grapefruit juice and paroxetine nail fungus treatment lamisil cream efectos secundarios del cialis de 5 mg buy finasteride for hair plavix und clexane tac dung phu cua thuoc phenergan how much does orlistat tablets cost cipro bar torino anafranil 150 mg wat is trazodone zithromax 250 mg posologie vibramycin australia glucophage tablets 850mg clomid cost australia strattera makes me feel high is it safe to take ibuprofen with mirtazapine propecia doctors teaching instructions for buspirone can i drink milk on amoxicillin can you use conditioner after ketoconazole shampoo viagra effect on ejackulation propranolol a concor fincart sas cialis 10 mg en mexico dipyridamole 25mg tab viagra works best erectile coming off topamax migraines mixing ondansetron, tylenol and antiacids cialis e miopia a case of topiramate induced epistaxis saudi arabia cialis viagra online stations how often do you take cialis torsemide 10 mg tab bactrim insomnia anxiety zoloft and grief cheapest paxil online ambes amlodipine 5 mg can dogs take celebrex erythromycin lactating mothers amlodipine besylate 5mg zyd wellbutrin and prolactin levels can dog have amoxicillin maximum dose of amlodipine allegra flowers avodart vs proscar prostate cancer topamax side effects deep vein thrombosis atenolol mot stress viagra ho chi min cialis 20 mg directions mort par clomipramine cialis dalla germania buy zyprexa olanzapine nizoral and autism clomid after spotting clomid wlasciwosci mobicity australia store levothyroxine 275 mcg 50 milligram diamond yellow pill like viagra cipro xr sales what is the nexium commercial drug interaction warning lupin ciprofloxacin topiramate emedicine is it safe to take benadryl while on zoloft kamagra prices pakistan trade name of amoxicillin in pakistan metformin side effects weight loss the cost of paroxetine without health insurance accutane bertibarots overnight to much viagra stars take propecia metformin 500 mg serve anche a perdere peso komposisi obat spironolactone kamagra auf deutsch mercedes benz cipro 55 nexium cold hands ciprofloxacin gluten free 250 ilosone gel onde encontrar topamax or toplep for migraines lexapro withdrawal and muscle spasms augmentin iv rxlist side effects of prednisone wear off buy clomid 150mg online apa itu danocrine how much is ciprotab flagyl tablet content bactrim gel oral allopurinol bloody nose can i use albuterol inhalation with epilepsy atorvastatin 5 mg side effects has abilify helped anyone pediatric dosing chart septra does viagra show up in urine test military buying viagra in mexico genuine viagra in south africa cape town flagyl a mettalic taste metronidazole vs herpes ciprofloxacin obat apa zyprexa and side effects tratamento com cloridrato de ciprofloxacino terbinafine hydrochloride medicine cipla price plavix medication paxil vs prozac anxiety disorder norvasc and calcium levels hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg weight loss zuir antibiotic cytotec available in dubai propranolol how long does it last famagosta cipro mappa cut levitra into halves can you use amoxicillin for insect bites xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai fungsi obat danocrine 200 mg obat cordarone 200 mg detikforum kegunaan viagra tamoxifen and clenbuterol coca cola and flagyl comprimidos de nizoral low dose cialis and lexapro ercolano allegra how long does amlodipine withdrawal symptoms take tamoxifeno e linha tetracycline dissolved seroquel is good for anxiety maximum daily dose of nifedipine does tinidazole compare metronidazole montelukast swelling wellbutrin nyquil drug interactions does keflex work for bladder infections paracitomal amoxcicaline ciprofloxin leofloxin metoprolol wellbutrin can amoxicillin make me itch how do clomiphene work verapamil 40 mg tab warfarin 5 mg tablet topamax and synthroid why prasugrel or clopidogrel clomid femara fertility clinic how does ampicillin work on bacteria healthy man viagra review how mant times can you viagra in a week amoxicillin black stool neurontin pharm class effetti collaterali di aciclovir prednisone 10mg dspk for neck pain neurontin cream pain adderall ritalin concerta strattera pt assistance for lipitor zyprexa 5mg tab lilly espanol yahoo mobic tablet philippines lisinopril metoprolol digoxin 100mg of metformin took together will this hurt ventolin albuterol inhaler pfizer pierde patente de lipitor co thai uong thuoc amoxicillin lasix 500 cena lasix drug card nursing can you get a buzz from buspirone cipro price in philippines 15 mg meloxicam equals how much ibuprofen nebenwirkungen doxepin haarausfall brand wellbutrin xr makes ears hurt hydrochlorothiazide side effects kidney pain heart shaped tadalafil tablets 5mg 800 mg of sertraline oxandrolone and finasteride zovirax at boots lasix in gocce neurontin causing agitation purchase nitroglycerin ointment pregnant breastfeeding and on austell azithromycin verapamil 40 mg tablets in india does amoxicillin 1000 mg treat a uti side effects of stop taking lexapro cold turkey topamax hypokalemia celexa dexedrine will 10mg prednisone do zovirax cream blisters buy nizoral 1 percent shampoo can you snort levaquin lamisil at spray for neck quem ja tomou misoprostol cialis 5 mg does celebrex help pinched nerve cipro studies wellbutrin and nyquil interactions polytar czy nizoral wo kann man viagra kaufen und wie teuer prednisone et chute de cheveux atc code of erythromycin stearate can amoxicillin cure an ear infection can i take fennel seeds while taking warfarin cheap escitalopram can you drink beer when taking ciproantibiotics 120 mg strattera drinking tamoxifen oder nolvadex metronidazole k?b shelf life of augmentin quetiapine hypnotic gabapentin for me cfs methocarbamol heartburn prednisone dose for dogs per pound high dose iv prednisone hydroxyzine 613 tamoxifen creme aciclovir dosis maxima side effects of stopping thyroxine sodium tablets allopurinol and leukemia buy viagra over the counter wthout prescription lamisil once cena u srbiji what will happen if i use 2 viagra pills augmentin mims singapore baclofen 8566 seroquel bei zwangserkrankungen wellbutrin and cats bupropion xl high buy viagra without prescription london linezolid cefixime combination side affect best buy viagra generika online mobic for sciatica nerve gabapentin and baclofen colchicine and tylenol 3 is there a recall on celebrex how long does a viagra last plavix heart pvcs priligy dapoxetine does not work 10mg accutane week 2 tujuan augmentin 1.2 amitriptyline 10mg price medication expiry date celexa amoxicillin hands zofran dosage dogs 4mg medicine stronger than zofran what if a girl uses viagra metronidazole gel 1 reviews allegra cafe richmond bc celebrex vs ibuprofen dosage precio del viagra en farmacias ahumada atenolol 12.5mg twice a day thyroxine test normal range reason for taking clomid cipro 250 mg bid for uti clomid medical tamsulosin dosage clomipramine 10 mg buspirone anti shivering kamagra prices mumbai cipro good ear infection augmentin cpr 1g buspirone m b3 555 spironolactone side effects in pregnancy does acyclovir interact with other drugs lamisil liquid spray metformin and decreased appetite zoloft side effects allergies i have azithromycin 500mg do i take all 4 at one time how much is cialis in mercury drug what if i stop taking finasteride tablets can prednisone irritate stomach no withdrawal from zoloft how much is provera in south africa metoprolol succinate 47.5 mg metronidazole 250 mg 3 times a day abilify 5mg fiyat flomax and niacin reasons to take lexapro glucophage durchfall accutane candidiasis how to buy female viagra online augmentin wiki sildenafil drug action ciprofloxacin sperm metformin xerostomia pdf side effec and cost of viagra lamisil once depressionen ciprofloxacin hydrochloride ophthalmic ear drops cheap accutane singapore husband on lexapro isotretinoina cuanto cuesta singulair causes seizures metformin 500 mg slow release for pcos propranolol fibrilacion auricular strawberry birthmark propranolol yeast infection fluconazole treatment propecia tongue yellow a quel moment prendre inexium 40 nystatin vs lamisil viagra buy australia cheapest paypal when are ciprobiotic taken zovirax 150mg po now cephalexin and ativan cysts after accutane can u buy amoxicillin prijs van clopidogrel dutasteride for women hair loss tegretol and cialis anxious on wellbutrin positive opk on last day of clomid buy forzest howdotofound reviews on levothyroxine 50 mcg ttc with viagra does cialis give u more sperm famvir ritalin metoprolol 75mg brands in india should you take thyroxine on an empty stomach azithromycin in nursing mothers convert bactrim iv to po take wellbutrin xl at night wirkung viagra bei frau como trabaja metformin propranolol hcl 40mg placebo cuanto vale el clomid generic viagra bet price ciprofloxacin 750mg tablets levaquin dosage prostatitis clomid apres coelioscopie cialis actresses estrace 1mg side effects sertraline will it keep you from getting a cdl cialis san antonio feeling stoned on cymbalta does sandoz levothyroxine cause gastritis propecia per ricrescita capelli taking 3 yr old viagra nz thyroxine serequel and celebrex can witndrawal from topiramate cause headaches stop weight gain olanzapine albuterol ketosis levitra modo duso montelukast sodium pdf how many people take singulair zithromax 1 gm side effects cipro causing rash difference between celebrex and meloxicam prednisone 40 mg daily for 15 days substitute for albuterol inhaler famciclovir en venezuela codex tetracycline was ist kamagra gold brand viagra online parkinson en seroquel does quetiapine make u lose your appetite bodybuilder spironolacton vs lasixe generic luvox price plavix online pharmacy misoprostol costs how much in kenya nizoral cream 2 hair loss propecia makes scalp itch can u purchase flagyl in stores in usa viagra nebenwirkungen beipackzettel viagra online order no prescription linezolid inject cost paxil increases intelligence zyvoxid manufacturer zovirax in philippines indikasi erythromycin stopping zoloft headache spironolactone dosierung buy provera pills flexeril y voltaren pastillas how to use viagra for best results in urdu diflucan co uk viagra pfizer brazil can i take diflucan 150 twice ciprobay 50 going off lexapro side effects acute retinal necrosis acyclovir dose cymbalta and clenching teeth clomid luteal ivermectina kg esomeprazole iv price does doxycycline cause dizziness on south beach diet can i lose with taking remeron baclofen amitriptyline ketamine viagra pil 100mg ciprofloxacino dosis caninos furosemide with or without albumin cymbalta kostar can you take imitrex with topamax exilar vs cialis

Death Penalty Clarification Needed

The trial and punishment of Saddam might well be a clarifying moment for Catholic teaching.
by Father Raymond J. de Souza | Source:
The worldwide coverage given to Cardinal Renato Martino’s remarks on Saddam Hussein and the death penalty has revealed the need for a clarification of the Church’s teaching on the death penalty.

Cardinal Martino, president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, has a reputation for rhetorical extravagance that sometimes exceeds the bounds of theological precision.

Nevertheless, at a press conference a few days after the capture of Saddam, he gave the impression that Catholic teaching would oppose the execution of the Iraqi dictator. Many international news outlets reported that Pope John Paul II himself was opposed to Saddam’s possible execution.

Is it the case that the Catholic Church is against all recourse to capital punishment, even for cases such as Saddam’s? Cardinal Martino at least implied as much. The Holy Father’s many statements and requests for clemency for death-row inmates seem to confirm that implication.

Yet the matter remains ambiguous.

As all knowledgeable commentators recognize, the Church teaches that the state has the right to administer capital punishment — an ancient teaching embraced by the full breadth of Catholic tradition. Yet John Paul and, following him, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, have indicated that the death penalty should not be used. The bishops of Canada and the United States have also made this teaching their own.

The ambiguity in need of clarification lies in the arguments the Holy Father proposed in No. 56 of the 1995 encyclical Evangelium Vitae (The Gospel of Life), which were later inserted into the definitive edition of the Catechism, in Nos. 2266 and 2267.

“Legitimate public authority has the right and duty to inflict punishment proportionate to the gravity of the offense,” the Catechism says in No. 2266 on penalties in general. “Punishment has the primary aim of redressing the disorder introduced by the offense.”

Traditionally, the death penalty has been justified on those grounds — namely, that some crimes are so heinous that the only proportionate punishment that would redress the injustice suffered would be execution.

A secondary argument in favor of the death penalty was that it would ensure public safety by preventing the criminal from committing further crimes.

“The Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor,” the Catechism says in No. 2267. “If, however, nonlethal means are sufficient to defend and protect people’s safety from the aggressor, authority will limit itself to such means. … Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities that the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm — without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself — the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.”

It is the Church’s clear teaching that if it is possible to keep society safe without the death penalty, then the death penalty should not be used.

Yet nothing is said in the Catechism about the first reason for the death penalty — the proportionate penalty aimed at redressing the disorder. Observing the Holy Father’s repeated statements and requests for clemency, it seems he does not think the first reason justifies the death penalty. But he has never said as much, and saying so would be difficult to square with the Catholic tradition. So the matter has been left deliberately ambiguous, with the Church appearing to be against all executions for stated reasons that do not address all the reasons for which executions are done.

Saddam’s notoriety will make this ambiguity harder to maintain. If the primary reason for capital punishment is still valid — proportionate punishment — it is clear that his crimes merit the death penalty. If the Church judges otherwise, she will have, in effect, resolved the current ambiguity in her teaching by stating, in effect, that no crime merits the death penalty as proportionate punishment.

Saddam also puts the Catechism’s teaching to the test on the secondary reason — public safety. The Catechism explicitly teaches that public safety is a permissible reason for execution if no other means would ensure public safety. In effect, the current Catholic teaching is that the death penalty would be more permissible in the Congo, for example, where public security measures are not as sophisticated as, for example, in Belgium.

An imprisoned Saddam in an Iraq still under reconstruction would likely pose a threat to public safety. His loyalists might attempt to raid the prison to free him in the first months of shaky Iraqi sovereignty. Allowed visitors for humanitarian reasons, Saddam might use them to direct further violence, as Mafia bosses continue to run their families from prison. In short, the public-safety considerations in the Catechism would allow for Saddam’s execution.

If the Church nevertheless opposes Saddam’s execution on public-safety grounds, too, then it would appear the criteria in the Catechism do not apply in practice and that states should never have recourse to the death penalty. “Practically nonexistent” would then have to be read as simply “nonexistent.”

The trial and punishment of Saddam might well be a clarifying moment for Catholic teaching.

Father Raymond J. de Souza is a chaplain at Queens College in Kingstown, Ontario.

Reprinted with permission from the National Catholic Register, Jan. 4-10, 2004. All rights reserved.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular