floryakurye.com.tr kamagra oral jelly reviews fluoxetine amphetamine vidal meloxicam para que sirve addictedtoallthingspretty.com camerata.com amoxicillin trihydrate 500mg for sinus infection zoloft vs celexa anxiety gabapentin serotonin syndrome can you split 5mg of zyprexa cialis canada pharmacy online septran ds doses available in pakistan generic lexapro coupon ikoa-f.com albuterol dosage for for three year old venta de pastillas cytotec en caracas venezuela is singulair chewable over the counter ciprofloxacin hc ear drops down a tracheostomy is promethazine syrup phenergan gives to 9 month baby strattera 100 effects albuterol sulfate nebu sobrietybyyourside.com metformin for bipolar disorder lotensin 10 cena diltiazem 90 mg tab teva where can i buy nexium cheap bdxmen.com clomiphene citrate 50 mg buy uk viagra 50 dlm bhs indonesia can zovirax aciclovir cream genital herpes vagina duloxetine medicines in pakistan zofran 8 mg oral tablet 1001.org escitalopram 40 mg daily dunnacupuncture.com azithromycin for kittens dosage haas.com.pl baclofen benadryl mix biovail zovirax sample for physician en que se utiliza la ciprofloxacin 500mg is 600 mgs of bupropion hcl sr to mubh to take amoxicillin gluten free levaquin 500 mg dosage sinus infection how to counter the effects of prednisone harga esomeprazole astrazeneca where to buy cytotec in davao city westwoodhomesinc.com theorientalhotels.com order propecia through bosley nifedipine 10 mg sen csitdurg.in advantagegolfcars.com para que sirve clomiphene citrate 150mg cheapest cialis au learninc.org cialis how long till hits withdrawal symptoms from paxil in the elderly shelf life for septra suspension cardaffairs.com buy dog antibiotic eyedrop uk is 500 mg antibiotics too strong for a 12 year old does viagra keep you erect xenical ubat kurus buspirone hcl 10mg white teva reviews anxiety eu-atp.org what to do if taken overdose of synthroid amoxicillin is commonly used for what diflucan ringworm dosage how to come off celexa safely does cymbalta cause dilated pupils levofloxacin 500 in typhoid treatment in india nitroglycerin .4 sl how much would bupropion cost for 7 weeks harnal ocas tamsulosin hydrochloride women montelukast 10 mg dosage hhpz.org walmart oral phenergan medicine price fluconazole 150 for ringworm lexapro for ibs ywdtx.com can u get high off of mirtazapine 45 mg of snort them timminsfamilycounselling.com gabapentin and high blood sugar lineofoslo.no sside effects compared lasix torsemide bumetanide steroids cycles and finasteride can it stop strength purchase lexapro canada gabapentin 300mg 5027 how do lexapro concerta and buspar mix isotretinoin cost comparison eu-atp.org arroyograndecc.com misoprostol nursing responsibilities doxycycline hyclate 20 mg for dogs ebusiness-lab.gr medicines for std without prescription in hyderabad captionedit.com how much is clomiphene in the philippines cabergoline 500 mcg should i take lisinopril 7.5 mg termitepestsolutions.com side effects of increaseing celexa from 5mg to 10mg how to make ampicillin 50 mg ml does metformin cause prostate cancer prednisone 10 mg dose pack side effects 4kom.it carlosfloresmusic.com quetiapine fumarate jak buy doxycycline from canada 20mg levitra dosage is terbinafine contraindindicated with alprazolam irbesartan 300mg hctz in india olanzapine 6 mg can you drink alcohol after azithromycin 500 mg kamagra online australia zoloft and swollen knee pain upperbe.it nizoral 2 cream ingredients amoxicillin why does it taste like poison duloxetine uncontrollable crying tofranil kullananlar can synthroid and metformin help you lose weight launchpoker.com buy lexapro with no prescription how many days after flagyl taking the effect accutane de vanzare liceoagnoletti.it montelukast plus acebrophylline chizeaphockey.com grandlakehistory.org verapamil no prescription managedent.ca stop bupropion tongue sores how long to go away acyclovir salep untuk jerawat waterfrontalehouse.com clomid twins gender buy zithromax pills stopping prometrium at 9 weeks baclofen cost walmart exercise and clomid does celebrex cancel out birth control antibiotics and breast milk dws-xip.pl filmarray.com flomax and yeast infections can a person with afib take cialis molecular structure esomeprazole magnesium dihydrate ywdtx.com hansrajcollege.info metronidazole 500mg and alcohol arrow meloxicam tamoxifen and running nose carvedilol 6.25 price co sertraline and nursing topamax online how long does celebrex take to work doxycycline hyclate is good open capsule diflucan fluconazole buy online fda approved indication of atorvastatin generic cialis soft tabs benazepril 40 mg reviews best price on cialis 5mg can you take esomeprazole with colpermin how long after taking cipro can you drink alcohol time dependent antibiotics ppt potency of old viagra tablets diet pill approved 30 mgs prednisone ivf diltiazem 60 mg pret bupropion 150 mg price millionaire-meena.com vibrancetech.net can azithromycin dihydrate affect your menstrual cycle cytotec 600 mg buy strattera 100 mg metronidazole for yeast infection in dogs siwe.be rf5.org cialis dosage 5mg or 10mg flagyl indications for 8 years old serviciosarcom.com can i take to much diflucan lemurialifecoaching.com arroyograndecc.com daisylcreations.com antifungals with terbinafine costo de cytotec lasix side effects with viagra where can i buy priligy tablets in kolkata dirtbiker.cz irregular period clomid 18 days last period which is better for anger effexor or bupropion buy albuterol sulfate does nizoral shampoo lower testosterone in the body generic viagra rx que es mejor meloxicam o celebrex is benadryl safe with phenergan for dogs prostatitis levofloxacin antibiotics isoptin retard 240 pret ciprofloxacn ear infection 10 year old gel generic tab viagra usian.org metronidazole hinta can bactrim give myoclonus nexium plus para que sirve kegunaan obat ciprofloaxin firsttimetravels.com telmisartan generic philippines valtrex cold sore dosage lasix 40 mp iv equivalent to po will sildenafil tablets show up in a drug test seroquel 25mg cost walgreens gabapentin street value can zithromax 250 mg cure gonorrhea learninc.org will a quetiapine 200 get me high do chinese herbs effect lexapro withdrawal zum.no wal mart cost long term side effects of pamelor eu-atp.org inasweets.com arimidex on test e dosagw cost of esomeprazole suspension metronidazole side effectswalmart how much is propecia at walmart westwoodhomesinc.com yogaindailylife.org rizatriptan benzoate 10mg price iaspm2013.espora.es dose burst for prednisone floraphotographs.com diflucan yeast infection men how long to work fluconazole unguent moldova pret efectos despues de usar cytotec glucophage clorhidrato de metformina cialis quick delivery beda ketoconazole dan miconazole mekanisme ondansetron ssri drug interaction tamiflu and phenergan cuanto cuesta cytotec en merida yucatan price of generic orlistat in the philippines nexium vs omepron take 2 5mg. cialis one day skip one day tedmitew.com kamagra oral jelly uk next day delivery ingredients of erythromycin mazowsze.waw.pl bengbeng.de lexapro dosage 60 coumadin 5 mg tablet fiyat?± are all the finasteride tablets same anaheimangelsjersey.com atorvastatin tadalafil cost of cialis at cvs jwalkny.com clomid when to take pregnancy test cymbalta back pain reviews warfarin sodium 2.5mg interacting with meloxicam. 15 mg zoladex plus nolvadex lekovi can i take viagra with diltiazem cordarone 150 mg 6 amp wordsalamode.com buy cialis online no prescription uk misoprostol cytotec buy generic acyclovir no prescription is trustan the generic for nexium multi-monety.pl lasix 20 mg side effects so-sc.org narrative.in amoxicillin gran 250mg mixing generic viagra and singulair benicar 20 mg tablet meccanicanova.com carpetandfloors.co.uk break prednisone in syllables mirtazapine 7.5mg 15mg different zovirax for cold sore at 36.weeks pregnant buy viagra with no prescription buspar plus lexapro para que sirce el ciprofloxacino over the counter albuterol inderal 40 mg tabletten chinyee.cc buy zovirax ointment online sildenafil cost per pill lyrica versus gabapentin neurontin lower back pain azithromycin 1 gram oral packet advantagegolfcars.com compare generic viagra price enteric coated doxycycline brand pct nolvadex clomid dosage haciendahotel-oldtown.com can i give my dog amoxicillin 400 mg 40mg of prednisone for 9 year old can ciprofloxacin affect my microgynon pill how long does singulair take to work for urticaria thearcofnovatrust.com buy lamisil tablets uk buy prozac online usa are azithromycin tablets chewable withdrawal from prednisone symptoms augmentin bustine prezzo ciprone tablet for what amitriptyline hydrochloride 25 mg street value 500mg dispersible amoxicillin dosage instructions how long does it take avapro to get in your system les effets secondaires lopressor provera puede tomar licor liquid flagyl medicine for sale erythromycin pregnancy australia increased mucus with lisinopril es compatible anafranil en el embarazo decadron cube what would happen if u snort ondansetron millionaire-meena.com montelukast chewable para que es twospy.com que es misoprostol si funciona cuando tienes 6 semanas antibiotics next day delivery uk premarin cream breast enlargement lexapro generic available when buildingsonfire.com is bactrim ds 800 160 safe while breastfeeding skipping inactive pills in mircette zyprexa po to im conversion bactrim nausea fatigue cheapest substitute of azithromycin wellbutrin xl how long to work mirtazapine es bueno low dose paxil 1000 mg metoprolol a day thecottonfilm.com where can i buy diflucan from mexico cipla cialis review what is the ideal dosage for mirtazapine and duloxetine nolvadex 20mg sterilite masculine viagra vision side effects perbedaan amoxilin dengan tramadol trazodone capsules in insomnia cost of flagyl medication fungsi digoxin o5 mg difference in 50g viagra and 100g viagra faunaforever.org lineofoslo.no does azithromycin make you retain fluid metformin 7267 jual misoprostol cytotec di solo diflucan foe jock itch and yeast infection pastile kamagra gold can you give bactrim and flagyl together and dogs generics for cardizem 360mg asyras2013.espora.es tamsulosin interstitial cystitis bad side effects berenboom.com chinaskinny.com fluconazole and itraconazole images watson bupropion makes my jaw clench ebusiness-lab.gr does prednisone 50 mg make you high atarax 2 mg ml annostus cialis maintenance dosage double gauntletpress.com erythromycin 2 gel price erythromycin syrup ritemed images of lamisil bd cream azithromycin price mercury drug store estrace vs premarin cost nexiumcostco and nexium generic drug benicar hct hanhvyshop.vn ampollas feldene 500 mg para que son provera 60 mg ok to take motrin after prednisone 20mg can 1 capsule of vibramycin delay period wer can i get viagra tablet plavix 7 5 does doxycycline come in 40mg arroyograndecc.com launchpoker.com trip report luvox albuterol sulfate safe during pregnancy ebay zovirax stendhal.com prazosin 5 mg nizoral for white heads vibramycin for sale nyscaa.org can you buy metformin 500 mg over the counter in usa amoxicillin 500 mg exp. date du hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg kegunaan salp metronidazole berenboom.com can you use premarin with cholestrol tablets amoxicillin online next day delivery online viagra ordering propranolol 40 mg inpanol am1320.com vpdcorp.com can 5 days on septra ds for abscess have back pain after using clomid 50mg wordsalamode.com alcohol and amoxicillin and c diff kamagra oral jelly tschechien 6 day burst prednisone can you take advil and cialis atorvastatin en espanol learninc.org weaning off 10mg lexapro side effects of zithromax in adults propecia cheap finasteride eu-atp.org if i take 20 celexa can i overdose conjugated linoleic acid 9 11 phenergan for 8 year old cymbalta 60 mg vs 90 mg bactrim for strep throat dosage 283858.com asi.wpgsystem.com terbinafine how long to work quetiapine rbx lexapro hair loss tbr.pl theburgeradventure.com refineyourfeel.com marontech.com.my how much does cymbalta cost in the uk launchpoker.com sunrise remedies india generic propecia augmentin 1.2g clonidine hcl 0.1 mg tablet make me hungry toxic dose of augmentin 875 daily what happens when you first start zoloft yahoo webworksandgraphics.com effect of fluconazole on menstrual period revue-pto.com contraindicado atenolol con chikungunya advantagegolfcars.com actionbinaire.net ventline hfa vs albuterol naplulizer 2.5 andysternberg.com chatapropo.info hiding azithromycin in food wac price zyvox 2exhibitions.com how much can cytotec cost in za norvasc 5 mg 30 tablet fiyat?± how long does 100 mg zoloft how much does paxil cost denimandlace.ca generic seroquel makes me tired how long does buspirone take to work 17 alpha ethinyl estradiol bnf prescription price lisinopril anafranil 10mg dolorgiet accutane 50mg can mucinex be taken with citalopram doxycycline monohydrate use for insect bites voltaren tabletten 500mg desyrel 100 yan etkileri metformin 4000 mg per day nitroglycerine varients available in kerala synthroid no prescription cheap childlabor-payson.org lexapro pooped out pristiq anxiety nizoral pills for treating pityrosporum folliculitis fluconazole 400 mg iv sapp flex proactivelogic.com topiramate 50 mg price can i take a pregnancy test while on metronidazole arimidex without steroids propecia 84 compresse zovirax 200 mg uses buy albuterol capsules 8mg uk bodybuilding can you take avodart every other day doxycycline acne mercury drug cozaar medication cost edgewaterstudio.com dws-xip.pl thesoundalarm.com how to stop taking inderal feldene 40 mg inyectable arroyograndecc.com online viagra 100mg antidepressants droopy face is maxalt 10 mg a narcotic lifesaverpoolfencesofnevada.com orlistat 120mg bula premarin cream breast enlargement can u take zopiclone with synthroid stdennischurch.org valor del zofran en drogas la rebaja cali does phenergan come in pill form puedo tomar alcohol y levaquin ftortho.net glucophage xr 250 phenergan iv infiltration antidote hanhvyshop.vn cuanto dura cytotec para hacer efecto buy cheap amitriptyline

A Commentator's Role

Inappropriate tasks Commentators must avoid.
by Father Edward McNamara, LC | Source: Catholic.net

Question: Can you provide any insight into the role of the commentator? The commentator is quite common here in the United States, and every church seems to have a different job description for this person. For example, in our parish before the start of Mass the commentator greets the people, asks if anyone is celebrating a birthday or anniversary or is visiting. Then there is the usual happy birthday or anniversary song. Then the commentator gives a 5- to 6-minute reflection and words of advice for the coming week. During the Mass the commentator sits in the sanctuary; directs the people via hand signals whether to sit, kneel, rise; calls out the music/song that we will be singing, etc. At the end of Mass, before the final benediction he/she reads the announcements; gives comments and their take on the homily; and thanks the people, etc. I have suggested this is taking the role of "commentator" a bit too far, but cannot find anything in the GIRM to help back up my claim. Can you help? -- M.P., Keaau, Hawaii

Answer: I think you are correct that this is taking the role of commentator a bit too far.

The liturgical function of the commentator is described, along with that of sacristans, ushers, and those who take up the collection, in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, No. 105:

“The commentator […] provides the faithful, when appropriate, with brief explanations and commentaries with the purpose of introducing them to the celebration and preparing them to understand it better. The commentator's remarks must be meticulously prepared and clear though brief. In performing this function the commentator stands in an appropriate place facing the faithful, but not at the ambo.”

No. 352 of the GIRM later insists on the need for preparation: “Since, indeed, a variety of options is provided for the different parts of the Mass, it is necessary for the deacon, the lectors, the psalmist, the cantor, the commentator, and the choir to be completely sure before the celebration which text for which each is responsible is to be used and that nothing be improvised. Harmonious planning and carrying out of the rites will great assistance in disposing the faithful to participate in the Eucharist.”

This is all that is said about the commentator. By saying that the commentator intervenes “when appropriate” could be interpreted that this function is best used whenever there is something special, such as a confirmation or ordination that requires some explanation.

The insistence that this office’s functions must be meticulously prepared and are specifically orientated toward helping the people live the celebration would seem to exclude spontaneous interventions and unprepared remarks based on the homily.

Likewise it is highly debatable that the assembly’s singing "Happy Birthday" is the most appropriate spiritual preparation for Mass.

It must also be remembered that GIRM, No. 31, specifically assigns the presentation of the rite and any concluding summaries to the presiding priest and not to the commentator: “It is also up to the priest, in the exercise of his office of presiding over the gathered assembly, to offer certain explanations that are foreseen in the rite itself…. In addition, he may give the faithful a very brief introduction to the Mass of the day (after the initial Greeting and before the Act of Penitence), to the Liturgy of the Word (before the readings), and to the Eucharistic Prayer (before the Preface), though never during the Eucharistic Prayer itself; he may also make concluding comments to the entire sacred action before the dismissal.”

GIRM, No. 50, however, foresees the possibility that the brief introduction to the Mass of the day may also be assigned to a lay minister.

Although it is not a specific function of the commentator to call out the songs or make the usual announcements at the end of Mass, it is practical so as not to multiply the number of people in the sanctuary. All the same, it would be better to find another means to designate the songs so as to limit interruptions to the prescribed rite.

The duty of indicating, whenever necessary, the posture to be adopted by the people has traditionally fallen on the deacon, or on the cantor. It is usually only necessary when some special rite is celebrated, such as the Litany of Saints during ordinations.

The duty of indicating, whenever necessary, the posture to be adopted by the people has traditionally fallen on the deacon or the cantor. But No. 43 of the GIRM also allows this task to be assigned to another lay minister if necessary: “With a view to a uniformity in gestures and postures during one and the same celebration, the faithful should follow the directions which the deacon, lay minister, or priest gives according to whatever is indicated in the Missal.”

I believe that such indications are usually only necessary when some special rite is celebrated, such as the Litany of Saints during ordinations or in places where there are frequent visitors from different parts of the world who might be used to other practices.

Otherwise I believe that it is better to leave aside choreographic gestures and indications for regular Sunday Masses. Some of these might have been necessary at the beginning of the reform until people got used to the new rite. But after nearly 40 years of practice I think most Catholics now know when to kneel, sit and stand.

Something similar can be said about the persistent habit of cantors raising their hands, or saying “Response” after each psalm verse or invocation of the prayer of the faithful. It was all very well when the responsorial psalm and the intercessions were liturgical novelties, but by now it is sometimes a bit theatrical and distracting.

It is worth noting that such gestures are studiously avoided in papal Masses celebrated in Rome. The faithful easily interpret the appropriate moment to intervene as indicated by a pause, the cadence of the melody, or the intervention of the organ.

* * *

Follow-up: Kissing the Hands of a New Priest

The theme of kissing of hands of a new priest (see
June 10) brought to the fore another question regarding the use of hands.

A New Orleans reader asked: “Should there be silence (i.e., no music) during the imposition of hands at an ordination? I believe that the Pontifical says something like, 'Saying nothing' the bishop and then the other priests present impose hands. The force of the Latin, if I recall it correctly, seems to be simply that the priests say nothing (no prayer, no "God bless," no "You made it, Bill") while imposing hands. My question is this: Which is more fitting during this liturgical action, sacred silence similar to the elevation of the sacred species after the words of institution, or some fitting piece of music like, say, 'Veni, Sancte Spiritus'?”

The Pontifical, which our reader remembers well, says: “One by one, the candidates go to the bishop and kneel before him. The bishop wearing the miter lays his hands on the head of each, in silence.

“Next all the concelebrating presbyters and all other presbyters present, provided they are vested with a stole worn over an alb or over a cassock and surplice, lay their hands on each of the candidates, in silence. After the laying on of hands, the presbyters remain on either side of the bishop until the prayer of consecration is completed.”

From this we adduce that the priests imposing hands should say nothing and that any prayer for the ordinand should be purely mental.

The silence of this moment of the rite of ordination is of great importance and in a way it is a rite in itself. Thus during the rite of imposition of hands there should be no music or singing whatsoever.

However, even though there is nothing in the rubrics to support it, when the imposition of hands is likely to be protracted due to the number of priests or due to the number of candidates, liturgical practice seems to tolerate singing some invocation to the Holy Spirit. If and when this is done, the bishop usually imposes hands in silence and the hymn is intoned shortly after the priests have begun to impose hands.

In order to maintain the climate of silence the rubrics foresee the possibility of a smaller number of the priests present imposing hands. This is sometimes done, and is to be preferred to interrupting the silence, but it is not always easy to carry out without someone feeling excluded.

The second, much rarer, situation of prolonged silence is when the number of candidates is very numerous. After 10 minutes of absolute silence during a rite, even fervent people can get nervous and lose concentration on the mystery that is being celebrated. Thus the silence itself can become an obstacle to the concentration it seeks to promote.

In such cases some invocations such as the Veni Creator Spiritus can be tolerated.

This was the case in my own ordination in which I was blessed to form part of a group of 60 priests ordained by Pope John Paul II in St. Peter’s Basilica. The rite of imposition of hands alone lasted about half an hour and thus several hymns invoking the Holy Spirit were sung during its course.

* * *

Readers may send questions to liturgy@zenit.org. Please put the word "Liturgy" in the subject field. The text should include your initials, your city and your state, province or country. Father McNamara can only answer a small selection of the great number of questions that arrive.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular