singulair 4 mg price clopidogrel half tablet venta de pastillas cytotec en la lima honduras how long does ivermectin last lisinopril and sea salt reaction can i take buspar with hydrocodone azithromycin monohydrate and alcohol salep chloramphenicol untuk kulit can you take nitric oxide if you are taking flomax depo provera generic brand teeth damage bupropion feldene sublingual sandoz mirtazapine 30 mg side effects nortriptyline 30 mg side effects pastillas cytotec en houston tx ketoconazole shampoo price in india dog suppository antibiotics citalopram price costco oral yeast unfection not responsive to diflucan does estratest increase levothyroxine will 15mg of prednisone give you a headache terbinafine 250 mg dosage instructions is ciprofloxacin hcl a sulfa drug diltiazem 420 vs 240 coreg cr online synthroid 200 mcg and weight loss viagra a diaretic que funcion cumple la pastilla cytotec lipitor stuck in throat burns in fever tab. augmentin 625 mg is safe para que sirve el gabapentin discount cialis 10mg steal trazodone online prometrium after ovulation for trying to conceive cordarone 150 mg price in pakistan amoxicillin capsules price in india viagra price one pill ciprofloxacin and fluconazole when doing ivf non prescription viagra online seroquel not working is levaquin safe for dogs serophene 1 ciclo generic lexapro united states does augmentin make you feel flushed harga amlodipine 5 mg can you get high off lisinopril prednisone treatment for poison ivy dosage does cialis for daily use really work augmentin fara reteta in uk 1g baclofen 20 mg vs soma voltaren gel precio ecuador cheap flagyl no prescription can lisinopril be taken with aspirin lexapro for 8 years what is the success rate of cipro in curing prostatitis buy augmentin without a prescription jock itch fluconazole dosage augmentin 500 pret catena ketoconazole zinc pyrithione lotion clomiphene low testosterone sinusitis resistente a levofloxacina order bupropion no prescription remeron and valdoxan what is best kandungan metformin 500 mg plendil tab. nuspojave buy levitra american pharmacy pathway respo sible for hair loss in fosamax use veterinary topiramate buy obat stator 10 mg montelukastsodium10mg buy lasix online cheap synthroid pronunciation amoxicillin is it the same for dogs and humans mirtazapine reviews accutane 5th month taking clomid for 6 days vs 5 zoloft 100mg tablets can i take codral cold and flu lasix iv push rate prescription of cypro for 30 days generic seroquel cost montelukast 5mg in the morning 5mg at night pastile nexium how long should propecia be out of system before ttc lamisil bebes levitra online prices cheap viagra online prescription bactrim chlamydia metronidazole human liquid orange plus safe for cata purchase cialis prescription avodart 10 mg 100mg zoloft doseage equivancy to 30 mg celexa fluconazole suspension autism what is the price of misoprostol in kolkata canine prednisone muscle weakness 20 mg does escitalopram gluten free topamax uk prednisone usual dosage for dogs misoprostol pill price in india ketoconazole tablet price philippines clopidogrel platexan is it safe to take zyrtec d while on cipro yasmin levofloxacin no herx from lymes on zithromax aventis flagyl doxycycline 4 weeks pregnant i mixed oxycodone and clonidine pill is that dangerous doxycycline capsule bp 100mg structure prescribed water pills furosemide 20mg does cymbalta mellow you out lamisil 250 mg tablet yan etkileri zithromax 2g chlamydia misoprostol dosage for 3 weeks pregnant is quetiapine fumarate in benzo family diltiazem 200 mg will 1000 mg azithromycin cure chlamydia baclofen 10 mg yahoo what is the effect of cipro 500mg to hemorrhoid xenical pills at walmart no prescription cialis online conversion of iv lasix to po do i need to taper off 5mg lexapro taken fir 6 days lisinopril overdose fatalities online cialis pills can i buy synthroid online can ciprotab terminate early pregnancy cialis super active vs professional diflucan 150 mg tablet best generic price viagra how much does singulair cost prometrium suppository 200mg meloxicam melofar price philippines diltiazem gel sale ciprofloxacin hcl over the counter walgreens 30 year old male using viagra how much does lexapro cost in ireland obat lipitor atorvastatin bactrim mic breakpoint buspar chills para que es atarax hidroxizina 10mg voltaren krem neye iyi gelir augmentin 875 prospect adulti buy clomid canada can i give my cat amoxicillin premarin vaginal cream dosage albuterol mg cpt code for pdt zithromax lamisil krema i sprey protiv gljivica premarin nasal spray side effects inderal 60 fluoxetine 30 mg tablets amlodipine besylate for cats no prescription amoxicillin 500mg antibiotics if diflucan works in my geografic tongue mesns what why does the nhs not provide propecia inderal hair loss accutane 10mg lasix from uk to buy fosamax price googlewhat is tamsulosin lexapro cause gout will reglan prevent erythromycin nausea lipitor online uk azithromycin 500 mg adalah generic cialis tadalafil australia celebrex recall too much intake of fluconazole can delay period donde puedo comprar cytotec en puerto vallarta does cialis help you last longer zestril 20 mg prezzo levaquin cephalosporin 400mg de amoxilling para que edad zyrtec contraindications with levaquin can i get cyproheptadine at clicks dr ray peat on viagra and hair nizoral shampoo india cipro chlamydia clozapine 200 mg can zoloft and abilify be taken together paxil and personality change levitra tablets 20 mg femara causa impotencia cost of viagra cialis citalopram hbr 15 mg buy antibiotics online uk how to attract a girl with the viagra tablets does temazepam help with depression cialis 600 mg can i take ambien 5 mg with gabapentin flagyl dose for dog diaarhea azithromycin 300mg vibramycin 100mg for sinus infection how to ween off of neurontin naproxen online bestellen buy nexium online no prescription how to use ketoconazole solution nizoral prednisone can prednisone be take before surgery how much does bupropion xl cost without insurance can valtrex be bought in tesco bupropion smells like vinegar cytotec 7 pastillas prozac 40 mg benefits buy zyban online no prescription how long after stopping plavix can i take motrin cialis paypal canada viagra price per pill azithromycin 250 mg es bueno para la clamidia can i drink beer 5days after one dose of azithromycin can bupropion hcl xl be cut in half montelukast palpitations floacin antibiotic how long before birth control pills desogen effective cost zyvox is 875mg of amoxicillin too much sandoz azithromycin 1g vomit generic cialis 20mg uk side effects of augmentin bd 1ooomg recall on clopidogrel piroxicam 20 mg capsule plavix dosage range kamagra jel bulk buy phenergan 7 year old dosage celebrex chien 200mg how many sachet of augmentin 625 mg can cure staph harga nizoral ss shampo thuoc montelukast la thuoc gi gabapentin 100mg neurontin informacion en espanol dose of cipro for chlamydia take acyclovir with or without food no prescription viagra in australia does synthroid 100 mg make you gain weight glimepiride appetite tapering off prednisone after an allergic reaction vibramycin liquid form can micardis cause neuropathy how to take misoprostol orally is drinking while dogs on prednisone side effects cost of cytotec and mifeprex in kenya is it ok to take coq10 with aspirin and clopidogrel nhs side effects of lexapro after 5 years how to cycle albuterol t3 keto singulair powder can you drink alcohol when on tetracycline 250 mg uk prednisone 10 mg dosage instructions purchase acyclovir tablets metronidazole vaginal gel for a uti best antidepressant for hypomania in woman 20 milligrams of cialis compared to 100 of viagra what would happen if i snorted periactin lexapro cancer furosemide vs torsemide dose harga pil cytotec 200 mcg terbinafine hydrochloride dusting powder cialis brand buy online can you take amoxicillin with melatonin fake cytotec quiapo dental dosage metronidazole dogs augmentin 5 days target azithromycin suspension cost cut cialis 36 hour pill augmentin 625 mg overdose ketoconazole cream teva for sale cialis prices giant eagle herbal levitra price in india purchase erythromycin purchase doxazosin does doxycycline affect blood thinner can i take out of date antibiotics uk kamagra online kaufen wo maintenance dose of valtrex to prevent fever blisters can one use clomid after using wild yam is metronidazole gel an antifungal can i buy a liquid amoxicillin over the counter luvox australia doxycycline dan 5553 zofran injection price in pakistan desogestrel 75 mcg 28 comprimidos generic metronidazole lotion buy lisinopril dihydrate online xeloda is not is cipro a fluoroquinolone 60 mg orlistat price uric acid lipitor coq10 estradiol over 5000 naproxen sodium street value buy diltiazem cream uk does lisinopril effect joints and tendons how much is seroquel 100mg street value mezclar gabapentin 300 mg con acetaminofen 625mg can i take lexapro after drinking isotretinoin 10mg isotane 10 donde puedo comprar el cytotec en uruapan does amoxicillin 500mg cure gonoread lisinopril and grapefruit interaction thuoc augmentin how long is tetracycline good for indocin gel manufacturing componetes del viagra does cipro help with tooth infections can i drink alcohol while taking fluconazole celexa 10 mg effective how fast will cipro work in the elderly sildenafil canada no prescription citalopram irritability zofran 16 mg czopki desogen generic cost can i take metronidazole with propranolol estradiol 900 lab monitoring terbinafine costs augmentin syrup duo yan etki can augmentin be used in bartholins abcess lek plendil 5 mg vet med fluconazole no prescription tenormin a cosa serve buy glucophage 500mg side effects of nexium 24 hour buy nexium prescription valacyclovir no prescription elavil reviews for migraines benazepril 5 mg cena micardis telmisartan 40 mg price sciatic pain with zoloft 36 horas tadalafil 20 mg amoxicillin a45 side effects swelling kegunaan clomiphene citrate tamsulosin hydrochloride treat psoriasis augmentin duo forte and alcohol clomiphene citrate brands for men doxycycline dogs urination provera uknjizbe feldene 20 mg price in philippines can you drink alcohol with celexa and wellbutrin doxazosin 2 mg tab apotex usa baclofen pump in india discount generic viagra panama arimidex liquid para que sirve can i take nexium with probiotics steet value of zyprexa fluconazole for dogs for cheap when does regrowth on finasteride start diflucan fluconazole 5omg espanol jual misoprostol cytotec di solo nhs paroxetine 12.5 mg amoxicillin for adult dose kaplet eye infection bactrim skin infection fungal how much doxycycline is consider an oversose in dogs metformin pcos time released paroxetine side effects forum diclofenac misoprostol 50 mg buy levitra us inj.nitroglycerin prize amitriptyline dose for muscle pain order valtrex online purchase nolvadex pct terbinafine dogs seizure is there over the counter equivilent for prednisone how to switch from lyrica to gabapentin generic cialis prices lisinopril 30 mg side effects nortriptyline 10mgs. for anxiety anyone drink beer while taking metoprolol 25mg albuterol uk amoxicillin 1 gram petco flagyl tablets robaxin 750 versus metformin periactin 4 symptoms from skipping synthroid buy levaquin online no prescription is it safe to take 40 mg of lexapro lisinopril 10 mg sandoz italia jerawat doxycycline 100mg correct dosage of amoxicillin 400 for dogs synthroid dosage too high symptoms lipitor 600 mg cipro mg hold metformin for mri can i get a flu shot while taking valtrex

Preventing a 'spiritual Disneyland' in the Holy Land

By now, the threat facing Christianity in its birthplace has become depressingly clear.
by John L Allen Jr | Source: ARCOL

 Jul 21, 2011

 Christians represented 30 percent of British Mandate Palestine in 1948, while today their share in Israel and the Palestinian Territories is estimated at 1.25 percent. The risk, as the Catholic Patriarch of Jerusalem, Fouad Twal, has put it, is that the Holy Land is becoming a “spiritual Disneyland” -- full of glittering rides and attractions, but empty of its indigenous Christian population.

French Cardinal Jean-Louis Tauran, president of the Vatican’s Pontifical Commission for Interreligious Dialogue and formerly Pope John Paul II’s top diplomat, offers another evocative image: The Christian centers of the Holy Land as “archeological and historical sites, to be visited like the Colosseum in Rome … museums with entrance tickets, and guides who explain the beautiful legends.”

This decline in the Holy Land is part of a broad Christian exodus all across the Middle East. The reasons are also well known, and fairly obvious:

  • The Israeli/Palestinian conflict, which affects Arab Christians just as much as Arab Muslims;
  • Economic instability and lack of opportunity;
  • Rising Islamic fundamentalism, today compounded by fear that the promise of the Arab Spring could give way a winter of insecurity and theocratic regimes;
  • The fact that Christians in the area are disproportionately better educated and more affluent, and thus stand a better chance of getting out. As one observer has said, in the Middle East frustrated Christians emigrate physically, while frustrated Muslims emigrate ideologically.

Yet even when the big picture is familiar, its details still pack emotional punch.

Raphaela Fischer Mourra is the daughter of a German father and a Palestinian mother, born and raised in Bethlehem. In 2000, at the age of 15, she lost her father to an Israeli missile attack as he raced to rescue their neighbors; she tearfully describes him as “the first Christian martyr of the Second Intifada.” Samer Makhlouf, a 35-year-old raised in a Christian village on the West Bank, was arrested by Israeli troops at the age of 15 for tossing a stone in frustration. He was detained for four months, he said, interrogated and tortured, and still bears the marks of the experience, both physical and emotional. Another young Palestinian Christian, Jacoub Sleibi, says his family is forced to haul water to their home in Bethlehem, while fresh water flows abundantly through nearby Israeli settlements.

To make the point that no one has a monopoly on pain, there’s Rabbi Daniel Sperber of Bar-Ilan University in Tel Aviv, who over the years has found himself scraping bits of bone and skin out of burned Israeli tanks in order to make DNA identifications, calling it the sort of tragedy “that has touched every Israeli family.” His own children have been afraid to get on the school bus, he said, worrying that it might blow up – illustrating, as Sperber puts it, that “we also have our agony.”

These were among the voices at a two-day conference on the fate of Christians in the Holy Land in London this week, cosponsored by the Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, and the Catholic Archbishop of Westminster, Vincent Nichols. Held at Lambeth Palace, the spiritual headquarters of the Anglican Communion, the event brought together some 90 church leaders, politicians, activists and media types to raise what Williams described as “literate, compassionate awareness” of the Christian plight, and to galvanize action.

The summit seemed to offer three main contributions:

  • A crystallized form of the rationale as to why the Christian world should care;
  • A survey of open questions;
  • A set of concrete ideas about how to support the Christian presence in the Holy Land.

Retired Cardinal Theodore McCarrick of Washington, D.C., and Bishop Gerald Kicanas of Tucson, Arizona, were the American prelates at the gathering, while Tauran was on hand for the Vatican. (As a footnote, McCarrick is “retired” only in the technical sense. At 81, he logs more miles as a trouble-shooter and promoter of dialogue than anyone else I know; while he checked into our hotel he let me flip through the pages of his passport, which has to be one of the most used travel documents I’ve ever seen.)

* * *
The argument as to why we ought to care about Christians in the Holy Land boiled down to two points: First, their survival is critical to Christianity’s identity; second, it’s a key to peace in the region, and therefore to peace in the world.

Williams made the first case.

“Christianity is an historical religion,” he said. “At its center is a set of events that occurred in a particular place and at a particular time. It is not open to Christians to say that Christianity is whatever they choose it to be. We are responsible to what happened in the Holy Land two millennia ago.”

A Christian witness in the place where these events occurred, Williams said, is therefore “no small thing.”

“It would be a form of Gnosticism if we were to say that the Christian presence in the land of Our Lord does not matter to us,” Williams argued, calling such disregard a way of “cutting ourselves loose from history.”

(The depth of that history, by the way, was memorably captured by Zoughbi Zoughbi, a Palestinian Christian from Bethlehem: “My great-great grandmother,” he quipped, “was the babysitter of Jesus.”)

Beyond an antidote to Gnosticism, Williams said, the Arab Christians of the Holy Land make another contribution to Christian identity: They remind us that at its origins, Christianity is an “exotic Eastern religion … not bound up with Western culture.”

In typically wry fashion, Williams observed that Christianity was not born “in Europe, or even on the shores of North America … which is quite good for us all.” It is, therefore, as alien “to the Capitalist West as it is to the Far East.”

That point, Williams said, is vital to the “specificity of Christian faith” and its “authenticity.”

In terms of the importance of Christianity in the Holy Land to hopes for peace, speakers repeatedly stressed that although Christianity have a small sociological footprint, it is, in the words of Tauran, “a minority that matters.” Churches operate a vast network of schools and universities, hospitals, and social service centers, and individual Christians make key contributions to business, politics, and arts and culture.

Several observers also insisted the presence of Christianity keeps alive the notion of the Holy Land as a pluralistic space in which tolerance, democracy, and respect for human rights are essential – and, conversely, the disappearance of Christianity would send the wrong signal about the future direction of the region.

In that sense, the presence or absence of a flourishing Christian minority is a bellwether for the political and cultural health of the society.

Perhaps the most compelling form of that argument came from Lubna Alzaroo, a young Palestinian Muslim who currently attends Bethlehem University, an institution sponsored by the De La Salle Christian Brothers. Raised in Hebron, Alzaroo said her family can trace its roots in the area back 1,500 years.

In the mid-1960s, Alzaroo said, Hebron had a small Christian community, but today it’s entirely disappeared. (There’s a Christian elementary school, she said, but its student population is entirely Muslim.) As a result, she didn’t actually meet a Christian until she was 18 years old, and that encounter came during a study program in the United States.

It’s not a coincidence, Alzaroo said, that Hebron is considered the most religiously conservative city in the Palestinian Territories, and thus an incubator for more radical and militant currents.

“Part of the reason is the lack of pluralism,” she said. “The more isolated they become, the more they think their way is the only way.”

Given the link between the presence of Christianity and the plausibility of a democratic and tolerant Palestine, Alzaroo offered this dramatic warning: If Christianity were to disappear, she said, “It would have ramifications as catastrophic for the Palestinians as the Nakba in 1948.”

(“Nakba” is an Arabic term, roughly meaning “disaster,” which Palestinians use to refer to their displacement following the creation of the State of Israel in 1948.)

* * *
Making the case for concern, of course, is the easy part. Knowing what to do is far harder, in part because the situation is maddeningly complex. One consensus was that any intervention in defense of Christians in the Holy Land, and, more broadly, in favor of peace in the region, cannot come off as partisan – i.e., biased in favor of one party to the conflict or the other.

Twal, who is himself a Jordanian, put it this way: “The only authentic pro-Israeli position is one that’s also pro-Palestinian and pro-peace.”

Beyond that call for balance, at least three recurrent tensions ran through the discussions at Lambeth Palace – open questions which drew differing answers, depending upon who was speaking.

1. What’s the impact of Israeli policy on Christians?

Samer Makhlouf, a Latin Catholic and executive director of “One Voice” in Palestine, a grassroots movement that brings together young Palestinians and Israelis to promote peace, said that of the four problems facing Christians in the Holy Land, the first three are “occupation, occupation, occupation.”

Makhlouf described Israeli military and security policy, which Palestinians capture with the term “occupation,” as “the father of all the problems in the region.”

Over and over, Palestinian Christians insisted that the main factors fueling their exodus – political discrimination and a sense of second-class citizenship, lack of economic development and employment, restrictions on their freedom of movement, and so on – are fundamentally the result of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict, rather than explicit discrimination against Christians.

One frequently cited difficulty involves access to Christian holy sites. Palestinians living in the West Bank and in East Jerusalem hold different residency cards, and they cannot move from one place to the other without special permits. It can be virtually impossible for a Christian in Bethlehem, for instance, to travel to Jerusalem to worship in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. (That’s true even if a permit is granted, many speakers said, since Easter coincides with the Jewish festival of Pescah, when a security lockdown is imposed.)

As Mourra put it, “It’s easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a Palestinian to go to Jerusalem.”

Residency policies can have a devastating impact on families. Reportedly, there are some 200 Christian families living apart today, split between members in the West Bank and members in Jerusalem.

Hana Bendcowsky, a Jewish Israeli affiliated with the Jerusalem Centre for Christian Jewish Relations, warned of hardening Israeli attitudes towards Christianity. A 2009 survey, she said, found that 18-29 year old Israelis hold more negative views of Christians than older generations.

At root, she said, Jews in Israel have a hard time thinking of themselves as a majority. They see tend to see the Christians in their midst not as an embattled minority, but a “doubly threatening majority” – part of both the Arab world and the Christian West.

There was also an undercurrent of frustration at the London meeting about negotiations which have lingered since 1993 over the “Fundamental Agreement” between Israel and the Vatican, which among other things was supposed to regulate the tax and legal status of church properties in Israel. The terms of the agreement have never been implemented by the Israeli Knesset, and in the meantime, Israeli has declared certain important Christian sites, such as Mount Tabor and Capernaum, to be national parks, overriding Christian control.

As one speaker put it, those acts seem part of an Israeli policy of creating “facts on the ground” that unilaterally reshape negotiations.

During a plenary session at the end of the gathering, a recommendation surfaced that church leaders should urge Israel to act – and should also urge the Vatican to keep up the pressure. The fear is that if Israel ignores its deal with the Vatican, it erodes public confidence in the possibility of a negotiated settlement to anything.

On the other hand, several speakers noted that as the lone genuine democracy in the region, Israel has a track record of giving minorities, including Christians, a better break than they find elsewhere. Some argued that Christianity is actually doing comparatively well inside Israel itself.

Sperber said that more than 50,000 Christians have recently settled in Israel from the former territories of the Soviet Union, and adding to those numbers are other émigrés from the Balkans and from Asia, especially the Philippines. As a result, he said, “the churches are full in Tel Aviv and Haifa,” and he sees the same thing in Jerusalem.

Sperber said there is also a “tremendous upsurge” in Christian pilgrimage in Israel – so much so, he said, that his neighbors often find it difficult to get out of their houses because their narrow alleyways are stuffed with Christian tourists.

In fact, Sperber said, there is “a renaissance of Christian activity in the state of Israel.” He added that Israel is one of the few countries in the Middle East where the Christian population is growing, and where Christian institutions enjoy state support.

Bernard Sabellah, a Palestinian Christian academic and a member of the Palestinian Legislative Council, offered a different take.

There were roughly 35,000 Christians in the territory of Israel in 1948, he said, while today the number is 110,000. Given the natural rate of demographic increase over a half-century, he said, the Christian population today should be 150,000, which means that there are a “missing” 40,000 Christians in Israel. Moreover, he asserted, a recent survey of young Christians in Israel found that 26 percent want to leave – the same percentage as in the Palestinian Territories.

As a result, Sabellah said, for Christians, “the state system is not a blessing from the Israeli government.”

2. What to make of the Arab Spring?

Nowhere in the Christian world does one find a more positive treatment of secularism than in the Middle East. In the West, secularism is often the bogeyman of the Christian imagination, because it’s identified with declines in religious faith and practice and in the impact of traditional moral values. In the Middle East, Christians generally see secularism as a survival strategy – the only viable alternative to corrupt authoritarian regimes on the one hand, and Islamic theocracy on the other.

Reflecting that psychology, considerable enthusiasm coursed through the Lambeth gathering about the Arab Spring, and the vision of pluralistic, democratic, and participatory societies which seem to animate its young protagonists.

“The recent Arab Spring of youth in the region is spreading,” Twal said. “Sooner or later, with violence or peacefully, it is coming. No regime is immune to these events.”

The Anglican Bishop of Jerusalem, Suheil Dawani, said the Arab Spring demonstrates that “the people are demanding to be heard,” and that as Arab Christians, “we join our Arab brothers and sisters.”

Sabellah said the Arab Spring reflects the reality that the majority of Arabs want to live “in an open, preferably secular, democratic society.” That’s especially true, he said, for Christians.

“I have no problem with Islam, but I want to be a citizen, not a tolerated minority by a gracious act of Israel, or Assad, or Abu Mazen, or the King of Jordan,” he said.

“Citizenship” was a key theme throughout the meeting, seeming to capture a distinctly Arab Christian vision of secular society. Zoughbi once again put the point in pithy fashion: In the Middle East, he said, “We don’t need liberation theology. We need liberation from theology.”

Yet some Christians cannot help but feel ambivalent about the Arab Spring, wondering if it will really deliver on those heady promises.

“I look at it with great hope, but also great worry and fear,” Makhlouf said. “If it means greater democracy and more free societies, that’s very promising. But the future is not clear … What’s next? Is it the Muslim Brotherhood? More Islamic regimes in the region?”

Others echoed those sentiments.

McCarrick said he recently returned from a trip to Gaza, where he met both with young people and with some of the elders. While the youth expressed frustration about the lack of movement and the difficult of obtaining visas, he said, the elderly voiced deeper worries.

“They’re afraid of Hamas, and they’re afraid of the Arab Spring, what it might mean for the government there,” he said.

Likewise, conservative British MP Tony Baldry said he recently visited Egypt, where he met with both Coptic and Catholic leaders who “are not optimistic” about the Arab Spring. Christian leaders in Egypt, he said, worry that “by next year, the Muslim Brotherhood will be in control of the military” – with potentially threatening consequences for the country’s Christian minority.

Harry Hagopian, a Jerusalem-based representative of the Armenian Orthodox Patriarchate and also an advisor to the Catholic bishops of England and Wales on the Middle East, put it this way: “The Arab Spring is bringing down walls, and sometimes kicking up dust.”

To the extent there was a consensus, it might be expressed this way: There’s much to applaud in the Arab Spring, but it’s also naïve, as Baldry put it, “to think that every change is necessarily for the better.”

3. Is political advocacy or grassroots effort the way to go?

Repeatedly, speakers at the Lambeth event said that politicians, both inside and outside the Holy Land, appear incapable of resolving the region’s problems. There seemed little confidence in a new outburst of sensibility.

Indeed, there was a palpable sense that politics is driving the region towards a new cycle of disaster – with the potential for a new Intifada, or a new war in Lebanon, or new conflict between Al-Fatah and Hamas. Several speakers even raised the prospect that in Gaza, Hamas is coming to seem a “moderate” force up against even more radical currents of Islam.

Though it wasn’t much discussed, participants were obviously conscious of the likelihood of a September vote on Palestinian statehood in the General Assembly of the United Nations, and the prospect that it too could unleash new conflict.

As a result, some suggested that the right approach to aiding Christians is to focus on bottom-up, grassroots initiatives, ignoring the bleak political landscape.

“We are not sitting by the wayside waiting for politicians or anyone else to create a path to peace,” Dawani said.

He pointed to a number of concrete efforts launched by Christian leaders, including a new joint project in Jerusalem between the Anglican and Catholic churches intended to give young Christian families access to decent housing. A wide range of similar initiatives, either already under way or in the planning stages, were floated over the two days.

On the other hand, several speakers insisted that one cannot simply throw in the towel on the political process – especially given the obvious linkage between the specific plight of Christians and the broader Israeli/Palestinian conflict.

“The greatest single thing Christians worldwide can do [to help believers in the Holy Land] is to encourage a two-state solution,” said Stephen Colecchi, director of the U.S. bishops’ Office of International Justice and Peace. He argued that the drive to work locally, and on a small scale, must be “held together” with broader political advocacy.

Robert Edmunds, chaplain to the Anglican Bishop of Jerusalem, said that many grassroots initiatives amount to “band-aids,” and that “if we don’t encourage the government of Israel to cut a deal, we’re going to be putting on band-aids for a very long time.”

Edmunds insisted he’s not opposed to such projects: “Band-aids are important,” he said. “They keep you from bleeding to death.” Yet until there’s a broad political solution, he said, the grassroots approach risks ending in “words and good will” that don’t fundamentally change the realities on the ground.

In the end, the approach that seemed to prevail was “both/and” – small-scale initiatives as a form of confidence-building measures, while continuing the pursuit of a political game-changer.

In terms of how to do effective advocacy, Sabellah stressed the importance of a limited and pragmatic agenda.

“Lofty dialogue will get you nowhere,” he said. “Let’s not waste effort.” He suggested a narrow focus on practical matters such as residency, housing, and freedom of movement, which could be resolved even in the absence of a comprehensive peace deal.

* * *
Towards the end of the meeting, an effort was made to identify concrete ideas that would be of help to Christians in the Holy Land, and which could be achieved not in a far-off speculative future, but in the here and now.

A sampling of those proposals follows.

  1. A targeted push with the Israeli authorities in favor of easier access to the holy sites, especially movement from the West Bank to Jerusalem. As Nichols put it, “The de facto separation of Bethlehem from Jerusalem seems to sum up the frustration and fear that people feel.”
  2. Supporting projects such as “Friends of the Holy Land,” a new charity established under Catholic auspices in England and Wales and now endorsed by Williams and the Church of England as an ecumenical project.
  3. Encouraging Catholic charities around the world to focus on projects in the Holy Land, such as water supplies, medical care, housing and employment.
  4. Encouraging pilgrimage and tourism to the Holy Land, under a “new template” which would focus not merely on seeing historical sites but also encountering living Christian faith communities.
  5. Launching an umbrella group for Christian NGOs which would pool their efforts, both in terms of political advocacy and on-the-ground aid projects.
  6. Organizing a conference similar to the Lambeth event in the United States. That idea came from Kicanas, who suggested bringing religious, political and cultural leaders in the States together for a similar high-level discussion.
  7. Inviting Palestinian Christian students from Bethlehem University to spend a few months abroad, perhaps as part of an exchange program. They could be hosted by parishes, and also have the chance to meet with political leaders in those areas.
  8. Conducting a church study of Christian Messianic Zionism – i.e., the view that the return of Jews to Israel is a prerequisite to the Second Coming – and what it means for the Christians living in Palestine.
  9. Preparing homiletic materials to promote preaching and faith formation about the situation facing Christians in the Holy Land.
  10. Supporting the Vatican’s position on an international statute for Jerusalem, in which the holy sites would be accorded legal protection, and also encouraging the Israeli government to implement the Fundamental Agreement.
  11. Reaching out to the Palestinian Christian diaspora in the United States and Europe, promoting relationships with their fellow Christians who remain in the Palestinian Territories.
  12. Promoting micro-finance and job training programs for Christians in Israel and the Palestinian Territories.
  13. Developing classes for the non-Christian majorities in Israel and the Palestinian Territories to educate them about the Christian presence.
  14. Encouraging business firms in the West to “adopt” a Christian enterprise in Palestine, meaning to enter into partnership and ensure its access to markets.
  15. Developing an ecumenical day of prayer for the Christians of the Holy Land, so that one day a year they know the entire Christian world is praying on their behalf.
  16. Developing a web-based communications network which would allow the Christians of the Holy Land to connect with the global church about their daily challenges.
  17. Ensuring that advocacy and aid related to Christians in the Holy Land is truly ecumenical, beginning with a sustained Anglican/Catholic partnership.
  18. Parishes in the West “adopting” a Christian parish, or an entire community, in the Holy Land. Sperber suggested an analogy with the way Jews in the 19th century adopted fledging communities in Ottoman Palestine, which helped solidify the Jewish presence in the land.

* * *

Here’s one final reflection, on the ecumenical significance of what happened in Lambeth Palace this week.

Williams and Nichols were genuine co-chairs of the event. It was not a typical ecclesiastical summit, where the VIPs issue a few words of greeting at the beginning and then scuttle off to other appointments. Williams and Nichols sat together on the dais throughout, introducing speakers and listening carefully, then offering reflections of their own. They also held a joint press conference at the end, presenting everything as a common reflection and plan of action.

For anyone conscious of the strained past (and, for that matter, present) of Anglican/Catholic relations, it was an impressive display of partnership. In particular, the event seemed to rebut fears that recent turbulence caused by creation of a Catholic ordinariate to welcome ex-Anglicans would somehow shut down the relationship.

Williams and Nichols did everything possible to strike an image of common cause. During a brief press conference at the conclusion of the event, a British reporter asked for comment on a pending visit to the U.K. by American pastor John Hagee, known for his staunchly pro-Israeli views which, in the eyes of some, buttress extremist positions inside Israel.

Nichols fielded the question, conceding that he’s never heard of Hagee, but saying that “I would trust the intelligence of people in this country to judge his remarks appropriately,” and then added: “He seems to have a very different approach than we do.”

The “we” in that sentence, of course, was himself and Williams.

No doubt, the growing divide between Anglicanism and Catholicism on a well-known canon of issues – including women priests and women bishops, homosexuality and same-sex marriage, and the whole question of ecclesial authority – has made structural reunion more difficult. But if this week in London proved anything, it’s that those differences do not have to prevent the two churches from working together on other matters, and in a spirit of real friendship.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular