xenical bahasa indonesia 300 mg doxycycline lyme agrofph.com cate zile se ia augmentin mirtazapine mims online can you split zyprexa zydis mazowsze.waw.pl chinatripadvisor.com sichtwandel.ch ampicillin for strep throat cuesto cuesta mifepristona o misoprostol atomoxetine hydrochloride 18 mg benicar 40 25 buy generic viagra online with mastercard how much does ciprodex really cost prednisone 10 mg 3 times a day misoprostol 200 pg can you eat grapefruit while on teva telmisartan cost of generic gabapentin can you take cialis and doxycycline interactions itching during prednisone taper misoprostol missed abortion cpt amoxicillin and metronidazole and breastfeeding digoxin immune fab cost meccanicanova.com buy amoxicillin in uk fast delivery from holland amoxicillin oral suspension mox redimix amlodipine and atenolol tablet benefit can you take adderall and cialis together ryman.pl cialis order form in uk do i need prescription for terbinafine tablets tedmitew.com where can i buy amitriptyline 2.5mg in ontario chrisandradeforcongress.com cena cialisa u srbiji what happens if you take hydrocodone with gabapentin hydroxyzine 60 mg revive sildenafil 50mg is finasteride an alpha blocker nasminc.com online provera uplate staza buy arimidex canada pharmacy what the strongest levitra dose how quickly does diflucan work for yeast infection how many hours does 10mg buspar last hansrajcollege.info obat voltaren untuk apa cialis viagra canada what is the action of prednisone to accutane viagra vs cialis staying erection after climax amoxicillin trihydrate std cerisdieventi.com lisinopril generic cost diflucan 200mg treat systemic candida iaspm2013.espora.es is misoprostol available in the philippines synthroid and ethinyl estradiol interactions how will u know that the cytotec is original over the counter kids amoxicillin lipitor 10mg price australia levofloxacin vs augmentin purchase cialis online uk generic actos westregion.org how long is the ganeric zofran good for home remedies to counteract flagyl medicine colchicine 1mg dosage danoday.com if you overdose on trazodone will it kill you nolvadex online credit card amoxil drops dosage 3 days celebrex 100 mg capsule prospect muscle weakness eased after discontinuing levothyroxine albuterol inhaler for fat loss how many sprays groganstudios.com gauntletpress.com dexcipro eyedrop twospy.com cost of nizoral shampoo 2 vibramycin orange black capsule cipla allcoinreviews.org ciprofloxacin us 500 mg where can i buy liquid form amoxicillin for my cat doxycycline 50 mg and alcohol cerisdieventi.com olmesartan 10 mg india huntofalifetime.org nizoral shampoo sildenafil citrate tablets target 100 pill haciendahotel-oldtown.com obat super tetra tetracycline hcl zovirax acyclovir ointment price in peso augmentin 475 5ml suspension taking .4 mg of clonidine iaspm2013.espora.es is atarax syrup is safe for 4 month baby quetiapine 12.5 addictedtoallthingspretty.com theweddingdolls.co.uk precio feldene piroxicam 20 mg katartisi-pnai.gr azithromycin 500 mg 4 pills montelukast sod 4 mg chewable can my kid take another mobic 15 mg and alcohol thumbuy.com cost of cialis 5mg shoppersdrug mart how does paxil paroxetine look like am1320.com where can i buy ciprofloxacin eye drops dexamethasone 2mg infertility side effects andrijastepic.renianstudio.com diltiazem 125 mg thesavvysocialista.com dapoxetine fda newworldfoods.ca yagbank.com virtualsem.com yellowmag.co.uk zoloft for weight loss remeron high khasiat obat voltaren 25 mg waterfrontalehouse.com will one dose 500 mg of flagyl kill trichomonas nizoral 30g cream seroquel interaction with ativan 1001.org waterfrontalehouse.com harga 1 strip fluconazole companys that make avapro paroxetine 10 mg weight gain ikoa-f.com content-catalyst.com finasteride sale metoprolol succinate watson problem can you shoot neurontin800mg doxycycline yellow teeth where to purchase viagra in canada learninc.org paroxetine hcl 40mg how much do they cost sekerpinarosgb.com revue-pto.com viagra pricing how much does nitroglycerin tablets cost levothyroxine 75mg costco price how much is acyclovir in mercury drug lambda max of gabapentin wikipedia atorvastatin 20mg periactin 2mg 5ml septra pregnancy and dry mouth cytotec el salvador 1001.org orlistat obetas grandcanyonbrewery.com dws-xip.pl buildingsonfire.com hhpz.org eu-atp.org allegra salem nh voltaren emulgel gel 40g cabergoline cost uk priligy in indian market doxycycline hyclate 100mg rosacea phenergan dosage for 7 month old how much do they sell clomid in nigerian currency celebrex 200 bid onset time of amoxicillin himox cyproheptadine tablets 10 mg antibiotics vial cover ed with black paper metformin hcl can get you high propecia 3 months shedding thesoundalarm.com farmakodinamik ciprofloxacin zoloft and palpitations flagyl 400 mg side effects day 3 clomid challenge cut off for insurance femara 10mg success gauntletpress.com esomeprazole affect nuvo ring hasta cuanto tiempo puedo usar cytotec brownhousephoto.com fosamax patient uk allegra fruit juice warning thearcofnovatrust.com will taking 7.5 mg of remeron wil make you fat propranolol test anxiety xeloda with fluconazole nizoral shampoo 2 percentdirectionshair loss how much does gabapentin cost without insurance azithromycin 250 chlamydia and side effects ketoconazole online pharmacy gratisdiscotecas.com can you give a dog melatonin and hydroxyzine cost of lamisil tablets in ireland clopidogrel for sale paroxetine cr 12.5 mg side effects doxycycline make you feel sick wordsalamode.com lisinopril quitting cold turkey acyclovir for 3 year old famciclovir 1000 mg male thrush is it worth trying fluconazole vibrancetech.net is gabapentin 100mg a muscle relaxer citalopram 20mg tablets and alcohol launchpoker.com narrative.in tedmitew.com stopping taking sertraline, male augmentin 875 7 days metformin 250 mg price que es azithromycin 1 gm powder packet why does nifedipine 30 mg interactions with lisinopril khasiat levofloxacin 750 buscomi.com sweetcheekshq.com clomiphenecitrate and getting bloated augmentin mg sizes prednisone 50 mg side effects nglturf.org apparel-chic.com crush viagra quicker results fosamax 60mg lp non prescription viagra accept discover plavix 37.5 yagbank.com how much amoxicillin oral sold in dollars revue-pto.com azithromycin 500 mg 1 dose wedlok.com mobilestoreoperators.com nolvadex to reverse gyno what is lisinopril 10 mg used for metoprolol 25 er convert to tartrate tome levaquin y no me puedo parar thoracic outlet syndrome baclofen best enhancement pills like viagra comprimidos amoxicillin 250 mg para qe zithromax australia ureaplasma doxazosin generic drug nolvadex 40mg per day amaryl 2 mg tabletas generic fluconazole no prescription erecto 100mg how to use champion-container.com zoloft and cialis interaction weingutkohl.de arthurstractors.com mail order amaryllis gifts flagyl works on strep b flagyl 3 day treatment zyprexa cena veofinancial.com nizoral shampoo wholesale prednisone side effects short term use what happens when women takes revatio drug periactin philippines uasa.co.za artpol.org.pl nasminc.com can you take flagyl and levaquin at the sametime side effect ng metformin cost of esomeprazole suspension gambar untuk nizoral krim managedent.ca overdose 3000 mg metformin side effects can zoloft be lethal obat celebrex celecoxib aljanine.com newworldfoods.ca sildenafil online uk erythromycin dabber where can i buy nexium 40 mg metformin 500 mg price in dubai metronidazole side effects indogs yeast infection fluconazole not working how much prednisone in z pack webbrowsers.lv tomar zolof con topamax fluoxetine 20 mg capsule revue-pto.com can someone trying to concieve use metronidazole erythromycin for acne price ph efector secundarios del quetiapine fumarate aptmetrics.com tadalafil calox de 20 miligramos thu?»‘c chloramphenicol 250mg sildenafil 20 mg price does tramadol and zoloft cause confusion in pregnancy can you take tamiflu if you been taking azithromycin tngo 1 mes de embarazo puedo usar las cytotec harsa.se wedlok.com fluoxetine v tehotenstve antidote for zofran axellerata.com premarin .3mg side effects buy neurontin grandcanyonbrewery.com dxm amoxicillin oeufspolis.com liceoagnoletti.it metronidazole gram positive xenical drug in ghana dapoxetine 90mg is ok if i take cipralex and cymbalta together amaryl tablet adalah mg gula xenical price can angular cheilitis be cured by acyclovir azithromycin 500 mg ingredients cuanto cuestan las pastillas cytotec vpdcorp.com were in jamaica can i get misoprostol pills to buy will i lose weight if i switch from paxil to lexapro getting pregnant with extended clomid and norvasc can zithromax be used for a boil tamsulosin hcl .4mg for kidney stones ahmeterhan.com order lexapro over the counter so-sc.org doxepin 25 mg eude.es citalopram 20 mg hair loss price fof levocitrizine montelukast tablets of mankind edgewaterstudio.com citek misoprostol 200ml mylan rizatriptan gluten NEOHAIRINDO.COM generic drug name cipro when does prednisone acne go away afsvc.com ipp telmisartan eu-atp.org erectile dysfunction natural replacement for glucophage estradiol 4mg side effects azithromycin tablets for sore throat captionedit.com erectil taladafil dapoxetine firsttimetravels.com zoloft tablet price in pakistan dosing schedule for prednisone blister pack how much milligrams is a z pack of prednisone bactrim ds streptococcus coverage how much is celexa out of pocket kegunaan dexamethasone 0.75mg vpdcorp.com dog cancer stopping prednisone muscle waste terbinafine tablets usp 250 mg para q se usa montelukast recreational hiw long diflucan one mirtazapine increased breathlessness copd prednisone 5 mg for pets with no prescription can 3 zithromax pills cure gonorrhea where can i buy amoxicillin in ul without prescription montelukast granules ingredients 4g groganstudios.com ciprofloxacin 250 dose can i alternate lisinopril amd enalapril does buspirone hydrochloride 15mg get u high took 1000 mg of amoxicillin at the same time spacecityparent.com nglturf.org grandlakehistory.org cloferclomiphene citrate bp 50mg harga nexium 50mg di indonesia cuanto cuesta la cytotec en venezuela can you give dogs bactrim for uti compounding strattera to liquid proscar 20 mg fluconazole 150 mg for yeast infection 3 day supply how much per pc of cytotec in philippines ftortho.net clozapine 200 mg hansrajcollege.info paxil side effects first week 1001.org does viagra make you hard longer kegunaan dexamethasone 0.75mg is 600 mgs of bupropion hcl sr to mubh to take deremerstudios.com viagra pills pakistan buscomi.com dose of linezolide i.v refineyourfeel.com can you mix amoxicillin trihydrate with doxycycline gabapentin 200 mg tablets for rls how much would you sell seroquel 400mg for orange tongue escitalopram generic cozaar hctz cla 1000 conjugated linoleic acid buy naproxen tablets 500mg 365travelinsurance.com duloxetine tablets metronidazole syrup buy india online cialis order viagra can you get high off of ic quetiapine fumarate 50 mg louielouie.net clomiphene 25mg thaibrother.net azithromycin daily dose limit india warfarin 832 voltaren dispers 40mg une dose de 400mg d cytotec narrative.in lexapro price comparison bursatekstil.org hydroxyzine overdose in 4year olds prozac 8 weeks to work amoxicillin rash in infants fluoxetine 5ht2a zithromax no prescription online buspar 15 amoxicillin brand for 2 year old philippines is wellbutrin and adderall are the same cipla albuterol mdi hormonske tab. provera que hacer si fallan laa pastillas misoprostol ryman.pl amoxicillin clavulanate potassium for chicken pox can you take topamax with hepatitis c how to stop 600mg gabapentin safely cipro lawsuits florida bjceke.com allegra versace kg famvir 1 webbrowsers.lv does diabex help with prednisone weight gain what is gabapentin 300mg capsules used for chloramphenicol 1 eye drops can you get high off of buspirone hydrochloride 30 mg can u crush chlamydia antibiotic bactrim for strep throat doumsystems.com hhpz.org paladardigital.com levaquin extravasation albuterol positive drug test cat rash reaction to prednisone propecia overnight faunaforever.org buy albuterol tablet has anyone got pregnant after using provera 5mg lexapro y antigripales preparation h and lexapro cefixme linezolid in hindi convert capotril to lisinopril daily maintenance amoxicillin for a dog voltaren 100 retard financial assistance for metoprolol seenonstage.pl metformin appetite control redzigaismu.lv starting zoloft side effect anxiety gaviscon and clopidogrel negative side effects wellbutrin xl rantical.com lemurialifecoaching.com NEOHAIRINDO.COM buy cheap celebrex online ambien hydrocodone gabapentin ok levitra purchase generic can amoxicillin plus clavulanic acid treat syphilis lasix retard 30 mg depotkapsel guna zovirax cream 80mg of paxil for panic attacks cual es la dosis maxima de decadron injectable mirtazapine anafranil weight gain webworksandgraphics.com prazosin australia how many mcgs can a 4 year old boy used for albuterol which diseases medicine rupatadine and montelukast inasweets.com amoxicillin syrup for infant levaquin red eyes will doctor give you cialis if you ask creatina erectie can clomid cause breast milk discharge does azithromycin come in capsule form amoxil capsule after miscarriage nexium cost apa kegunaan obat cytostol misoprostol 200mg doxycycline hyclate 100mg rosacea davidkadner.cz 20 mg cialis prices walmart cvs walgreens cialis and cardiac arrhythmia azithromycin 500mg tablet price list is amitriptyline hcl 50 mg tab a narcotic buspar with lexapro generic estrace vag cream thisisjacobriddle.com diflucan 40 NEOHAIRINDO.COM marontech.com.my phenergan for dog with kidney problems furosemide 10 mg cat glimepiride 2 mg nizoral uk muscle deltasone approval do antidepressants cause wet dreams

Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ: A Christian Work of Art Part II

An analysis of the motivations behind the controversy surrounding this epic film.
by Father Jesús Villagrasa | Source:
March 30, 2004 / The phenomenon of The Passion of the Christ could be considered--as in this article--on three levels: one, superficial, goes only into the cinematographic chronicle; another, could stop to analyze the motivations behind the controversy; and, finally, as a profound explanation of the phenomenon, one can delve deep into what is, in my opinion, the reason for being of the originality and beauty of this film: this is a true work of art and, more specifically, a true work of Christian art.

Click here to read Part I of this article.

The controversy before the release

During the summer and autumn of 2003, an initial draft of the film was presented in the United States and Italy to small groups of Catholic and Evangelic audiences, to personalities of the religious and political circles as well as to some of the leaders of the communications industry. The objective behind these screenings was to collect impressions from the Christian groups, calibrate the reactions and get away from the rumors and open accusations about the movie that had already begun to circulate. The producers wished to prove false the accusations of anti-Semitism and lack of historical rigor.

The issue of anti-Semitism

Profoundly offended, Mel Gibson rejects the accusations of anti-Semitic defamation launched against him personally and against the film. Without having seen the movie, Jewish organizations Anti Defamation League and the Simon Weisenthal Center have made declarations of this sort. Both organizations--Gibson points out--have, unfortunately, a long history of confrontation with the Catholic Church; both have devoted efforts to defame the memory of Pope Pious XII, and according to both organizations the Gospel itself is anti-Semitic.

"Anti-Semitism is not only contrary to my personal beliefs but contrary also to the message of my film. I don't hate people and I certainly don't hate Jews; I have friends and partners who are Jewish. The Passion of the Christ is a movie meant to inspire, not to offend. My intent when putting this on film is to create a work of art that can remain and motivate the reflection amongst audiences of different creeds, or of none, for whom the story is familiar," said Mel Gibson, the film's director and co-producer.

Gibson and Jim Caviezel are both Catholic, and the screenplay was written by Catholics, but the cast and production team are comprised of Christians of diverse denominations, as well as Jews, Muslims, Buddhists and even agnostics.

Representative Christian and Jewish voices have come out in defense of the movie: the Romanian actress, Maia Morgenstern, who is herself Jewish and the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, plays the role of the Virgin Mary in the movie. She stated to The Jewish Journal that the film is not anti-Semitic.

Dean Devlin, co producer of Braveheart, after seeing the preview screening said "I have found nothing in it that is the least bit anti-Semitic and I am Jewish."

Keith Fournier, constitutional attorney who has participated in important religious rights cases before the US Supreme Court, attended a private screening in Washington, D.C. along with other political personalities, and maintains that the accusation of anti-Semitism makes no sense.

The most vigorous defense of the movie comes from an Orthodox Jewish Rabbi, Daniel Lapin, one of the most respected Jewish community leaders in the United States and founder/director of the Toward Tradition organization, which is devoted to strengthening the good relations between Jews and Christians.

In an article published in Jewsweek (3-X-03), Lapin confronted the campaign that some Jewish organizations have waged against the film and defends the fact that "these protests against The Passion of the Christ are not only morally indefensible but downright stupid." Above all, "they have little chance of achieving changes in the movie. Gibson is an artist and a Catholic of strong conviction of which this movie is an expression. Therefore, the motivation that has lead him to make this movie is not commercial. Besides, anyone who has seen his movie 'Braveheart' can acknowledge the profound identification of Mel Gibson with the hero of this epic story who prefers to be torn apart before he will betray his principles. Does anyone find it likely that Gibson would make a pact with the Jewish organizations?"

Lapin also considers the attacks against Gibson to be mistaken because "even if the anti-Semitic accusations may benefit some of these Jewish organizations in their fund raising tasks or benefit some Jewish New York Times reporter or other journalists attempting to make a name for their careers, it, of course does not benefit at all, the interests of the majority of American Jews who live in comfortable harmony with their Christian neighbors. Many Christians see all these attacks on Mel Gibson either as mere criticism against the film, or, for some reason in my opinion, as attacks against all Christians."

Eugene Korn, director of inter religious affairs for the Jewish Anti Defamation League and one of the "strategists" who designed the campaign to censure the movie with the accusation of anti-Semitism--and perhaps the most boisterous detractor--was forced to offer his resignation to The League in the midst of debate concerning the group's aggressive reaction to the Christian film.

Also against The League's campaign is the Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein, president and founder of the International Fellowship of Christians and Jews, and Michael Medved, a film critic and orthodox Jew.

Cardinal Dario Castrillon, prefect for the Congregation for Clerics and one of the guests to the private screenings of the film prior to its release, declared in an interview with La Stampa newspaper (18-IX-2003): "Anti-Semitism, as any form of racism, distorts the truth in order to denigrate an entire race of peoples. The movie does none of that. Based on the historical objectiveness of the Gospel reports, it generates feelings of forgiveness, mercy and reconciliation. It portrays the horrors of sin, while contrasting with the gentle power of love and forgiveness, without making or even insinuating condemnation against any group. This film conveys the exact opposite. That learning from the example of Christ, there should be no more violence against another human being."

However, some people do not share the notion that the movie is faithful to history and have led the second front of controversy.

The issue of historical authenticity

Mel Gibson repeats, convinced that his movie corresponds to the truth of the historical facts, that "it is according to what the gospels of the four Evangelists of the New Testament tell us about the passion and death of Christ," and that whoever expects a faithful report of the life of Christ will not come out disappointed.

At the same time, he doubtlessly admits that for some passages he has been inspired by the visions of some "mystics" of the passion, especially those of a German nun currently in the process of beatification, Sr. Katherine Emmerich (1774-1824), who bore the stigmas of the Passion of The Lord and received extraordinary charisma.

She, herself, described her visions in the book "The Painful Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ." Gibson justifies his choice of depicting the crucifixion on the hands as opposed to the wrists, as it seems most likely historically, by saying that "the possibility that Jesus was crucified at the wrists has foundation, but tradition has represented Jesus with the wounds in the hands and, throughout history, the saints who received the Stigmas of The Lord, have presented them in the hands."

A group of Catholic experts and American Jews, seemingly with some initial backing from a committee of the Episcopal Conference of the US, declared that the screenplay of the movie contained "historical mistakes" and that its vision of the Jewish personalities was incorrect. It is surprising, though, that an inter-religious committee of experts would have based their opinion on a primitive version of the screenplay (a 'stolen' version and very different from the current, according to the producer.)

Paula Fredriksen, writing professor at Boston University, author of Jesus of Nazareth, 'King of the Jews: a historical study of the final twelve hours in the life of Jesus', agrees that the script startled them. "We pointed out the historical mistakes and -as Gibson had proclaimed his Catholicism- his deviations from the magisterial principles of Biblical interpretation. We concluded with general recommendations for some changes in the screenplay (The New Republic, 28-VII-2003)."

On July 21,2003, Mel Gibson held a meeting with Monsignor William P. Fay, general secretary of the Episcopal Conference of the United States, to clear up terms and manifest his good disposition (Inside the Vatican, 16-VIII-03).

A defender of the historical licenses of Mel Gibson uses a fairly weak argument that goes something like this: "from 'Jesus Christ Superstar' through 'The Last Temptation of Christ' we are used to film makers pulling bits and pieces of Gospels to recreate their particular visions of the life of Christ. If anyone is scandalized by this and demands fidelity to the gospel texts, they are labeled as conservative and reminded that the artist's creativity is not tied by the letter of the text. If anyone feels offended by the 'recreation,' they are told that, of course, without being offensive, but that freedom of expression does not admit censure or limits based on bruised sensitivities. But now comes 'The Passion', a recreation of the last hours of Jesus Christ prior to his death on the cross, and that traditional cliché is no longer valid."

The argument is weak because it does not confront the issue of historical authenticity. Certainly, in creating his piece, an artist is free to make many artistic choices. It is still fair, though, to ask why Mel Gibson introduced elements outside of the Gospel or outside of serious historical studies about the time of Jesus if his intent was to present the Passion "as it was." This pretension of historical accuracy, repeatedly declared by Gibson, can justify some critical intervention by the students of the Holy Scripture and of the culture and history of the time of Jesus. Otherwise, it is hard to figure that 'zeal', preoccupation and intervention from the students who are now devoted to judging the "historical orthodoxy" of a movie.

The director has not found himself lacking of renowned defenders in this controversy.

Ted Haggard, president of the National Evangelical Association, whose theologians highly value the precise citing of the Bible, declared that the movie is "the most authentic representation I have ever seen."

The Archbishop of Denver, Monsignor Charles Chaput, considers that "the movie is a work of art and extraordinarily faithful to the Gospel," as well as stating that "for Mel Gibson, making this film has been an act of faith and enormously significant (National Catholic Register, 14-X-2003)."

Augustine Di Noia, undersecretary of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, after having seen the movie said that "without being a documentary but a work of artistic imagination, Gibson's movie is absolutely faithful to the New Testament: he incorporates elements of the Passion according to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, maintaining the fundamental structure common to all four narratives (Zenit, 10-XII-2003)."

In each of these values there are elements of notable interest to make a balanced judgment of the movie: in it come together the fidelity of the facts, the artistic freedom and the depth of the believer into the mystery. The film tells the gospel story in a dramatically beautiful manner. The facts narrated in the gospels correspond to real events. All four gospel writers are aware of telling the historical facts, but even more so the salvation-related events. The gospels are a narrative of a story, penetrated by faith, expressed with faith, accepted and lived in faith.

Mel Gibson is an artist and a Christian; he is not a gospel writer--in the first place because he has not been blessed with divine inspiration--but he shares with the gospel writers their effort to communicate events that faith discovered, recognizes and confesses as leading to salvation.

Gibson feels entitled to the right to tell the story as it happened (arrived at through his convictions), because we are dealing with a message that is of interest for all mankind; and, each one of them has, also, the right to listen to the truth.

As an artist, Gibson feels entitled to create a work of art that could communicate his "artistic inspiration." Inspiration is not foreign to the life of an artist. Gibson has confessed that ever since he was 35 years old the passion of Christ has hounded him. At that age he had the grace of penetrating in the mystery of divine love revealed in the passion. This mystery can illuminate the life of men, especially the darkest and most mysterious dimensions such as his pain and suffering and the defeat of sin. The pain of Christ in his passion, the wounds on his face and body, so callous at plain sight, are revealed extraordinarily beautifully when they are discovered as suffered and endured voluntarily for love.

Is the film historically accurate?

Closely related to the controversy regarding historical accuracy is the issue of the violence of the scenes. Jim Caviezel, the actor who portrays Jesus, in an interview with the daily Globe and Mail assures us that the suffering endured by Jesus was much worse than what is shown on the film. There is a lot of blood; one cannot lie about that fact. And yet, the veracity regarding the events cannot move the audience away from the message.

"We won't get to a point where people get so impacted by what they are seeing on the screen that they miss the point of the story. We don't want that," concludes Caviezel. The violence reveals both the evil of sin and the greatness of the love of God.

The violent scenes will not provoke hatred and spite amongst the spectators because "one of the greatest accomplishments of this movie is its ability to precisely show both the horror of sin and selfishness as well as the redeeming power of love. As the movie is being viewed, feelings of compassion and love arise within audiences. It makes the spectator desire to love more, forgive, be kind and strong, regardless of obstacles; as Christ was even during his terrible suffering," said Cardinal Castrillón (La Stampa, 18-IX-2003).

Perhaps this is one of the biggest accomplishments of the movie: that in the horror of the passion, love can shine brighter than blood itself, and that before He, from whom one would hide one's face, can be contemplated with gratitude and love.

Rabbi Lapin cites some of Cardinal Castrillón's declarations to respond to those who accuse Gibson of incurring errors about the true bearers of responsibility of the death of Jesus: "Gibson has had to make many artistic choices to build up his portrayal of the characters and events that come together during 'The Passion', and he has completed the gospel narrative with the perceptions and reflections of saints and mystics throughout centuries. Mel Gibson not only rigorously follows the gospel story, but he gives the spectator a new appreciation of these bible passages. Thanks to his esthetic choices, he has made a film faithful to the meaning of the Gospels, as interpreted by the church (Jewsweek, 3-X-2003)."

The liberty of a believing artist, who wished to remain faithful to the gospel, resulted in a piece of work that all can appreciate. But it will be appreciated in a very particular way by the spectator who is in tune with the faith that has inspired this work of art. While watching an unfinished version of the film, Cardinal Castrillon said he experienced "moments of profound spiritual intimacy with Jesus Christ. It is a film that drives the spectator to prayer and reflection, to a contemplation that touches the heart. As a matter of fact -and I said this to Mr. Gibson after the screening- I would gladly exchange some of the homilies I have given regarding the passion of Christ for some of the scenes from the movie (La Stampa, 18-IX-2003)."

A few words from an exceptional spectator have stirred a long debate in the media. Did Pope John Paul II pronounce--or not--the phrase "it is as it was" after watching the film. The director of the Press Office at the Holy See, Joaquin Navarro-Valls, to clear the issue published on January 22nd of 2004 an official statement: "After consulting with his personal secretary, Archbishop Stanislaw Dzawisz, I can confirm that the Holy Father has had an opportunity to see the movie The Passion of the Christ ." The statement also positively describes the film as "a cinematographic adaptation of the historical event of the passion of Jesus Christ according to the gospel narrative." This description is relevant, considering that one of the controversies surrounding the movie had been its fidelity to the historical events and to the gospel report. And yet, the statement points out that had the Pontiff said the phrase "it is as it was," this should not be taken as an official endorsement: "It is the Holy Father's custom

The statement from Navarro-Valls "has a dual purpose: it seems to respond to the evident pressure to distance the Pope from any direct connection to the movie, while at the same time loaning it limited support (Inside the Vatican, 22-I-204)." The statement makes it very clear in its main portion that the Pope does not make public judgments about "works of art," because as they are of an esthetic nature, and not moral or doctrine, the judgment of works of art, such as movies, is outside of the papal competency.

History, faith and art seem inseparable in this movie. The specialist in Holy Scripture, oriental culture, spiritual theology or cinematography, will be able to make a detailed analysis of the movie and perhaps, especially of the historical loyalty, finding deficiencies or making objections. An analysis of this type is not hard.

What is notable is the artistic synthesis, the creative work of the artist. The Passion of the Christ is an extraordinarily beautiful work, if we understand beauty as "the sensible manifestation of idea (Hegel)."

One objection seems inevitable though; was it necessary to resort to the visions of a mystic that do not necessarily reflect historical truths to communicate the experience of faith? I would have preferred that Gibson not use those. But, on the other hand, was it that grave that he did? As a matter of fact, it does not take away from the artistic merit of the piece and it will not detract, possibly, from the results that the director, producers and members of the cast have set out to achieve. Perhaps those are the liberties that artists can allow themselves.

Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ: A Christian Work of Art Part I

Part III to follow.

Father Jesus Villagrasa is a professor of metaphysics at the Regina Apostolorum Pontifical Athenaeum.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular