor the terrorist attack in 1921, when a bomb was placed in front of her in a
flower vase, have been able to destroy the Tilma of Guadalupe.
NASA has stated that the image’s colors are not made from any material found
on Earth. A laser that scanned the image even found that the colors float three tenths of a
millimeter in front of the Tilma surface, without touching it.
Microscopic analysis of the pupils of Our Lady of Guadalupe reveals what she
must have seen in the instant her image appeared. She is surrounded by thirteen people. One of these
is clearly identified as Bishop Juan de Zumárraga. Zooming in even more, to the point of examining
the Bishop’s pupils, reveals the spectacle he saw: Juan Diego opening his garment in front of him.
The Virgin exhibits qualities of a living
person, too. Her eyes contract and dilate in response to light and darkness. The temperature of the
Tilma remains stable at 98.6 degrees. A stethoscope has even measured the heartbeats of a baby in
Science has no explanation for such
phenomena. We are talking about something supernatural. Can the same be said about the Shroud of
Turin? Whether the Shroud is an authentic miracle and portrays the image of Jesus Christ is a hot
topic for debate. Even touching on all the points that science, art, and other disciplines have
investigated about the Shroud surpasses the scope of this article. Let it suffice here to mention
some inconsistencies of those who reject its authenticity.
The scientists who performed the carbon-dating tests, taking a sample from a corner of the Shroud
(which in 2005 was acknowledged not to be a representative part of the whole), declared that it must
have been made between 1260 and 1390. Those who say Leonardo da Vinci made the image, however, can
only consider a date during the lifetime of this artist (1452-1519). If one of his paintings matches
it perfectly, that does not prove he was the author of both, but only argues for his exceptional
skill as an artist. Many other paintings, from the 4th century through the 15th, closely resemble
the face of the man of the Shroud. Anyone who has studied this enigmatic object knows there is not a
single drop of paint on it. It even contains three-dimensional information, something not even
photographs are capable of.
For this reason
those who are serious about denying that the man of the Shroud was Jesus resort to the theory that
its falsifier had to scourge and crucify a man in order to get his desired result. Such a dissembler
would have depicted several details of the Passion against an overwhelming consensus of tradition
precedent to his forgery: nails in the wrists, the crown as a helmet, and the body without any
garment, for example. His scientific capacities and intelligence would have had to have been far
ahead of his time, including but not limited to knowledge of photographic negatives, infrared and
ultraviolet light, and a method of imprinting the image. In fact, even today we are yet to discover
exactly how the image was formed. As a result, theories about the formation of the image cannot
presently be tested in laboratories.
facts about the Tilma and the Shroud, no one can remain indifferent. Do all these pieces come
together to form a marvelous puzzle that spells out the word “authentic,” or are they the most
deceiving forgery a malevolent mastermind ever concocted? You decide.
Believers would not hesitate before thanking God for revealing himself and his
Mother to us. The Shroud of Turin can be nothing other than a portrait of Love made concrete in
enduring the cruel torments of the Passion to redeem us from our sins. The Tilma of Guadalupe
complements this manifestation of such divine love with the miraculous image of our Blessed Mother,
Christ’s most precious gift to us, the gift he saved for last. By showing us there are reasons for
our faith, he expresses his loving care in these two images, two images “not made by human hands.”
Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.
|Print Article||Email Friend||Palm Download||Forums||Questions||More in this Channel||Up|
Write a comment on this article|