amoxicillin different penicillin zyprexa and cipralex does singulair help with food allergies effects of chewing amoxil capsules how does seroquel affect dementia alzheimer patients clomid 100 mg day 1 ciprofloxacin for dogs dose amoxicillin plus clavulante buy online gabapentin 300 mg generic spironolactone side effects facial hair buspirone hcl pill how much should i take to get high augmentin antibiotico bustine bambini can prednisone cause palpitations in pregnancys ventolin dozlari drooping eyelid and olanzapine cytotec riesgo de 6 pastillas metronidazole gel price in india is phenergan ok for 2 year old can i take montelukast sodium 10mg with symbicort ramipril hydrochlorothiazide vidal cuanto cuesta celebrex can you take metoprolol succ er 25 mg and diazepam 5 mg interaction entre cipro et valsartan clopidogrel chemical assumere insieme cialis e viagra ventolin es doping allopurinol effects on heart rizatriptan benz vs maxalt where is furosemide absorbed topamax propranolol zoloft birth defects settlements purchase diflucan online zoloft affiliate program zoloft cause peripheral neuropathy generic xenical does it really work i took paxil while pregnant is viagra available in bali lipitor induced rhabdomyolysis celexa breastfeeding safety kamagra 4u amlodipine 2.5 mg apple cider vinegar methocarbamol actions viagra 100mg and 50mg 4 pec orlistat hersteller can you take paxil and zyrtec can cephalexin treat eye infections tamiflu and zofran singulair tablet income under petent kamagra uk viagra wellbutrin avec topamax side effects of viagra overdose gabapentin and dress what is prednisone drugs seroquel side effects 150 mg montelukast y prolactina prednisone side effects in dogs urinating neurontin para el cancer aciclovir pharmacorama ketoconazole cream philippines price rizatriptan neuraxpharm dosis obat tetracycline estrace provera is wellbutrin dangerous lisinopril and gynaecomastia donde comprar nizoral sertraline bipolar disorder lasix without sulfa lisinopril side effects nose bleed pityriasis versicolor metronidazole pre?o dostinex 0 5 where to get biomox suspension no prescription bactrim ds dark urine prodotto alternativo al cialis azithromycin 5 day dose pack side effects half inderal la 80 mg pro rel caps segundo tratamiento de isotretinoina arimidex not working tetracycline stain mechanism citalopram reviews for anxiety metronidazole flagyl suppository price jual tamoxifen cipro causing frequent urination i accidentally took double dose 88 mcg levothyroxine cialis c80 dosage indikasi dan efek samping lasix cozaar 50mg online can lamisil cream treat uti paroxetine 20 mg buy electronic cigarette viagra propecia dosage mg metoprolol er 25mg interaction with grapefruit can i take tylenol with my synthroid generic singulair available in u.s girlfriend pregnant finasteride how to take clomid and nolva pct indapamide baownbeuv cost vardenafil 40 mg india buspar ativan together direction to use biotech ciprollaxacin 500 amoxil 1g dispersible tablets i taking metformin hcl and i gave me diarrhea estradiol sistema inmune hydroxyzine and suboxone heartburn after taking doxycycline paxil ibs prozac during third trimester buy conjugated estrogens directions on taking prednisone levitra dil alti kullanimi stromectol 3 mg einnahme irbesartan hctz price chart 75mg over 300 dose of synthroid nexium esomeprazole acne fosamax australia revatio prijs is prazosin a narcotic where to buy propecia hong kong bestellen viagra generic name linezolid viagra gel uk nizoral shampoo ad how to get off zoloft 25 mg thuoc cordarone 200 efeito colateral bactrim f singulair merck frosst importing tamoxifen citrate in australia zithromax 250 mg twice a day for chlamydia retail cost of montelukast 4 amoxicillin to increase cervical mucus healthy man viagra nexium 20mg pdf para que son las pastillas ciprofloxacino 500 ondansetron price philippines what happens if you drink alcohol while on doxycycline wellbutrin and weight losss benicar hct and hair loss dog on antibiotics peeing green kamagra 360 dose of doxycycline for cellulitis metronidazole gel trade name flomax mood swings zoloft 50 mg benefits zofran indian equivolent ciprodex fungal infection qualcuno sa il prezzo do periactin compresse safety of cefixime and linezolid in lactation reviews on amitriptyline 10mg azithromycin price in nigeria can i take nytol with sertraline meclazine zoloft klonopin increasing estradiol naturally what is the max does of cialis after prostate surgury que efectos tiene doxycycline hyclate side effects of premarin nose spray buspirone allergic reactions prednisone pack sun exposure jarabe misoprostol para abortar how long will it take for 50mg quetiapine to wear off albuterol neb solution online no prescription prices cialis 20mg buy celebrex canadian pharmacy diltiazem 30 mg crush and or chew cialis pills can cymbalta make you itch six months on clomid buy amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium acyclovir 200mg tablets ndc code zofran dosage for 12 month old levothroid adelgazar uso de pastilla cialis cuanto vale misoprostol en argentina zofran in liquid precio nexium mexico cipro and cream cheese ondansetron odt with tylenol venta de cytotec en cochabamba bolivia propecia reversing miniaturization temples clozaril and zyprexa antidepressant withdrawal syndrome comprar viagra por boleto perbedaan salep ketoconazole miconazole dealing with cymbalta withdrawal best price on generic viagra metronidazole cream better than pills when pregnant can i give my cat the third session of antibiotics prednisone and prostate enlargement does viagra increase length clomid not pregnant no period ejertol sildenafil viagra no more premature ejaculation can you drink grapefruit juice on citalopram bactrim vias urinarias pct nolvadex and clomid cycle howsafe is clomid try for twins estradiol no prescription needed zithromax patient assistance program writing a prescription for amoxicillin suspension antibiotic azithromycin doses india cost of real levitra mejer does carvedilol react with tums buy clomid online ireland glucophage cost septra ds dosage for dogs mechanism of action of furosemide in ards wellbutrin lost 50 pounds uti augmentin 875 metformin 550 mg side effects levofloxacin hemihydrate 750 mg treatment of sti tinnitus and tetracycline post pci clopidogrel escitalopram oxalate is for erection disinfection cheapest metronidazole syrup generic viagra online to canada ondansetron and diarrhea can u have weed with buspar and celexa quien vende misoprostol en chile dose of metformin for prediabetes terbinafine dusting powder to face wound can i use phenergan for nausea from tylenol 3 abortion with cytotec australia online generic plavix 75mg price in europe cymbalta and driving precios de viagra pfizer 100g. magnesium thyroxine effet du silagra how long after taking fluconazole can you drink alcohol buy famciclovir diflucan interactions food premarin uk trazodone high compassionate care cymbalta buy cheap actos buy sildenafil citrate at gnc cymbalta spinal cord injury celebrex 200mg capsule olanzapine sidesffects check sheet plavix therapeutic levels food interaction fluconazole 150mg premarin on urethra modelo 790 certificado actos ultima voluntad dermatologic reactions to azithromycin wellbutrin sperm count buy online clomid 50mg tablet in india clomid side effects for males how to take amoxicillin 500mg men gonorrhea best canadian online pharmacy for viagra baclofen myelopathy lamisil for yeast infection vagina 20mg cialis at tesco supermarket wellbutrin for adderrall addicyion can i drink milk with my synthroid voltaren sammen med wellbutrin paroxetine vruchtbaarheid erection pills in uae azithromycin 250 mg dose pack and alcohol usage stopping premarin in the elderly ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg uses does augmentin kill.anarobe ondansetron 4 mg injection can i stop nifedipine erythromycin gingivitis tetracycline teeth whitening uk can apo quetiapine be smoked can you take bactrim for lyme disease buy zithromax online no prescription mexico xenical for medium weight wellbutrin tablet meaning of ondansetron hcl 4mg stromectol tue les oeufs plavix coverup como se llama la pastilla del viagra skipping antidepressants 3 days tightening of jaw after stopping escitalopram what is substituted for zyprexa 10 mg tablet aldactone hombres como actua el adalat renal mag 3 lasix nateglinide tab 60 mg wellbutrin swollen tongue how long to go away dose cyproheptadine increase libido celexa adrenal efecto adverso del finasteride synthroid dosage and tsh levels spironolactone male fertility is propranolol good with elavil for tension headache acupuncture clomid success viagra japan does prednisone make you speed benicar without diuretic can you take escitalopram with gingko bobla metoprolol er succinate and sleep apnea sildenafil 50mggenfar who can prescribe cialis other than doctor ivermectin tqeovertoz overnight can i drink grapefruit juice with seroquel viagra online bestellen schweiz feldene gel 0.5 50g can u snort hydroxyzine hcl 10mg tab que es metoprolol 100 mg purchase principen tqeovertoz hyperkalemia lasix viagra too big a dose 7.5 mg prednisone long term nurse intervention cialis high amh clomid phillip stricker sildenafil primary investigator pfizer thyroxine after thyroidectomy zithromax dosage 6 year old mixing acyclovir 400mg and metronidazole 500mg cycin ciprofloxacin for uti costo de caja de viagra best prices on viagra cialis online no prescription uk baclofen maximum daily dose cipro 16 year old zinc pyrithione,ketoconazole shampoo india metformine om af te vallen erythromycin ointment dosage newborns singulair pliculete prospect how many tabs of doxycycline for infection the effects using cialis and androgel together cipro temperature luglio ofloxacin and ciprodex the same does flagyl changes date for mastruation chances of getting pregnant with clomid 100mg amitriptyline 25 mg slapen cipro memorandum of incorporation nizoral compresse da 200mg prednisone once daily can clomid be taken on day 7 doctors in richmond va for erectile dysfunction chef de produit plavix lexapro better sleep topamax pupils pearl chemist xenical 120mg can seroquel cause leg swelling information about diflucan 50 mg on zoloft while pregnant zithromax 37.5 ml precio avodart el salvador sito sicuro per acquisto viagra aciclovir oral dosis en ni?os cipro private company registration will i notice going from 100mg of zoloft to 150 if i am zithromax can i take clindamycin are metronidazole pills used to cure sti price lisinopril china levothyroxine canine strattera 40 mg vs adderall fluconazole liver side effects spironolactone and itching quais as chances de engravidar com clomid cialis commercial opera how many drops of ciprodex for swimmers ear can you take cialis with alpha blockers sildenafil citrate tablets ip vigora 100 dosaggio flagyl in acquario premarin 0.3 mg tablet finasteride e cataratta is amoxicillin kosher aciclovir contro brufoli obat telmisartan boehringer levitra 5 mg history of albuterol sulfate pronicy 4 cyproheptadine 5mg levitra and arrhythmia long term prednisone effects hair texture sildenafil super active

Why JP2 Should NOT Be Beatified

A humble response to the objections.
by Matthew Schneider, LC | Source:
Bl. John Paul II! Hooray! But wait, a few huddle in the corner and in hushed tones question if our late Pope was a saint. These whisperers, who are generally orthodox Catholics (liberals, heretics or quacks wouldn’t care for beatifications in the first place), raise some seemingly legitimate arguments regarding his beatification. If you want all the Pope’s heroic virtue, read the official decree; here I want to address the reasonable but false arguments against it. 3 categories of arguments predominate: he seemed to promote other religions, he did not punish the deviant sufficiently, and the Church does not look ideal after his reign.
Beatification requires two things: a miracle, which here is a matter for doctors, and a life of heroic virtue, which some claim was not universal in John Paul’s life as saints require. Heroic virtue implies all the virtues, not just some, unto death, so no part of John Paul II’s life can be against virtue.
Other religions
October 27, 1986, Pope John Paul II convoked a meeting in Assisi for religious leaders to pray for world peace. It has been called the interfaith prayer meeting, as the Pope encouraged the other religious leaders to pray for peace. It seems impossible to pray together unless you pray to the same God but many pray in a manner opposed to the Gospel. Additionally, while visiting a mosque, John Paul kissed the Koran.
The meeting in Assisi, however, had no common prayer. It was a meeting to encourage all religious people to pray for peace. Since we Catholics are the biggest religion in the world, it only seems appropriate that we organized it – which was done through the Pontifical Commission Iustitia et Pax (Justice and Peace), not the Pontifical Council for Inter-religious Dialogue to clarify it was a peace meeting. Is it better that a Hindu doesn’t pray, prays to Vishnu to destroy his enemies, or prays to Vishnu for peace? It is obvious that the third is best and closest to the Gospel, and hence the Pope’s initiative was correct. Card. Ratzinger skipped the original meeting, over concerns regarding the very misinterpretations that followed it, but as Pope, he just announced a similar event on the 25th anniversary this fall.
The Pope once kissed the Koran, but he also kissed the ground dozens of times, and kissed hundreds of babies. The latter two obviously don’t imply he worshiped Gaia or a fertility goddess, so why insist that the former means he worshiped Allah. A kiss is a sign of respect, not necessarily a sign of worship. The fact that Koran contains many good moral teachings, despite errors, that have guided a billion souls live well makes it a document worthy of respect – just like the American Constitution.
In Redemptoris Missio, Pope John Paul II explained the Catholic understanding of other religions: “Whatever the Spirit brings about in … religions, serves as a preparation for the Gospel and can only be understood in reference to Christ, the Word who took flesh by the power of the Spirit.” (#5) His basic teaching is that these religions prepare for and are fully explained in Jesus Christ. It is clear that these religions in themselves do not save as was further clarified in Dominus Iesus, which he personally approved: “There is only one salvific economy of the One and Triune God, realized in the mystery of the incarnation, death, and resurrection of the Son of God, actualized with the cooperation of the Holy Spirit, and extended in its salvific value to all humanity and to the entire universe.” (#12)
Inaction on mental and moral deviance
Everyone in Catholic Church admits that there have been some heretical theologians and some unfaithful priests, but what did the Pope do about it? Basically nothing, some answer: look there were only a handful of theologians condemned; the Vatican knew about Fr X’s sins and he remained in the priesthood for 10 more years. St. Louis IX lead two unsuccessful crusades – in the 7th he lost his army and was captured, and in the 8th he died of a stomach ailment and the crusade ended at Tunis – so making decisions which seem imprudent in hindsight doesn’t disprove sanctity. We have to view these decisions from the moment they were made with the information on hand.
Even though the Pope has universal authority in the Church it may not always be prudent to use it. Unorthodox theologians who strayed enough to be condemned by John Paul II wear it as a badge of honor, plus get plenty of interviews with the press – twisted but true. Limiting their publicity seems like a good reason to limit the number condemned, only condemning the grossest heretics.
Most of us, I think, were shocked when we heard the extent of moral crimes committed by priests. I, for one, assumed that every priest choose the priesthood for positive reasons and could not imagine someone doing it with the intent to harm God’s children. It is unreasonable to expect the Pope to be able to remove every morally inept priest from the priesthood, as the Church is not absolutely centralized as some wish – the Pope has final judgment but he relies on others to initiate and process these actions. One other aspect hidden from the general view is that many psychologists told Church leaders they could cure these offenders with a little therapy, which, of course, failed. However, you can’t blame someone for deferring to an expert on the subject. Now remember the majority of these cases were of a homosexual nature and Pope John Paul worked to clean up seminaries to keep such people out of the priesthood – he issued two apostolic visitations of American seminaries (on this point some will argue that the first one was totally ineffective as many seminaries just put on a show for the visitors but the visitors themselves, not the Pope, need to answer for that). In hindsight, I am sure that he would admit some errors, but at the moment, the decisions seemed prudential.
An imperfect Church
I think we could all admit that the Church is not in a perfect situation now, only a few years after John Paul’s pontificate. This is used as an argument against his beatification in two ways, a stronger form which makes him responsible, and a weaker form that says we should wait to see the effects of his pontificate. They follow from the simple Gospel truth that you will know a tree by its fruits. No matter what official power the Pope has, he can’t make every Catholic show up at Sunday Mass, sorry. The role of each of us, and the Pope all the more, is to propose the Gospel as a way of life with love, not to impose it. There are a million factors that could cause declining Mass attendance in certain places and among certain population segments, most of which are beyond the Pope’s control. It is clear he tried to encourage Mass attendance and vocations but you can’t blame him for every foible at a parish-level. It is interesting to note that during his pontificate, the number of seminarians worldwide almost doubled from 63,882 in 1978 to 112,643 in 2002 (Ignatius Insight).
Now a brief word on waiting, even if the usual 5-year period was not waived, I suspect we would have seen this beatification before 2015, the effects of his life are clearly visible, and beatification means the person lived as a saint, not that every act have a positive long-term impact. Given the cries, “Santo Subito!” (Saint Now!) at his funeral vs. the realistic issues that I have tried to briefly address here, skipping the waiting period but requiring full rigor, a middle road, seems prudential.
John Paul II was an example of holiness for us all. Despite some misunderstandings, some decisions that in hindsight seem inopportune, and despite an imperfect Church, he deserves to be beatified. I conclude with the Card. Ratzinger’s words at the Holy Father’s funeral, “We can be sure that our beloved Pope is standing today at the window of the Father’s house, that he sees us and blesses us.” Bl. John Paul II, pray for us.

About the Author:
Matthew Schneider, LC studies for the priesthood in Rome.  He can be reached at


Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Published by: Shin
Date: 2011-02-22 08:15:39
I truly didn't care for the deceptive nature of this article's title. If we're to accept the premise that Pope John Paul IInd was an example for us all, it would be an understatement to say at the least we're going to have some pretty troublesome examples from now on and in future, which would be a great departure from the previous meaning and quality of sainthood. The saint is to be a sign of contradiction to the world, not a sign which the world loves, because it is not admonished by it. There were so many key neglects, and so many key scandals during this pontificate. Those neglected, suffered invisibly and in silence, while with ambiguous words rather than clear words and significant deeds the people were preached to. The official documents, the changes to the liturgical books, the selective enforcement of canon law... If we assume ignorance or simple mistakes as the excuse, nevertheless the problem of poor example remains. And it is a hard assumption to reasonably make, given the good example given by so many previous popes which was certainly a model known to this last pope -- the model of these popes and saints, if truly followed, would have had a different result. I think perhaps that if the Pope were, by some loophole, in Heaven, the last thing he would want, would be his own canonization. Those who desire this cause, seem to desire it because of popularity and personality, but how many people can read the works of Pope John Paul IInd and say they are clear and directly deal with the problems of the day, and helpful to all people? And how can his lack of good deeds in regards to all the people who suffered unjustly due to lack of enforcement of canon law, be a model for any future pope? Shall future popes look to their lives as being possibly saintly with such a tragic failure? Neglect in canonical discipline, neglect in justice, neglect in preaching, neglect in shepherding. . . The good shepherd protects the sheep from the wolves, rather than giving them positions as assistant shepherds.

Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular