850 mg of metformin and sore breasts and cramp zyprexa for chronic insomnia taking probiotics with flagyl metronidazole nausea and headaches banganderson.co.uk lechatnoirrestaurant.com weltrowska.com.pl can i take cipro with zantac tome cytotec y aun sigo sangrando ibicisi.com cialis 20 mg boite fluconazole 800 mg viagra if one not enough flagyl compadable with zosyn inderal retard 80 mg uk adas-israel.org insideinsights.net 1819wine.com amlodipine and atenolol combination adiconsult.pl how many mg of remeron are equal to ativan iphone-accessory.cn ondansetron hcl untuk ibu hamil aman mayo clinic viagra and blood clots chengdong.net generic cialis fedex overnight paypal cipro fiyat can u buy amoxicillin over the counter uk can prednisone cause loose stools in dogs generic atomoxetine south africa montelukast and fexofenadine hydrochloride tablets mikezielinski.com furosemide syrup image india drink albuterol sulfate inhalation solution michaelgahler.de ip4b.de lopressor and fish oil are there natural viagra herbs in ligiuid forms zofran 4 mg dosage for nausea order neurontin no prescription charis247.org hillsidesanctuary.com taking hydrocodone and clonidine together adalat cr mims celexa not helping depression levitra 10mg 20mg tamoxifen side effects in men atenolol svt unesco-iicas.org generic wellbutrin sr mylan how to take cialis soft tab cost of meloxicam without insurance allegra 24 hour 90 count happydeal4u.com can to many irbesartan hydro kill you tetracycline for tooth abscesses misoprostol venta en neuquen high bilirubin generic finasteride teen dude take viagra and fuck girl nightanddaysoireeanimation.com ciprofloxacin ld50 phenergan strong sleeping tablets ebay africanamericanimages.us micardis causes angioedema apo olanzapine street price upd315.com how many pill come in valtrex venta en medelln orlistat pastillas para adelgazar lisinopril with metoprolol baclofen 10 mg ivax muteber.com generic mircette azurette citalopram wellbutrin side effects vendo misoprostol en temuco streetstylesinfo.com lamisil gland nightanddaysoireeanimation.com how fast can you get pregnant while taking metformin single dose of diflucan for yeast infection ondansetron m 732 where to buy flagyl for humans 500 mg will cephalexin help my sore throat a1commerce.com imajji.com tenormin 40 bactrim vias urinarias prednisone six day pack directions spironolactone peak time progesteron cytotec en cd obregon andiescafenapavalley.com is lisinopril hctz contraindicated to myelography cialis argentina can dexamethasone treat pityriasis rosea bluedays.com shawniverse.com buspar 10 mg only at bedtime dosis diarias de cialis how long apart should you take amoxiling 3 times a days haltner.com generic viagra cheapest sildenafil citrate levitra 20 ankara does cipro make you pee more xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai clopidogrel financial aid lisinopril mood swings upd315.com acyclovir vs alcohol para que serve o rem?dio aciclovir pioglitazone plus metformin ebodesign.com axellerata.com hopemedicaleducation.com boredstop.com viagra generic london muteber.com can i take 2 20mg cialis at a time taking prochlorperazine when on anti depresants adv-re.com does tamoxifen always cause side effects site de pasquale cipro neto does zoloft stop obsessive thoughts what is the side effect of furosemide effects of popping sertraline buy rizatriptan benzoate online india acyclovir 800 mg dosage for cold sores escitalopram efectos colaterales ugatipoffclub.com dexilant and zoloft how long do i have to take finasteride 25 mg amitriptyline uses other than depression twospy.com clomid and late menstruation muteber.com metspirit.com dapoxetine kosten cyproheptadine for toddlers online viagra prescription online piroxicam 1x20mg obat untuk period 6 days late clomid constipation avastan.pl cymbalta attacchi di panico purchase augmentin synthroid 50 bula sevrage abilify 5mg lipitor allergy cerisdieventi.com eeroaarnio.cz veziris.com tooth pain antibiotics in india nas farmacias na belgica existe cytotec lamisil cream 4 weeks clomid 3 or 5 days what can be used instead of albuterol sulfate atarax fiyati isotretinoin 40mg price monthly supply clomid du 3 au 7 jour iheartjonahbees.net do lamisil tablets work what is the work of ketoconazole tablets usp 200mg mensipox ciprofloxacin obat buat apa western-showline.de do i need a prescription for metronidazole gel depression cymbalta 60 mg baclofen generic price para que sirve clomiphene citrate 150mg zoloft kinetics mediatrax.com levitra appearance doxycycline candidiasis ic ciprofloxacin hcl 500 sildenafil citrate ip powder augmentin for cats without a rx can you take viagra with buspare and clodapine aciclovir pump bajrangibhaijaanboxofficecollection.org what is tab misoprostol 600 mcg use for fluconazole 500mg estradiol aqueous sildenafil hard on gel lamisil kr?©m 15g cialis past their sell date are they ok imajji.com veran d piroxicam 20 mg para que sirve celexa reglan mixing nexium and prevacid singulair one month free olmesartan medoxomil 40 mg celebrex or meloxicam for prostatitis what to expect from using viagra zyvox coupons discounts uzdrowisko-ewa.pl zovirax labiale cerotti prezzo line coupons for viagra informatyk-szczecin.com.pl can i take ibprofen next day after finishing clomid amoxicillin and diarrhea in dogs allegra manufacturer fluconazole dossge for fungal imfection of inner ear zithromax 4 pills at once will still work with alcohol mikezielinski.com liver propecia finasteride pill size metro2034.pl is augmentin stronger than penicillin irbesartan durch die nase ziehen gabapentin is it safe pain beribak.com viagra canada do need prescription efek samping clozapine 25 mg boots chemist viagra retail price el misoprostol es peligroso allegra de leon delli how to hv a longer erection even if you cum cialis dose for men how long does it take for oral metronidazole work gabapentin 300 mg capsule information iphone5sreview.nl metformin lost too much weight cialis yuksek tansiyon mikedekle.com ciprofloxacino glaucoma nursing interventions on ng patients with flomax order cialis online us pharmacy vizioescort.com side effects of 20 mg lexapro watseco.com cymbalta generic name duloxetine hydrochloride que pasa si no hay sangrado con cytotec boobisaweekendword.com .05 levothyroxine cause eye problems cuidados despues de usar cytotec batterymedix.com masturbating then taking levitra michellestockman.com en que te puede ayudar metformin er 500 mg 24hr asi.wpgsystem.com alisongreenwoodphotography.com luvox cr generic name ondansetron 4 mg and bentyl najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl manfaat suspensi farizol metronidazole hastings-print.co.uk buspirone 7 mg bactrim 400 mg for uti chloramphenicol comprimidos para que serve ventolin out of date early pregnancy signs for woman on clomiphene medievalcostumesandgifts.com africanamericanimages.us kamagra bestellen billig can you take paxil without food terbinafine 250 mg en espanol western-showline.de android-az.com doxycycline 200 mg syphilis amitriptyline cat dilated pupils dose of glucophage for pcos levofloxacin bei akne how long take doxycycline to work in cats posso prendere augmentin e zerinol insieme akathisia after stop taking celexa baclofen oral solution ip cialis permanent side effects avastan.pl viagra lot numbers nexium voor babies hastings-print.co.uk bringing viagra from turkey asi.wpgsystem.com can you take aleve and ciprofloxacin together is lexapro vegan restasis and lipitor diet with accutane nexium recreational walan.com meblebrzozowe24.pl viagra and lorazepam where to viagra in qatar why do u gain weight on paxil western-showline.de worldtravelandtourservices.com clindoxyl gel accutane napabusinessadvantage.com biggest dose of cipro buy depo provera injection australia doxycycline 100 mg for acne and hair loss paxil reviews for social anxiety cuanto dura el efecto del priligy metronidazole resistant parasites im-still-learning.com bupkoeln.de cymbalta kostar cipronne tablet abilify laihduttaa hashtonim.com panax ginseng and wellbutrin dose rate doxycycline for dogs nexium 20mg dosierung bluedays.com how bupropion stop smoking nightanddaysoireeanimation.com bushidozazen.com levofloxacin therapeutic class para que se utiliza la cialis hashtonim.com mycontradictions.com propranolol anabolic levaquin 500 levitra is made by bayer can i drink alcohol whilst taking mirtazapine 15mg besten viagra witze coleshill viagra capital of uk moravskavina.cz internationalintellectualproperty.org bv metronidazole gel side effects propecia body hair forum tisari adalat move naproxeno 500 mg la sante could get u high diflucan available india anafranil e allucinazioni moonman.io is 20mg citalopram fast acting wpmodder.com zyprexa 5 mg les effets secondaires clopidogrel dipyridamole stroke metformin abilify azithromycin low heart rate wendy-unes.com does 100mg viagra lenthen ijackulation time purchase elavil howdotofound should i take viagra3000mg on empty stomach strattera 25 mg street value pleiotrophic effect of metformin cuanto dura efecto viagra 100 mg flagyl pregnancy how long does it take for cytotec to work keflex bowel movement azfamilylawattorney.com doxycycline can cure stds does cialis come in 50 mg castinternational.org can lisinopril cause nerve damage clomid percentage of multiple births can daily cialis help with premature ejaculation jual cabergoline di surabaya amoxicillin flu abilify pour qui lisinopril with clonidine metoprolol mecanism de actiune cutting lexapro dosage hair loss levaquin syndrome microgestin and zoloft buy doxycycline hereisthebestin best site buy nolvadex 100mg doxycycline wound azithromycin and pcn allergies idesignawards.com withdrawal cymbalta brain zaps weltrowska.com.pl azithromycin 500 mg wat they for does cialis do antibiotics work if you drink alcohol septra ds 160 finasteride generic in malaysia canadian cialis generic pharmacy metspirit.com how fast does the first dose of cialis work antibiotics gsk athlone cardizem 180 cytotec 200 mcg nutrients to help taper prednisone for dog muslimdate.com voltaren rapid 25 gluten free carrepairmanualdoc.com ciprofloxacino na infec??o urinaria jwapr.com gabapentin and myofascial pain liquid viagra women staph resistant allergic to zithromax azascd.org puedo usar cytotec 2 semanas embarazo aneyron.com metoprolol succinate 100mg prednisone itching in dogs azyter azithromycin ethinylestradiol cyproteronacetaat bijsluiter viagra tablets no prescription symptoms of cephalexin vermogensbeheer.net apparel-chic.com sandoz azithromycin 500 for dog bite can gabapentin cause wetting the bed men take flagyl 500mg quanto costa una scatola di cialis in farmacia dirffence between tratul and voltaren iv augmentin pediatric dose what is the best way to wean off duloxetine cipro treatment for pyelonephritis mirtazapine 30mg tablets used olanzapine side effects gum problems metformin teva, metformin can doxylamine succinate be taken with antidepressant zovirax patches use mycities.com.au feeling good on 20mg of nolvadex pct myexactamundo.com azithromycin tablets cost in india clomid rapporti sessuali wirkweise von allopurinol wrse-modelling.org.uk medicamento cipro 500mg how use pregnant women montelukast sodium 6 rounds of clomid blue cross blue shield cialis coverage flagyl cost at walmart neurontin vs lyrica bipolar ip4b.de clomid d.m pills review online pharmacy cialis forum equivalent of gabapentin tseworldgolf.com augmentin 1.2 ing price ajo viagra de los pobres evista 60 mg dosage does amoxicillin 875 cause a rash can u snort mirtazapine vietnamese diet pills how long will viagra pill last in your body prednisone ulcerative colitis not working same and cymbalta interaction revista 23 augmentin fistula proscar side effects weight gain aciclovir quanto tempo melhora diflucan prescription ireland how many 20ml cialis can you take zovirax for cats cost buying viagra in the dominican republic buspar pap outlet.cz cytotec misoprostol em piracicaba tab.ketoconazole purchase online hywt.com azithromycin 250 mg tablet side effects can you swallow chewable singulair ciprofloxacin eye drops expiration date propranolol in central tremor dosing ondansetron 2mg harga propecia dosage instructions can i get pregnant with desogestrel pre how long does it take to withdraw from propecia diltiazem hcl er hot flashes prescribing levitra can bupropion hcl kill you propecia recuperarpelo lamisil 1 cream novartis esoxhunter.com doxycycline hyclate for sebaceous cysts woodmizer.org.pl what is the street value of hydroxyzine pam healthpromotionadvocates.org zithromax for bartonella tengo 6 semanas de embarazo puedo usar cytotec 80 mg prednisone shot staxyn 10mg vs levitra 20 mg zyprexa kullanimi cuales son los 6 actos del habla vigora fertilizer spreader parts que cuesta viagra ocella vs drospirenone and ethinyl estradiol aciclovir et grossesse novo sertraline designtide.jp hbtaoxian.com cialis original barato paracitomal amoxcicaline ciprofloxin leofloxin is volcano 20 vardenafil 20 is cialis ok to take if 2 months out of date amitriptyline hcl and ambien provera 2.5 mg side effects chelated magnesium treats levaquin toxicity is 2 azithromycin pills enough to get better drug interactions with valium baclofen and hydrocodone generic plavix cost ireland can you take kalms with levothyroxine viagra dhe efektet e saj aleskons.ru napabusinessadvantage.com generic prednisone cvs muteber.com viagra aprasymas where in london can i buy kamagra pills forum amigosdeamerica.org hpaulsantmire.com valsartan 40 mg tab kamerscuracao.net how long does it take celebrex to be effective is wellbutrin an barbiturates doxycycline and hpv erythromycin medicine into urdu henrycavillfan.org

Galileo’s Contribution to the Church

A reflection on the life and works of Galileo
by Joseph A’Hearn, LC | Source: Catholic.net

Galileo was definitely not a martyr of science. In fact, he was mistaken in important aspects. Today we know that the tides are caused by the gravitational influence of the Moon and the Sun, not the motion of the Earth. We know that the Sun is not the center of the universe, but just another star in the Milky Way that orbits the center of our galaxy, which is also in motion. 

We should not hastily conclude that Galileo didn’t make any contribution to science. Although he wasn’t right on in all of his theories, it is evident that he did contribute notably to scientific progress. He is even known as the founder of modern science. His contribution in the field of astronomy consists, above all, in his astronomical observations with different telescopes that he constructed by himself. Galileo saw the roughness of the Moon’s surface, four satellites of Jupiter, sunspots, the phases of Venus, stars that are invisible to the naked eye, and nebulae. Galileo knew that other astronomers would carry these observations further, but he was the first one who raised an eyepiece to the heavens and caused a chain reaction of astronomical discoveries. 

What is seldom considered is how Galileo helped the Church, especially in her understanding of the harmony between faith and reason, not merely in theory, which had already been developed during the age of Scholasticism, but in the face of new discoveries in science. Nevertheless, weren’t they ecclesiastics of the Catholic Church who condemned him to house arrest and prohibited him from spreading the Copernican doctrine? To understand his contributions, it is necessary to know the historical and cultural context and the relationship between Galileo and the Church. Here I will not elaborate the entire history; rather, I only intend to mention some necessary considerations.

Copernicus died in 1543, and that same year his book, De Revolutionibus, was published, declaring that the Sun was the center of the universe, and that everything went around the Sun. Andreas Osiander received from the hands of Copernicus (who was already on his deathbed) the text of De Revolutionibus for publication. Osiander, however, decided first to write a preface to the book, perhaps without Copernicus’s authorization. According to this preface, the Copernican hypothesis was not dealing with the reality of the universe. It was only an alternative mathematical method to make predictions. For this reason, Osiander said it was unnecessary to take the Copernican hypothesis seriously. That is why ecclesiastics did not condemn Copernicanism until 1616, when some astronomers did in fact begin to take it seriously. The explosion of a supernova in 1604 called into question the Ptolemaic doctrine of the incorruptibility of the heavens. The doubt increased when the observations Galileo started in 1609 showed that some celestial objects did not orbit the Earth. 

The possibility that Copernican doctrines would turn out correct seemed to shake the foundations of Christian theology, which according to many theologians was connected to Aristotelian cosmology. Aristotle, Ptolemy, St. Thomas Aquinas, and many great thinkers and astronomers had considered the Earth as the center of the universe. The theory of the four elements of the sublunar world and of ether for the world beyond the Moon dominated for many centuries. Sacred Scripture, as well, seemingly supported geocentrism. It did not fit in the minds of the ecclesiastics that Scripture or St. Thomas or Aristotle could be wrong in this. Besides, our experience tells us that the Earth doesn’t move. In the age of the Counterreformation, who was Galileo to put into check the doctrine believed for so many centuries? He had not even received the minor orders like Copernicus, neither had he studied theology like the Jesuits who disagreed with him. Galileo was officially the first mathematician of the Great Duke of Tuscany. It was an important and respected position. Nevertheless, this position did not provide him with an authoritative voice in theology. 

The ecclesiastics could not deny the facts, though. Some, like the Jesuit Clavius, dedicated the rest of their lives to explain how the recently observed phenomena could be compatible with Aristotelian doctrine. Others, like Christopher Borro, studied the hypothesis of Tycho Brahe, who said that the planets went around the Sun while the Sun orbited the Earth. The ecclesiastics came to the point of seeing without much difficulty that the heavens were corruptible, but the doctrine of geocentrism remained untouchable. They allowed heliocentrism to be spoken about as a means to calculate the positions of the stars and planets, but not as an explanation of reality. Galileo, however, kept insisting. It was then that the need to clarify the matter arose. 

1616 was the year of the first judgment about Copernicanism. Three books that supported the Copernican doctrine were condemned. Two of them were only suspended until corrected. The name of Galileo was not even mentioned in the process. Cardinal Bellarmine, one of the most renowned theologians of the Church back then, only warned Galileo not to defend the Copernican theory. Galileo submitted and asked Cardinal Bellarmine for a certificate of this warning, which he did receive.

Galileo was the friend of Cardinal Maffeo Barberini and had helped his nephew, Francisco Barberini, obtain his doctorate in the University of Pisa. When Maffeo Barberini was elected Pope in 1623, he raised his nephew to the College of Cardinals. Two other freinds of Galileo had important positions in the Church, Giovanni Ciampoli and Virginio Cesarini. On the other hand, Galileo made himself the enemy of the Jesuits, first of Orazio Grassi because of their dispute over comets; and, later, of Christopher Scheiner, because of their controversy over sunspots. Scheiner also said that if geocentrism turned out false, then it would be more prudent to adhere to Tycho’s alternative since it didn’t contradict the Scriptures. 

Galileo was given an imprimatur in 1632 for his Dialogue, but without revealing that he had been given a warning in 1616. A few months later, the Pope summoned him to Rome. 

Galileo was not a heretic, but neither was he a saint. He was not exemplary in his personal life, which we are not going to consider, nor in his way of responding to the prudent judgments of the Church. After demanding that Sacred Scripture be interpreted not literally, but allegorically, he quoted the famous phrase of Baronius: “Spiritui Sancto mentem fuisse nos docere quomodo ad caelum eatur, non quomodo caelum gradiatur,” as if nothing in the Bible had any authority at all over the physical world. Then he tried to show how Sacred Scripture supported the Copernican hypothesis. Moreover, while he demanded that the first criterion of our knowledge be empirical observation and that the interpretation of Sacred Scripture should conform itself with these observations, he showed no real proofs in favor of Copernicanism. These proofs would still not be produced for a long time: in 1837 Bessel demonstrated the Earth’s motion using stellar parallax; and in 1851 Foucault proved the same thing using a pendulum. In that case, Bellarmine was right when he told Galileo to consider the Copernican system a hypothesis until there were irrefutable demonstrative proofs in its favor. 

Neither was Galileo prudent in the publication of some of his works. In his Dialogue he presented in the mouth of Simplicius, the ridiculous Aristotelian, the argument that Pope Urban VIII (previously Maffeo Barberini) had told him personally over the impossibility of certitude in scientific theories. Simplicio said that if we tried to explain the Earth’s motion with the tides, we would be limiting divine power and wisdom. God could “confer reciprocal movement to the element of water,” for God is all-powerful, whereas our explanations have their limits. Galileo testified that he didn’t realize it, but that did not appease the Pope. In addition, after his condemnation, Galileo allowed his Dialogue to be translated into Latin and published in Germany. Thus he did not fulfill his oath of 1633.
This does not mean that he did not leave behind a legacy both in science and in the Catholic Church, which he remained always a member of. Galileo was right in some respects regarding the interpretation of the Scriptures. According to some ecclesiastics, the Fathers of the Church had been unanimous in the literal interpretation of the Bible passages that referred to the motion of the Sun and the Earth. In this case they were to be followed blindly, for the Council of Trent had given this norm: “In matters of faith and morals [...] no one relying on his own judgment and distorting the Sacred Scriptures according to his own conceptions, shall dare to interpret them contrary to that sense which Holy Mother Church [...] has held and does hold, or even contrary to the unanimous agreement of the Fathers, even though such interpretations were not at any time to be published.” The Fathers, however, had not been unanimous. Galileo used almost the very exegetical principles that Saint Augustine employed in his commentary to Genesis (De Genesi ad litteram). Nonetheless, this was not even an issue of faith or morals, but only a scientific one. 

The Catholic Church has learned from the Galileo case this lesson of criteriology and prudence. Concerning criteriology, John Paul II recognized in his speech on 31 October 1992: “In reality, the Scriptures do not deal with the details of the physical world, whose knowledge is confined to human experience and reasoning.” Concerning prudence, in the same speech the Pope quoted a letter of Saint Robert Bellarmine to Father Foscarini: “In the presence of eventual scientific proofs [...] it would be ‘better to say that we don’t understand it, instead of stating that what is demonstrated is false.’” 

This is why, for example, the Magisterium of the Church has not pronounced anything about the existence of extraterrestrials. Science is discovering more and more how hard it is to fit all the conditions for there to be life on any planet, and the Bible tells us that Jesus died once and for all for the salvation of mankind. Nevertheless, the question about the possibility of the existence of life on another planet remains open. Perhaps someday extraterrestrial life forms will be discovered. Applying to this possibility what Bellarmine said in the already quoted letter: “Then it would be necessary to go through with the utmost consideration in explaining the Scriptures that seem contrary.” 

“Sacred Scripture can never be mistaken,” wrote Galileo in his letter to Benedetto Castelli. It’s true, since reason and faith never contradict each other. They are two distinct sources for knowledge of the truth, and they also have some points in common. The possibility of this relation between science and faith is precisely another lesson that has been learned, thanks to Galileo. 

The Catholic Church has never been an enemy to scientific development. It is enough to take into account that several pioneers of the sciences were Catholic priests: Gregor Mendel, Georges Lemaître, Pierre Gassendi, and Saint Albert the Great, just to name a few, among so many others that could be mentioned.
“Faith and reason are like two wings on which the human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth” (Fides et ratio, introduction). In the light of what we have seen, Galileo should not be considered a sign of contradiction, but rather a sign of unity between science and faith. 

Joseph A'Hearn, LC studies for the priesthood in Rome.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular