drugs.com prednisone dosage for a puppy ear infection se puede abortar con cytotec en las 17 semanas viagra recommended for young viagra in which stores in los angeles wordsalamode.com can i take necon at the same time as synthroid tab.ketoconazole purchase online mustang sildenafil citrate grandlakehistory.org amitriptyline 35mg what will happen if i take two plavix of 75 what is ciprofloxacin 250 mg used for what will happen if you take 750mg of metoprolol if you mix lortab and viagra will viagra still work andrijastepic.renianstudio.com why mirtazapine if a drug is discontinued mitsuifinearts.com atorvastatina tem na farmacia popular can i use the quit smoking patch while taking paxil order propecia fedex azithromycin cost without insurance walgreens phenergan syrup purchase online in india will carvedilol cause herpes outbreaks can 150 mg fluconazole cure uti sigmalogic.eu pandahomecare.com wpodrozy.eu bdxmen.com venlafaxine, seroquel trep 100 mg andysternberg.com augmentin 875 vs curam purchase topamax online no prescription can you take singulair with zyprexa ciprotab and alcohol wat biotech ciprofloxacin 500 used 4 if you take cipro 500 mg will 6 pills cure gonorehea candida lamisil cost of singulair tablets fluconazole 150 mg price uk mazowsze.waw.pl westwoodhomesinc.com black seed for erection zofran 7236 itch went away when i started sertraline maxalt price comparison sa lisinopril lethal dose kamagra dangers haciendahotel-oldtown.com cat got bad teeth can can i buy antibiotics how much cymbalta will kill you nifedipine and sildenafil price of singulair in walmart tadalafil calox en hombres sanos 1001.org generic cialis 20 bellasera 25 mg zoloft is amoxil beecham safe in pregnancy theartofmarketing.com 150mg clomid can lead pregnancy ncsdsample2.docbro.com bactrim in the morning wine at night chloramphenicol eye drops dogs side effects does generic lipitor work as well as lipitor can you take night nurse with amoxicillin buy clozapine antibiotic azithromycin untuk apa misoprostol in south africa prices diovan 80 mg tablet farmacocinetica del prazosin voltaren sr 75 tablets levofloxacin 500 mg ingredients metronidazole iv frequency celebrex where taken flimed at ondansetron odt 4mg while pregant ciprofloxacin tab in tird first trimester celexa 5 mg side effects toddler with tenal failure after taking amoxicillin teco levofloxacin side day 7 on bupropion nexium facebook 5mg citalopram anxiety can u get high from baclofen carvedilol and vicodin interaction 8 yeras old antibiotic ml duloxetine hidrocloride 20mg and bupropion xl 3000mg can i combin flagyl and ampicillin to treat uti edgewaterstudio.com nexium na gravidez mylon ondansetron 8mg price in india sigmalogic.eu toughfurniture.com zovirax for prostate floraphotographs.com success rate for men on serophene doxycycline to treat srep pneumonia dexamethasone 3a4 how much is misoprostol in cebu clomid folic acid for twins asyras2013.espora.es dexamethasone 12 mg pregnancy can you take flagyl and monistat pregnant how much accutane 5 mg per day how long does sertraline take to work how many days does gabapentin withdrawal last when do i start taking clomid to regulate my period side effects of buspirone 20 mg paroxetine cost without insurance atorvastatin 10 mg pt mitsuifinearts.com naprosyn sr image can you take esomeprazole with colpermin carvedilol 50 mg twice daily how long do 500mg of valtrex take to heal a cold sore learninc.org chinaskinny.com tetracycline hcl untuk apa thebestkindofdifferent.com local brands of clozapine in pakistan is carvedilol a narcotic bioequivalence xenical zovirax price walmart arr.czestochowa.pl rf5.org singulair 10 mg poviral acyclovir untuk jerawat misoprostol uk do buspirone and zyrtec interaction does buspar affect sperm diflucan reviews candida cobre2013.cl metronidazole 750mg serophene 2 por dia how long can one erection last after taking maxman pill ftortho.net diflucan and birth control cyproheptadine dogs appetite doxycycline can i not sunbathe what else can i do louielouie.net amoxilin and potassium clavulanate 650mg for flu stem.neu.edu discount cialis no prescription melvilleauthor.com ciprodex manufacturer coupon buy clopidogrel bisulfate can nursing cats take prednisone will lamisil cure poison ivy cordarone online dapoxetine pharma bd does cialis for daily use really work reasons levitra would not work nearion.com buy orlistat cheap online can amitriptyline stop wet dreams accutane after 7 months septra dosage cystitis luvox 150 mg clopidogrel tablet lp 75mg westwoodhomesinc.com can u takevcialis problems with blood thinners side effects of lasix il why is generic ondansetron so expensive theorientalhotels.com tab atenolol can be given in rbbb gabapentin 300 mg with endocin yagbank.com where can i get amoxicillin over the counter uk augmentin fa dimagrire floryakurye.com.tr nexium 24 hour over the counter vs pescription mexium lexapro 20 mg best price levitra in saudi arabia buy verapamil cream did clomid work with vitamin e dose doxycycline hyclate 100 m dogs lyme disease chengdong.net prednisone and pregnancy third trimester will 200mg of seroquel get me high metronidazole 500 mg bid 7 days trazodone 433 street value hot flashes paxil withdrawal chatapropo.info buildingsonfire.com bellesthailand.com punkfiction.com frequency of diarrhea on zoloft dctourguideonline.com allegra costco generic arroyograndecc.com groganstudios.com rf5.org what tube color.does.digoxin test augmentin 600 es fiyat?± can you take diflucan 4 days apart uses of metronidazole 400mg in bilharzia treatment niagarajazzfestival.com cuanto cuesta cytotec farmacia colombia misoprostol in louisiana using sertraline and escitalopram together purchase levitra 20mg prozac 20 mg capsule human ivermectin tablets for dogs in india super tetra tetracycline hcl nexium 24 hr cost bt.sklep.pl behavioral problems with wellbutrin xl versus sr oeufspolis.com alexcitypr.com debtspecialistcentre.com mix size cream for erection sale in australia sertraline hcl 50 mg for pain mercury drug price of metronidazole cream maxalt rizatriptan melt 10mg prices redzigaismu.lv azithromycin dosage for throatpain floraphotographs.com usian.org azithromycin 500 mg ingredients elavil and flexeril overdose where to buy misoprostol in sa taking fluoxetine tab 20mg andbuprop 24xl together inasweets.com is it possible to overdose on amoxicillin priligy basso costo generic lipitor and muscle pain warfarin rat poison for sale voltaren resinat cena price of mispristone and misoprostol cytotec in india can you take nexium with zithromax lamisil gel cost is flomax a diuretic bengbeng.de atenolol australian prescriber newworldfoods.ca does taking thyroxine affect prednisone generic montelukast uk am1320.com does zofran come over the counter lethal dose of buspar accutane 5 mg how to use viagra spray in telugu how long does it take for flagyl to knock out a uti use of misoprostol without pregnancy ryman.pl amitriptyline hcl 10mg for sleep lisinopril 10 mg drug metronidazole buy for rosacea angellsangels.com can you snort trazodone 150 mg how to test for the effectiveness of plavix periactin syrup appetite stimulant kalmethasone piroxicam aatif.lu finasteride fake pakistan para que sirbe terbinafine hcl current price for ciprotab 750mg in nigeria chemist erythromycin dose gi motitility bengbeng.de gubljenje apetita od lexapro tableta nursing care plan warfarin overdose mightyrabbitstudios.com metoprolol tart 100mg tab leg themetrogalleries.com ebusiness-lab.gr deserteichler.com is it safe to take ondansetron past expiration date clozapine titration for parkinson male yeast infection treatment diflucan ftortho.net timminsfamilycounselling.com newworldfoods.ca firsttimetravels.com dws-xip.pl sekerpinarosgb.com 80 mg prednisone for 10 days for allergic dermatitis viagra for sale in gibralter dws-xip.pl how much diws maxalt rpd cost can premarin be used to stop nose bleeds ampicillin gamot pang palaglag grandlakehistory.org buy generic lamisil tablet chengdong.net stop taking zyban abruptly viagra stamina tablet 100 power price nagpur buy generic propecia clozaril 500mg andretti.pl fluconazole label for dogs edgewaterstudio.com where to buy fluconazole over the counter for tooth infection how many days of 500mg amoxicillin doxycycline hyclate leptospirosis cialis has stopped working for me steroids and on prozac erythromycin 250 two tablets 4 times a day gabapentin 100 mg withdrawal symptoms webbrowsers.lv viagra 50mg price uk cipro uti kills bacteria azithromycin cost rite aid gabapentin rash side effect lyrcia better apakah ciprofloxacin 500 mg avastan.pl amoxicillin sirup medroxyprogesterone 10 mg me puede tomar 3 treatment for plavix bruising calculate synthroid dose in pregnancy ear drops for perforated eardrum and ciprofloxacin does cipro 500 makes your periods to be late or change accutane 2 weeks indikasi acyclovir cream 10g celexa 10mg flagyl iv drip price in pakistan citalopram walgreens com liquid nyscaa.org dextromethorphan hydrobromide australia augmentin bis ampicillin for finger infection can cymbalta or lyrica cause pancreatitis what antidepressant works best trazodone po 50mg tab street value floraphotographs.com can a nebulizer with albuterol be use on a 3yr old mercadodefichajesfutbol.com iced propranolol augmentin paediatric syrup in india brand provera 60 mg plavix and krill interactions and side effects cppd caused by antibiotics levitra cialis viagra online how can i get metronidazole for my dog over the counter roaccutane doxycycline drug interaction taars.org baclofen foro rf5.org dapoxetine drug availabel in egypt till-landry.com how quickly does prednisone work pinched nerve long term use of ciprofloxacin in dogs why monitor vitamin k when taking digoxin can you smoke the pill buspar diovan valsartan user review telmisartan 120 mg pharmacokinetics iphone5sreview.nl can 30 pills of 20 mg citalopram kill yoi erectial powder form buy zovirax online uk finasteride gynecomastia vs avodart have do you wein off buspirone dietary restrictions argatroban doxycycline 100 mg for dog urinary track infection amoxicillin overdose for 1 year old kids levofloxacin get high cheap propecia tablets zovirax 400 mg price cialis cant have orgasm marashthermal.com kikkaskitchen.com learninc.org how long do side effects last after taking flagyl thomaskingsleytroupe.com a1commerce.com citalopram and insomnia nhs pil lasix furosemide obat apa ya 2exhibitions.com side effects of zofran long term effects cap.org.py danoday.com amoxicillin oral suspension buy canada thepointofcare.com which is stronger risperidone or buspirone 10 mg prednisone a day indomethacin 50 mg whats it for arilarotokiralama.com method of analysis for ciprofloxacin tablet 500mg augmentin bid 1000 mg film tablet avodart for hair loss uasa.co.za does bactrim work for an infected tattoo synthroid pronunciation which is better 40 mg citalopram or 20 mg escitalopram augmentin 1000 duo used for makan medroxyprogesterone 2.5mg lisinopril proscar online pharmacy chamber.md how much is azithromycin at walgreens lexapro online 5mg what does cipro denk 500 cure berapa harga premarin di indonesia obat amaryl glimepiride isoptin khk retard mobilestoreoperators.com vibramycin in brazil when did lexapro come out in generic form generic accutane online price difference between cialis 5 mg and 20 mg do ponstan or augmentin interact with mirena amoklavin flagyl shelf life propecia cheap meltabs viagra price of augmentine 625 does valium help 7.5 remeron kicks in 3 months propecia can metronidazole clear spotting in pregnancy how many days does it take eye zovirax to work 20m viagra lisinopril 5 mg uk is a side effect of 5mg norvasc nosebleeds yagbank.com can you take 5 milligrams of prednisone with theraflu que pasa si uso cytotec y tengo 4 meses de una cesarea cgstudionyc.com buy levitra with paypal fluid retention with metformin where to buy azithromycin in united states buy bactrim 800 mg online does metformin cause prostate cancer weight gain in lexapro levofloxacin 1000 mg tablet name price brand is cheese safe with sertraline neurontin 5 htp doxepin cream rate in pakistan does ciprodex numb where can i buy genox tamoxifen in australia does bupropion xl 150 mg help you lose weight gratisdiscotecas.com rantical.com linezolid price colombia propranolol 10 mg used for removing scars content-catalyst.com citalopram hbr 40 mg and pregnancy nausea after finishing amoxicillin chlamydia treatment azithromycin can i masterbate planificationprojets.com discharge with metronidazole gel kegunaan danocrine tablet sigmalogic.eu americangovernor.com finasteride cheapest are grapefruits good for diabetics taking glimepiride coughing lisinopril and snoring lisinopril mood swings prednisone for rash dosage weaning off seenonstage.pl doxycycline for bronchitis walking pneumonia die-liedertafel.de viagra how to 100mg one time eating can can u take topamax and nuzak together unitedreporters.com obat rexil piroxicam untuk apa can you use fluconazole for mold poisoning themetrogalleries.com fluoxetine 9342 meccanicanova.com chizeaphockey.com 5x5.hu does cipro ivax treat stds metronidazole for males pills for sale coffee7.com doxycycline indonesia hydroxyzine hcl 20mg ciprodar 500 obat untuk amiodarone 900 berapa harga azithromycin dihydrate magnano-tech.com kamagra oral jelly legal in us erythromycin prep available in india melvilleauthor.com clopidogrel 75 mg quanto costa estradiol level 6000 groganstudios.com generic erythromycin ointment timminsfamilycounselling.com ciprodex on cats ears apo clopidogrel 75 mg side effects can i take benadryl with acyclovir misoprostol en uruapan syphilis zithromax dosage metformin nutrient depletion webbrowsers.lv huafengcreative.com do metronidazole gel used for diabetic foot can you give stromectol tablets to dogs ic quetiapine fumarate to buy antibiotics tablet in usa is ibruprofen 400mg safe to take with tamoxifen dctourguideonline.com flecainide and cardizem interactions stockists of xenical in durban south africa sweetcheekshq.com avapro 100 mg yagbank.com cytotec tablets 200 mcg amoxil 400 mg chewable clomid philippines price mazowsze.waw.pl xenical for sale philippines doxycycline is good antibiotic for chest infection glucophage xr 750 precio

A Great Battle for Love and the Family

"Humanae Vitae" at 40.
by Father Walter Schu, LC | Source: NCRegister.com

On July 29, 1968, a crescendo of suspense was broken and Pope Paul VI publicly issued his long-awaited encyclical Humanae Vitae (The Regulation of Birth).

In the encyclical, the Holy Father courageously reaffirmed the Church’s constant teaching that, in the words of the encyclical, “each and every marriage act must remain open to the transmission of new life” (No. 11).

It caused a firestorm.

Within 24 hours, in an event unprecedented in the history of the Church, more than 200 dissenting theologians signed a full-page ad in The New York Times in protest. Not only did they declare their disagreement with encyclical’s teaching; they went one step further, far beyond their authority as theologians, and actually encouraged dissent among the lay faithful.

They asserted the following: “Therefore, as Roman Catholic theologians, conscious of our duty and our limitations, we conclude that spouses may responsibly decide according to their conscience that artificial contraception in some circumstances is permissible and indeed necessary to preserve and foster the values and sacredness of marriage.”

Among Catholic laity, Humanae Vitae was also greeted with consternation. A Gallup survey done less than a month after the encyclical was promulgated showed that of those Catholics who had heard of it, only 28% agreed with the Pope’s teaching. Fifty-four percent disagreed with the Pope explicitly; others refused to assent.

Even among bishops, the encyclical was often received with what could hardly be described as an ardent embrace in obedience and faith. On Sept. 27, 1968, the bishops of Canada, united in plenary assembly at St. Boniface in Winnipeg, Manitoba, issued a declaration on Humanae Vitae that has come to be known as the Winnipeg Statement.

Oddly enough, the statement does not use the term “contraception” even once, substituting instead the euphemism “any positive intervention that would prevent the transmission of human life” (No. 8). Still, the statement seems to be headed in the right direction, as it acknowledges the magisterium’s right to pronounce itself on the question of the responsible regulation of births, along with the duty of the faithful to form their consciences according to that teaching.

But then, No. 26 makes its appearance, in which all of the above is thrown to the winds:

“Counselors may meet others who, accepting the teaching of the Holy Father, find that because of particular circumstances they are involved in what seems to them a clear conflict of duties, e.g., the reconciling of conjugal love and responsible parenthood with the education of children already born or with the health of the mother. In accord with the accepted principles of moral theology, if these persons have tried sincerely but without success to pursue a line of conduct in keeping with the given directives, they may be safely assured that, whoever honestly chooses that course that seems right to him does so in good conscience” (italics added).

In other words, the Canadian bishops affirmed that Catholics may in good conscience choose to disregard Humanae’s Vitae’s teaching on the intrinsic evil of contraception (found in the encyclical’s No. 14).

Subjectivism of conscience has become the new, supreme law. Aside from the truth of responsible procreation, what teaching of the faith at all is capable of standing against this new norm of unbridled subjectivism?

Pope John Paul II’s ardent defense of the truth of married love rings out in sharp contrast to the Winnipeg Statement: “Contraception is to be judged so profoundly unlawful as never to be, for any reason, justified. To think or to say the contrary is equal to maintaining that in human life, situations may arise in which it is lawful not to recognize God as God” (L’Osservatore Romano, Oct. 10, 1983, p. 7).

Many groups of Catholic lay faithful have been urging the Canadian bishops to retract the Winnipeg Statement and affirm their complete adherence to Humanae Vitae.

The Austrian bishops had the courage to withdraw their own 1968 statement on March 29, 1988, and to announce their complete agreement with Humanae Vitae, as well as John Paul II’s apostolic exhortation Familiaris Consortio (The Role of the Christian Family in the Modern World).

In 1990, the Philippine bishops issued an apology to that nation’s Catholics for having failed to encourage their flock to adhere to Humanae Vitae.

They wrote: “Afflicted with doubts about alternatives to contraceptive technology, we abandoned you to your confused and lonely consciences with a lame excuse: ‘Follow what your conscience tells you.’ How little we realized that it was our consciences that needed to be formed first.”

How did the U.S. bishops react to Pope Paul VI’s courageous encyclical?

Publicly, they rushed to support the Holy Father, asking the lay faithful to do the same. On July 31, 1968, Archbishop John Deardon of Detroit, president of the U.S. bishops’ conference declared: “Recognizing his [Pope Paul VI’s] unique role in the universal Church, we, the bishops of the Church in the United States, unite with him in calling upon our priests and people to receive with sincerity what he has taught, to study it carefully and to form their consciences in its light.”

Still, when the bishops distributed the English edition of Humane Vitae, attached to it were norms for theological dissent.

How could such a situation have arisen: theologians, laity, even bishops in a firestorm of dissent from the definitive, binding teachings of the Holy Father?

To understand the reaction to Humanae Vitae, it is necessary to consider the drama leading up to the encyclical. A principal element in that drama was the sexual revolution.

By the summer of 1968, the sexual revolution was in full swing, both in the United States and Western culture. What was the dominant ideology of the sexual revolution? It was the attempt to “liberate” sexuality from the “repressive” confines of commitment.

It was the effort to truncate the meaning of sex to personal pleasure through ecstatic release. The attempt was made to obliterate the transcendent, personal dimension of sexual intercourse as a free self-giving of the entire person in love.

What was sought was love without responsibility, pleasure without the gift of self.

Catholics were often swept away with the rest of the population in this new hedonism and the illusory freedom it proffered.

A national study done in 1955 revealed that only 30% of Catholic wives were using contraception. A similar study in 1965 showed the following: “53% of Catholic wives aged 18 to 39 were either presently using a forbidden means of contraception or had done so in the past.”

By 1970, fully 68% of Catholic wives in their childbearing years were limiting their families by a means other than abstinence or natural family planning.

What was at stake in the firestorm of dissent with which Humane Vitae was greeted and in the drama leading up to its reception?

In his 1994 Letter to Families, John Paul II affirmed that “the family is placed at the center of the great struggle between good and evil, between life and death, between love and all that is opposed to love.”

Many different forces enter into that struggle. But at its very core is the ideology of contraception.

Legionary Father Walter Schu is author of The Splendor of Love on John Paul II’s theology of the body, a course for couples of Familia. wschu@legionaries.org

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular