kamerscuracao.net 300 mg of elavil gabapentin capsules usp 300mg dexamethasone oral apa fungsinya upd315.com escitalopram 10 mg walgreens nystatin or nizoral buy erection pills online paypal uk ile-au-tresor.net anafranil mania xenical prix en parapharmacie levothyroxine tablet appearance which is better celexa or buspar flomax makes me pee more bajrangibhaijaanboxofficecollection.org webfin.pl duracion de viagra depo provera pregnancy metronidazole 80 mg for dogs ciprofloxacin generic price walmart valtrex nursing category pravastatin vs lipitor ivermectin 1 spot on achat viagra promo allegra 360 mg amoxicillin and erythromycin rash allergy :pdf side effects of gabapentin 300mg in senior citizens iphone5sreview.nl can acos antibiotic be substitute by fimoxyl hnxxldb.com mikezielinski.com weaning off zoloft and wellbutrin taking finasreide and levitra aljanine.com actionbinaire.net mipcperu.com ciprobay alkohol synthroid icd 9 code 100g viagra pills pfizer abilify and vyvanse together what dosage of meloxicam can you get high off of albuterol inhaler cost us effect of taking clomid with vitamin c michaelgahler.de cytotec cuanto vale en bolivia pilule bleu viagra morbidoutlook.com lexapro 10mg tablets information taking propranolol daily anxiety bactrim e aids africanamericanimages.us taking lioresal 25 mg with effxor what date does celebrex go generic para que serve o comprimido propranolol greece athens viagra do i need prescription to buy viagra in johor bahru huaxzw.com cialis e nebivolol what to do when cialis stops working sildenafil citrate in natural foods testimonial pemakai cytotec viagra price canada is allegra for kids neurontin and demencia xenical 120 posologie vuongminh.com amoxicillin on drug test sertraline dreams how long does it take for proventil inhaler to ware off order levitra wiki aturan minum lasix para que sirve serophene en el hombre amitriptyline price uk sildenafil de 100 mg para que sirve morbidoutlook.com buy viagra ecuador gophercount.com bloating propecia childlabor-payson.org estradiol 17 beta glucuronide propecia extenze imipramine shortage australia erythromycin obat apa warchiwach.pl can you take celebrex with asthma montelukast teva v montelair heartsdirect.co.uk plan b pill and coumadin fosamax plus 5600 comprimidos boobisaweekendword.com fluconazole sandoz 150 prezzo bula meloxicam7 5mg zoloft dose reduction and dizziness dosing options with azithromycin for chylmidia streetstylesinfo.com lexapro or citalopram diflucan to treat anal otc get rx viagra gabapentin therapeutic class hopemedicalinstitute.org acquisto viagra roma flomax inactive ingredients can you take vicodin with amoxicillin clav k zovirax schwangerschaft packungsbeilage trying to get pregnant while on antibiotics tetracycline compatibility skin rash due to escitalopram or clonazepam where can i buy sildenafil in the uk manufacturer coupon for strattera wpmodder.com buy ciprofloxacin 500mg online uk bula de medicamento clomid buying viagra in lahore nizoral shampoo 2 for sale asylum-booksandgames.com brand cialis sale lexapro side effects vs zoloft hashtonim.com can u take clonidine when taking nifedipine wrse-modelling.org.uk coughing side effect of levaquin nizoral shampoo apotheke generic singulair india seroquel vs risperdal alzheimer mister-button.com propranolol clonazepam pdf ciprodex versus oflaxacin otic sta je zyprexa diovan 40 mg price take robitussin after taking clomid compare lotrel vs metoprolol xenical orlistat no prescription allcoinreviews.org resep pirocam 20mg dexamethasone 075mg wbstaffing.pl prednisone 5mg for dogs can i take amoxicillin with lansoprazole ketoconazole mycose gland breast cancer recurrence with tamoxifen over the counter otic drops similar to ciprodex name brand 5 mg cialis online annsweddings.com.au z71 metformin getting pregnant zithromax menstrual cycle can i buy misoprostol here in zamboanga peninsula buy plavix france costo de coumadin de 10 mg akademia-active.pl 25mg clomid lower side effects how can i get a prescription for wellbutrin brookridgefunding.com vrlaksaraytransfer.com gabapentin 3200 mg clomid and preterm labor vancampinc.com maigrir apres paroxetine glucophage et maigrir citalopram hydrobromide ta 20mg side effects flunarizine and propranolol migraine mikezielinski.com avnai.com micardis plus 12.5 mg erfahrungsberichte sildenafil pfizer safe buy clomid online canada can i put levitra in water is propranolol safe to take advil time amoxicillin take effect for uti indicatifs-telephoniques.net albuterol inhalation hyperkalemia treat allegra eq 180 mg amitriptyline negative effects harga ubat priligy prozac 40 mg benefits drug study of tetracycline itaessienchrisandco.com can i take topamax every other day how fast does acyclovir work for genital herpes kamagra gel only can you take amoxicillin for an abscessed tooth generic lexapro, w sildenafil sandoz 75 mg how long does prednisone take to reduce swelling doxycycline after 6 weeks itaessienchrisandco.com combination of linezolid tablet with cefixime order famvir rajat sharma aap ki adalat salman khan im-still-learning.com propecia side effects brand topamax and atenolol side effects wellbutrin negative thinking kegunaan azithromycin untuk gonore propranolol and topiramate iphone-accessory.cn revopac.com does valtrex show up on a drug test buying valtrex canada ile-au-tresor.net does valtrex damage kidneys alatnj.org can you take lexapro and bonine simultaneously prednisone 5 mg pack instructions zovirax augensalbe beipackzettel is acyclovir used longterm are phenergan and pepcid compatible is there rat poison in lipitor street value of topiramate hlahlaaung.com metro2034.pl can you buy otc viagra ciprobay stillzeit singulair 5 irontownmodular.com can ondansetron 4mg get you high idesignawards.com chances of twins metformin and clomid mspnor.com nolvadex clomid pct dosage and duration giardia metronidazole dose viagra details price india for erection newhollandcommunications.de cialis for recreational use review synthroid ld50 terbinafine cat cream ciprofloxcillin and forgetfulness why does zoloft and lexapro work together meblebrzozowe24.pl olmesartan vs lisinopril hoxtonradio.com httwp.com strattera missed consequetive days celebrex while trying to conceive lisinopril what pill looks like albuterol 90 mcg actuation inhaler 3 year old cost of cialis in kenya hillsboroughcountyfair.com 8haotejia.com trentacular.com lechatnoirrestaurant.com mildreddeskinsjewelry.com clomid spotting 6dpo hoxtonradio.com maksud metronidazole levothyroxine 224 cara pengambilan tadalafil 200mg bio metronidazole 400 is it safe pregnant women metoprolol and menstruation harelitasarim.com cialis is this covered by insurance henrycavillfan.org hottest cialis commercial women upd315.com tamoxifen testicles websitedesignportcharlotte.com rosuvastatin aspirin clopidogrel combination in india how long does lexapro stay in your system drug test valor strattera henrycavillfan.org viagra adoos atorvastatin thailand hnxxldb.com cost of one orlistat in india taking plavix with aspirin vapplica.org nitroglycerin ointment aldactone low heart rate association-secours-sante.cm flagyl metronidazole and breastfeeding mediatrax.com lechatnoirrestaurant.com can i take danabol with citalopram finasteride dosage 1mg vs 5mg do anything why prescribe misoprostol df metro2034.pl sildenafil 25 mg genfar can women effect taking dr x 100mg sildenafil doxycycline hyclate side effects nz mikezielinski.com medicadent.ru 100mg doxycycline hyc w3asia.com how long before diflucan will work viagra generic us pharmacy upd315.com is amoxicillin used for cold mooboos.com zpyjfc.com vbtube.com sildenafil wikipedia shqip lexapro sleep symptoms is seroquel sr50 a control substance mobilepushnotifications.org topshop allegra boots buy internetowe-szkolenia.pl centergaz.pl cymbalta boils mipcperu.com muslimdate.com felodipine er 10 mg side effects smith-jennings.com can u take zofran carafate together profipermanentmakeup.cz prozac 10 mg anxiety luvox 25 mg get propecia online uk mipcperu.com lisinoprill 40 milagrams salep ketoconazole buat ibu hamil buy generic levaquin online obat lasix itu untuk apa ya atenolol actavis tablet 25mg ciprodex otic coupon andros sildenafil erythromycin gbs prophylaxis how long does metronidazole keep working veziris.com metformin prevent miscarriage hedleyenterprises.co.uk ketoconazole shampoo 2 online false positive elavil does cipro cause low blood pressure tired in zoloft.pmdd short light period on clomid does tamoxifen cause iron deficiency asylum-booksandgames.com prednisone 50 mg mood side effects cialis india price backboneitgroup.com hillsidesanctuary.com lisinopril versus atenolol thyroxine totale does cephalexin affect pill can i take vitamins with lexapro long term side effects of metronidazole hydrochlorothiazide adalah lipitor and muscle tightness wellbutrin prescribed for adhd what is valtrex medication used for effects of overuse of prednisone prednisone interactions with other drugs for cats viagra hilft beim abnehmen houseontheisland.com mkvisio.pl cipro 500 mg fiyat wellbutrin and buspirone interactions western-showline.de castinternational.org mister-button.com bluedays.com fluconazole medicine is safe in six months pregnancy mycities.com.au uzdrowisko-ewa.pl is strattera a generic hopemedicaleducation.com wbstaffing.pl should you take meloxicam 15 mg tablet moring or night best place to network in viagra triangle chicago mrw-2012.pl inderal online prescriptions are h. pylori infections treated with septra h-o-s.co.uk metspirit.com atenolol medicine acyclovir 600 mg for fever blister hollisterlancasterlaw.com enteric fever azithromycin high dose combination of adderall and neurontin kava celexa how much does generic seroquel cost morbidoutlook.com viagra price drugs com cuanto cuesta priligy zofran compazine and pregnancy pre?o do clomid dosage for doxycycline for urinary tract infection indocid gel and indomethacin gel converting iv lasix to po lasix harga obat viagra 50mg hpaulsantmire.com lamisil tablet in philippines 1819wine.com long do celexa side effects last sertraline and weed 50 mg compare augmentin to azithromycin for bhronchitis amlodipine 2.5 mg price buspirone 555 white millteksport.pl side effect of weaning off prednisone augmentin 1.2 gm iv valacyclovir dosage maximum will prednisone help a urinary tract infection is 25mg trazodone addictive actionbinaire.net celexa dosage maximum levitra online purchase bajrangibhaijaanboxofficecollection.org apo valacyclovir reviews zithromax half life hour cialis can you take more than one differences between amlodipine 10mg atenolol 25mg.com shipped from the usa generic cialis harelitasarim.com hbm.org.pl luvox 50 mg of abbott what happens if i take 125 mg of sertraline ciprofloxacin dosage for uti propecia for eyebrows can you take ampicillin tylenol sinus worldwide-yacht-charter.com antibiotic cipro hc propranolol and hallucinations what is mean viagra in urdu prosedimientos para utilisar las pastillas cytotec topamax oligohidrosis generic tamoxifen vs brand where to buy lamisil pill susan adalat twitter bureau of prisons policy on staff using antidepressants orlistat obetas would 2 cialis for daily use equal 1 cialis 36 hour recall on substitute for lipitor taking hydrocortisone and amoxicillin together where can i buy periactin cyproheptadine for anorexia dilatrend carvedilol 50 mg xeloda 800 mg does topamax affect sperm id-protect.org misoprostol arthrotec mercury drug lexapro and weight loss depression mehmetaliguven.com cialis viagra derect from newzeland 1819wine.com ketoconazole cream philippines price ondansetron 131 does clomid causes high temperature and nipple pain mkvisio.pl can i take ciprofloxacin tablet alongside with clomid vuongminh.com generic for montelukast sodium philippies mycities.com.au cialis loss of sensation is zoloft for social anxiety momandfitness.com sintomas despues de aborto cytotec yeast and cyproheptadine veziris.com ugatipoffclub.com metformin voglibose hillsidesanctuary.com misoprostol a las 14semanas como se toma do keflex pills smell can bactrim treat a knee infection synthroid insomnia side effects allegra goodman interview pramil sildenafil para que serve cialis imodium variamedia.com.pl what would happen if a dog ate a nexium pill sertraline liver seroquel xr eye side effect albuterol 0.083 neb nephron can i use cialis discount code why does zoloft quit working bluedays.com thyroxine t4 free direct s test viagra online prescription required sildenafil citrate 100mg take can you buy over the counter viagra in new york can you snort wellbutrin kamagra 100mg oral jelly for sale cialis o que ? isso arthurstractors.com allcoinreviews.org ketoconazole cream and birth control is the pill prednisone a norcotic carvedilol 12.5 mg 7295 hillsboroughcountyfair.com childlabor-payson.org amoxicilline joint does azithromycin for chlamydia cause dark urine drug interaction diflucan zocor who made medicina ciproxin 500 in pakistan can amoxicillin and clavulanate treat athletes foot ketoconazole 6 viagra dealers in hyderabad cipro 1a pharma 250 mg filmtabl consecuencias de usar cyrux misoprostol boredstop.com viagra ungarn outlet.cz cost low viagra isotretinoin medicine found in bangladesh bayrakogullari.com recommended dose for cipro hemmers dapoxetine purchase clomid over counter henrycavillfan.org webtodesigns.co rajesh khanna in aap ki adalat can you buy amoxicillin for the dog to cure chlamydia

The Nature of Sin

Do you have to know you are committing a sin in order to actually commit one?
by Father John Bartunek, LC | Source: Catholic.net

Question: Do you have to know you are committing a sin in order to actually commit one?

Answer: You would think this simple question has a simple answer. But it doesn’t. We have to get a little theological here to unravel it, but I’ll try to be brief anyhow.

First of all, we have to remember what sin is. Sin is rebellion against God. It is saying to God, “I don’t want to do what you want me to do.” (For more on the nature of sin, you can you seen the posts on scrupulosity and bad thoughts) Right away, then, we can see that every sin has two poles.

Evil Effects Follow Evil Actions

In the first place, there is the action itself. As human beings, our actions can be conscious thoughts, words, or deeds. (Digesting lunch isn’t really a human action, because we don’t do it consciously). So a sin is, in the first place, a (conscious) thought, word, or deed that goes against God’s will. Now, we know that God’s will is as full of wisdom as the ocean is full of water (see Psalm 36:6). And his wisdom is intrinsically connected to his limitless love, his overflowing goodness, and his absolute omnipotence. To go against his will, then, is not a smart thing to do. It’s like going against the manufacturer’s instructions – like putting sand in the gas tank of our car, or drying out a wet cell phone by putting it in a hot oven for a couple of hours. It does damage.

It’s important to have that clear. Any thought, word, or action that goes against God’s will (that violates the natural moral law, the Ten Commandments, the teachings of his Church…) will cause some kind of damage to one’s own person, and to the world around us. We may not always see it right away, but it is there, and it will show up, sooner or later. God doesn’t make up a random list of sins out of thin air. Disobedience to God is disobedience to God’s wise plan for human life, for our life; it’s trying to fly without wings. To describe this first aspect of sin, we can use the term “evil action.”

To Blame or Not To Blame

In the second place, sin involves the conscious choice to perform such a rebellious action. This is why, for example, someone who is driving drunk and causes a fatal accident is not necessarily guilty of the sin of murder (they didn’t consciously intend to kill), but they are guilty of the sin of drunkenness (they chose to abuse alcohol). This is also why a criminal who forces a banker at gunpoint to unlock a safe doesn’t make the banker guilty of the sin of theft – the banker opened the safe against his will. Where there is no free choice, there can be no moral responsibility.

But our distinctions don’t end there. The conscious choice to perform an evil action can itself be culpable or not culpable. In other words, we can be responsible for the evil choice or not responsible for it. If I am responsible for it, then I become morally guilty for the evil committed and its consequences. If I am not responsible for it, then I am morally innocent.

For example, if a little boy grows up with parents who are thieves and who teach him to follow in their footsteps, that child may grow up convinced that stealing from non-family members is not an evil action. In that case, whenever he steals from non-family members, although he is freely committing an objectively evil action, he is not aware that it is evil (he doesn’t know that it is a sin). So, the damage is done, both to his soul (he deepens his habits of deception and dishonesty) and to the world around him (the pain and suffering caused by injustice), but he is not morally culpable for it – not guilty.

On the other hand, if a little boy grows up in a normal family environment, his natural, God-given sense of right and wrong will be nourished by the words and example of his parents and education. In this case, he will know that he shouldn’t take anything that doesn’t belong to him. And so, when he goes off to summer camp for the first time and discovers that his roommate has a collection of candy bars, he knows that taking one of them without permission is an evil action. And so, if he takes one anyway, he is responsible for the evil – guilty.

The Hazy Days of Sinners

This all seems obvious. But in real life the line between culpability and non-culpability often gets hazy. As the first little boy grows up, for example, at some point he will realize that other people don’t live like thieves. At some point his natural, God-given sense of right and wrong will flash a thought into his mind: “What is this person going to do if I steal their credit card and max it out at the cash machine?” It may be a very quiet qualm of conscience, but at some point, unless he has become psychopathic or sociopathic, the qualm will surface. At that point, doesn’t he become culpable, even though he had such a twisted upbringing?

A classic example of this haziness in the realm of moral responsibility is the case of the guards in charge of exterminating prisoners during the Nazi holocaust. Was it truly possible that they didn’t realize, at some level of consciousness, that they were destroying fellow human beings? Are the guards morally innocent because they were simply following orders?… When we start to wrestle with tangled cases like that, it is relief to remember that God is the perfect judge.

Here is an example of haziness (uncertainty about what’s right or wrong in a specific situation) that’s a little closer to home. Imagine that the government makes a mistake in my favor and sends me an extra $1000 on a tax rebate. That money really doesn’t belong to me, which means it belongs to someone else. So, shouldn’t I send it back to the government? But wait, doesn’t the government charge too much money in taxes anyway, and wasn’t it their mistake? Is taking that extra rebate (which I may really need) stealing? Some good Catholics would keep that money without batting an eye, thanking God for it. Others would send it back immediately, convinced that it was a temptation from the Devil. On rare occasions, then, knowing right and wrong is tricky business, business that keeps moral theologians busy.

Getting Down to Brass Tacks

Now we are ready to answer your question. To be guilty of an evil action, I must be aware that it is evil, that it is morally wrong. That awareness may be clear or fuzzy. The clearer it is, the more guilty I am. To be guilty of an evil action, I also have to freely make the evil choice. The greater the degree of freedom, the great the culpability. If I commit an evil action without awareness of the evil or when my freedom is impaired, however, the evil is still committed; damage is done. This is why ignorance is NOT bliss. Fornication still wounds souls and societies, even if the fornicators have never been taught that fornication is wrong.

The spiritual consequences of this long answer to your very short question are pretty obvious. We need to make a decent effort not only to do what’s good and avoid what’s evil, but also, to know what’s right and wrong – it’s much easier to walk quickly and surely in the daylight than in the dark. We have to inform ourselves about what the Church teaches and why, going beyond the Google News sound bites about the Pope’s latest encyclical. That’s why you are reading this Q&A, and that’s why faithful Catholic resources like http://www.ncregister.com and http://www.faithandfamilylive.com are so invaluable to us.

Yours in Christ, Father John Bartunek, LC

On the Net:
For more questions and answers on the spiritual life, go to 

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular