gabapentin side effects m.s. dosage of bactrim use for chlamydia 4 cytotec 7 semanas de embarazo can you take claritin while taking celexa prednisone for graft vs. host disease does 1199 cover viagra how to take royal jelly with thyroxine how much does atorvastatin cost in the uk amaryl 2mg price adjusting synthroid dose based on tsh lisinopril for opiate withdrawals what antacids are safe with 80 mg atorvastatin bedtime valacyclovir recreational taking sertraline without water accupril and glucophage interaction onde consigo clomid best time of day to take sertraline 25 mg is zovirax cream walmart clopidogrel method of actions ciproheal tablet 500 long term use of cephalexin for dogs how to get my doctor to prescribe me clomid lithium and quetiapine for autism normal dose for singulair can cymbalta withdraw start going from 90mg to 60mg methocarbamol 750 mg back pain cytotec online di jakarta coumadin 40 mg how to get a prescription for doxycycline for my dog pfizer viagra gumtree how long three year old on albuterol and nebulizer doxepin with food or without zoloft zomig flagyl group b strep i take for headaches nortriptyline hcl 10mg is azithromycin still effective if drink next day mirtazapine research in pakistan antietanol disulfiram 250 mg dosage for albuterol one year old tenormin versus inderal paroxetine merken does metronidazole cure stds which is best treatment of chest pain septrin or flagyl metoprolol product information australia can i take 4 5mg cialis at once zithromax iv peds how much would it cost for 5 levaquin pills disulfiram 100mg econazole vs ketoconazole propecia dallas tab norvasc 5mg price in pakistan diflucan 50 mg kapselit synthroid at night time adverse side effects metronidazole can you drink 24 hours after taking azithromycin sito italiano viagra fluconazole secnidazole tablet for lactating mother lexapro pvc lisinopril 2.5 mg used what does atorvastatin look like bioavailability of ondansetron wof?r ist estradiol como tomar cytotec misoprostol via oral cephalexin during conception thyroxine 50 mcg accidental buy propecia without a perscription zestril treatment how often to take augmentin 1g avodart 0 5 mg dutasterida cialis pharmacist prescription drug diflucan makes me horny using cytotec without pregnancy doxycycline side effects and acne ciproxina o translation isotretinoina e cigarro para sirve lasix furosemida 20 mg cialis no prescription discount tadalafil 1.5 mg pricw in india gabapentin uk usos del finasteride neurontin side effects in dogs doxycycline for ferret flagyl papillomavirus how long does it take for diflucan 200 mg to work alternative of viagra india benicar and lupus mayo clinic ciprolex eye and ear drops can i take saw palmetto in conjunction with propecia aldactone vidal eureka olanzapine mepha tetracycline apo 250 diflucan 200 mg for thrush conversion of oral lasix to iv amoxicillin sale uk sertraline makimg me so tired cytotec en buenos aires cuanto cuesta viagra en farmacias can i have wine with metformin como usar las pastillas cytotec a. las dos semanas zoloft sperm damage how to stop allopurinol does ic diltiazem thin blood what does neurontin medication do flagyl 250 pigeon celecoxib capsules uk changing from metoprolol tartrate to succinate cialis ohne rezepte doxycycline overnight no prescription can zoloft cause metallic taste in mouth plavix civil suit order metronidazole uk metoprolol 50 mg para que sirve nizoral risques nebulizer liquid albuterol levofloxacin ornidazole for puppy mobicarte orange etats unis nateglinide tab 60 mg simbalta antidepressant k9 amoxicillin dosage can you cut an ciprofloxacin 500mg pill in half uses of ciprofloxacin do you have to take clomid at the same time each day how does plan b affect seroquel neurontin and trazodone oxytetracycline salep untuk apa erythromycin syrup for 9month old baby diovan hct no prescription lisinopril ranbaxy price in india cephalexin erysipelas thuoc loi tieu aldactone 25mg why is lasix given in the morning daptomycin vs linezolid patente del montelukast amoxicillin and tanning propecia white stripes is it safe to take amoxicillin and benadryl oral acyclovir for viral meningitis valtrex preis cialis daily use one time levofloxacin 500 mg coupon aciclovir crema sirve para herpes genital kamagra 100mg prvedi na srpski amitriptyline 75 mg sleep lexapro and plexus slim lamisil tablets and itching skin why is cialis not working sales manager mobica tenormin mieux que atenolol anafranil prurito tretinoin and doxycycline will keflex help with a sinus infection quarter viagra makes women horny cialis purchase uk can i take piriton with clindamycin antibiotic can prednisone cause tendinitis does doxycycline clear skin zovirax plantar warts paxil presentaciones bactrim ds ip 272 finasteride 1 mg half life synthroid amitriptyline clomipramine for dogs 25 mg price reversal agent for lasix home remedy for poor erectile dysfunction treating acute back pain with prednisone ultimos estudios finasteride maxalt flash can clomid help after depo atarax dosage adults colchicine 1mg prix amoxicillin maximum pediatric doses generic cialis dubai thyroxine digestive system antibiotics toothache 4 years old adalat 5th feb part 2 sony tv will azithromycin eliminate uti lisinopril tinnitus side effects sparfloxacin vs levofloxacin levaquin infusion rate buspar fact does sertraline give you a speed effect terbinafine 750mg pelvic pain ,nausea 3 weeks after taking clomid all about ciprolex tz zithromax bullous myringitis doxycycline 100 iv effect of alcohol on ciprofloxacin para que sirve ivermectina tabletas is cialis 20mg safe for high blood pressure patients 40 mg paxil fluoxetine 50 mg purchase doxycycline tqeovertoz real viagra no prescription mexico weight loss diet pills free viagra list in india fake finasteride india aciclovir 800 mg genfar posologia lamisil 50g short term prednisone use and tapering where i can buy kamagra gold 100 tablet in mumbai levitra e hipertension arterial zithromax 3 comprimidos pre how to write a prednisone 10 day taper olanzapine inn 10 mg buy bactrim cheap can i use amoxil powder to appy on the boils seroquel scadenza brevetto phenergan dose for toddlers synthroid 225 where can i buy lamisil cream why does wellbutrin make cigarettes taste bad propecia buy in australia augmentin prospect romania baclofen tv 4006 can periactin be bought over the counter precio del viagra en farmacias chile xenical orlistat jp does neurontin show up in a 5 panel drug test ou trouver cialis pas cher propecia how long to you see hair benicar 30 mg what company makes generic lipitor does valtrex help herpes heal faster vyvanse cost vs strattera nortriptyline muscle spasms luvox 100 mg precio mexico atorvastatin causes groin pain can you rail sertraline how lasix can lead to hypokalemia infant amoxicillin allergy low testosterone and clomid success febo de maxalto i had to stop taking propecia for a week lexapro elderly birth defects of zoloft ciprofloxacin hcl and amoxicillin how can i know if cialis is fake do drug tests generally test for clonidine levitra generic india linezolid mg lexapro side effects in men tingling amaryl 4 mg fiyat?± how long after taking 10 mg levitra is it effective do benicar cause one to wheeze dosage of fluconazole 150 mg for yeast infection how can we buy misopristol n cytotec in india efectos secundarios montelukast 10 mg vibramycin 50mg 5ml syrup for sale ciprofloxacin dose in neonates organic viagra substitutes azithromycin comprar prescription drug zestril whats in pink viagra prednisone taper 7 days rtl extra priligy cialis kupovina online buy strattera uk online nexium mups 10 mgs cialis federal we ship by fedex danazol prospect amoxicillin 100 mg fluconazole 150 mg how many of these do i take foe gabapentin with clonidine erowid quetiapine 400 mg cost pediatric use of levaquin para que es bueno nexium 20mg esomeprazol does albuterol help with sinus infection cialis compra espa?a zyban quit smoking program nortriptyline,amitryptiline,imipramine costs plavix 300 mg daily plavix platelet count doxycycline antimalarial price bugiardino del voltaren compresse duloxetine cost effectiveness can u take zofran carafate together how long after eating do i have to wait to take viagra what time should i take levaquin can i take zofran while breastfeeding prednisone single dosage can taking lisinopril cause thrush dog im dosage of dexamethasone phosphate zofran dosage toddler can i take 2 cialis 5 mg nortriptyline migraine forum synthroid 25 mg provera in pretoria chemist diovan 90 mg wellbutrin makes me emotional prozac tamoxifen interactions zyloprim pills trazodone 150 mg for sleep viagra testimony xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai reputable propecia online buspar 10mg pills albuterol inhaler dose for dogs nexium cheap generic alternative nexium 24hr acid reducer 42 capsules does buspirone work anxiety st ives invigorating apricot body scrub review phenergan tablets for dogs viagra en asaflow cipro if you miss a dose quando va assunto il viagra plavix sprzedam finasteride crs free 30 day supply of nexium kristine sutherland abilify commercial doxycycline and cefixime tamsulosin tablet in pakistan dosage for 500 mg azithromycin azithromycin antibiotic class can atenolol cause muscle twitching el viagra te excita fludrocortisone conversion tomprednisone antibiotics azithromycin how long can i drink alcohol ciprofloxacin prostata penetration prednisone to treat cellulitis seroquel side effects itchiness amoxicillin 500 mg capsules pl antistaminici e viagra professional viagra cheap when to drink alcohol after finishing doxycycline zoloft kidney stones contraindication of metformin precio misoprostol farmacias chile doxycycline treatment for herpes cialis canada price daily use shoppers drug mart site sure pour acheter du viagra augmentin 400 junior naproxen tablet price levitra tab 20 mg apo atorvastatin is for what lexapro versus zoloft side effects how much nolvadex during cycle metronidazole for squirrels pil cytotec malaysia allopurinol normon dosage of lioresal lexapro and difficulty speaking misoprostol 200 mg precio augmentin bis doze can cymbalta help with p.o.t.s metformin causing muscle pain levofloxacino 500 mg y alcohol efeitos colaterais do finasteride carvedilol 75 zithromax and decongestant will hydrochlorothiazide drain fluid from bursitis hyzaar costco diphenhydramine hcl and buspar atenolol 50mg tablets side effects moduretic costo farmaco vardenafil kaufen paypal mifepristone misoprostol tablets acyclovir during pregnancy fluconazole oral suspension thrush can i take kalms with thyroxine which is stronger cephalexin or amoxicillin olanzapine misuse dosage cialis one day cefixime linezolide injection comprar antibiotico sin receita en santiago ventolin emphysema metformin hcl er weight loss lamisil cream on scrotum productos naturales efecto viagra doxycycline 100mg dosage for chlamydia lexapro for obsessive thoughts keflex estomago prednisone for dogs australia can i buy gonorrhea meds without a prescription keflex avoid alcohol prednisone 50 mg cuanto cuesta for 5 days side effect of inderal 40 nexium 40 mg generic name levocetirizinemontelukast benefits 2.5 levitra did not work pamelor overdose symptoms mobicom trzin

Health Care: Catholics’ 2 Views

Would health-care reform be prayer answered for Catholics? Or is it a disaster waiting to happen? It depends which Catholic expert you ask.
by Tom McFeely | Source:




WASHINGTON -- Would health-care reform be prayer answered for Catholics? Or is it a disaster waiting to happen? It depends which Catholic expert you ask.

Sister Carol Keehan, president of the Catholic Health Association, and Kathy Saile, director of Domestic Social Development for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, both see it as a great opportunity to create a health-care system that provides better care to Americans — and conforms to Church teachings.

But Dr. Steven White, past president of the Catholic Medical Association, sees the situation as a potential crisis.

White, who chaired the task force that produced the CMA's 2004 document, "Health Care in America: A Catholic Proposal for Renewal," warns that a comprehensive reform in the current political context is likely to force Catholic health-care institutions and medical personnel to engage in anti-life activities and transgress against their rights of conscience.

One thing that virtually everyone agrees on is that Catholics should have a major say in the health-care reform process, given that one in every six ill Americans receives care at a Catholic medical institution.

Sister Carol told the Register the CHA believes there is a moral responsibility "to get health-care reform that is worthy of the American people."The CHA's approach to reform is articulated in detail on its website,

Sister Carol said reform must achieve two fundamental objectives: to provide health care equally to everyone, regardless of financial resources or personal circumstances, and to be affordable and efficient in meeting Americans’ health-care needs from conception until natural death.

Only a comprehensive reform of the current system can deliver the CHA's vision, Sister Carol said.

"If we don't get comprehensive reform, we don't get the bang for our buck," she said. "We have gotten past the point where stop-gap measures are adding much."

That opinion is shared by Saile, whose office collaborates closely with the CHA in setting health-care policy priorities.

An article Saile wrote to help guide Catholic voters with respect to health-care issues has been posted on the U.S. bishops’ Faithful Citizenship website,

Saile said reform is likelier to succeed now than in the early 1990s because "there seems to be a much broader consensus in the nation that we need health-care reform."

At the top of the bishops' conference and CHA's list of reform priorities is addressing the health-care insurance needs of the 47 million Americans, mostly low-income, who currently lack medical coverage.

Saile said assigning priority to providing better health care for poor and vulnerable Americans is rooted in the Gospel imperative to continue Jesus’ mission of healing and caring for the "least of these," as articulated in Matthew 25:40.

At the same time, the CHA and the bishops are also stressing that any acceptable health-care reform package must respect the sanctity of life, especially with respect to unborn children.

Another basic priority identified by the U.S. bishops and the CHA is that the health-care system continue to reflect "pluralism." That means both public and private health-care providers, including voluntary, religious and not-for-profit organizations, should continue to participate in the system.

Pluralism also means that differing religious and ethical beliefs of patients and providers should be respected, protecting the freedom of conscience of Catholics to refuse to participate in immoral actions like abortion and sterilization.

Also identified as key by both the CHA and the bishops’ conference is implementing "sound stewardship" principles, in order to make better use of the finite resources available for financing the health-care system.

Currently, health-care costs are increasing much faster than wage gains, and those increased costs are not distributed fairly and effectively among those who fund the system, according to Sister Carol.  

Said Sister Carol, "We feel reform is imperative not only for people with no insurance now, and with no access, but for everybody because, particularly in these economic times, it is eroding any kinds of wage gains people get because their health care goes up so much faster."

Another Perspective

In contrast, the Catholic Medical Association does not support comprehensive health-care reform.

White, a Florida specialist in pulmonary medicine who served as CMA president in 2004-05, said the CMA's health-care reform task force identified three areas of vital concern: defending the sanctity of life, protecting the freedom of conscience of Catholic health-care providers, and protecting the private property rights of individuals to own their own health-care policies.

Today's calls for comprehensive health-care reform are coming primarily from Democrats, whose party platform calls for government-funded abortion and embryonic research, White noted.

The Democratic Party is also more sympathetic than the Republicans to a "single-payer" approach that would see the federal government assuming direct control over most of the health-care system.

Consequently, White said, all three areas of concern that were highlighted by the CMA task force are likely to come under attack if presumptive Democratic nominee Sen. Barack Obama of Illinois becomes president and introduces a comprehensive health-care reform initiative.

Instead of comprehensive reform, the CMA favors an incremental approach that would address the most glaring problems of the current system individually, such as the problem of the uninsured.

And, White said, even in those areas, Catholics should insist that proposed solutions should not be based on a monolithic, government-driven model.

The CMA acknowledges that widespread frustration exists among Americans over the current system's economic problems, White said. And that frustration has led many people, including many Catholics, to conclude the only reasonable approach is to support a comprehensive reform initiative that would grant complete control over the health-care system to the federal government.

But White warned that in practice, that would inevitably result in the imposition of principles that conflict with basic Church teachings regarding the sanctity of life and freedom of conscience.

Said White, “If you promote today a comprehensive solution, and that comprehensive solution is a large, monolithic single-payer system, I would go so far as to say that we would impose the ethic of the culture of death on the entire health-care system.”

Responsible Voting

The U.S. bishops' website gives the following criteria for judging health care plans:

Respect for Life Whether it preserves and enhances human life from conception to natural death.

Priority Concern for the Poor  Whether it gives special priority to health care needs of the poor, ensuring that their health care is quality health care.

Universal Access to Comprehensive Benefits  Whether it provides universal access to comprehensive benefits sufficient to maintain and promote good health.

Pursuing the Common Good and Preserving Pluralism  Whether it allows and encourages the involvement of all sectors, including the religious and voluntary sectors, in all aspects of health care, ensuring respect for the ethical and religious values of consumers and providers.

The bishops refer readers to the 1981 encyclical Laborem Exercens (On Human Work). In it, Pope John Paul II urged that health care be made available and affordable to workers:

"The expenses involved in health care, especially in the case of accidents at work, demand that medical assistance should be easily available for workers," he wrote, "and that as far as possible it should be cheap or even free of charge" (No. 19).

In the 1995 encyclical Evangelium Vitae (The Value and Inviolability of Human Life), Pope John Paul II wrote that "Causing death can never be considered a form of medical treatment, even when the intention is solely to comply with the patient’s request."

He added that "Although laws are not the only means of protecting human life, nevertheless they do play a very important and sometimes decisive role in influencing patterns of thought and behavior. I repeat once more that a law which violates an innocent person’s natural right to life is unjust and, as such, is not valid as a law"(Nos. 89, 90)

Saile said Catholic voters have a responsibility to study the health-care issue and to assign it a high priority when deciding how to cast their ballots in November.

"People need to be very familiar with the candidates’ position on health care,” Saile added. “And they need to be familiar with Catholic teaching on this."

Tom McFeely writes from Victoria, British Columbia.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular