topamax hair damage augmentin 500 pret singulair coumadin harga danazol 200 mg tadacip sicher bestellen am i to ovulate 18days after taking last pill on clomid propecia costco price how much would would you sell 1 clonidine does viagra come in a pink pill endometrin vs prometrium zovirax ointment 15g price low cost viagra in the uk levitra generic canada barry brand paxil buy amoxicillin online overnight shipping nombres de farmacias de medellin venden cytotec ivermectin 3mg scabies what happens if you take viagra when your 12 para que sirve el orlistat does trazodone cause delayed ejaculation gabapentin 4 dollar weakness and metronidazole 600 mg ethinyl estradiol 25 closest over counter viagra isotretinoin capsules usp 10 mg price india can you drink alcohol with cipro flomax cytometry roche xenical 120 mg side effects enceinte paxil como usar misoprostol para abortar buy lexapro 10 ventolin bambini tosse lipitor labs monitor what is the use of clomiphene50 mg tab revista 20 minutos colombia zoloft and adhd meds cialis and pregancy clomiphene citrate and spotting how long to take diflucan for pink poop amoxicillin dye infant shakiness treatment levofloxacin can a mega dose of flagyl cause a yeast infection manfaat obat novamox 500 amoxicillin ventolin dependency amitriptyline 25 mg cause weight gain tamoxifeno retiene liquidos indomethacin cardiac risk get gigh off.celexa and meth zoloft and adrenal fatigue clomid cost walgreens is hcg and tamoxifen enough what are the effects of discontinuing prednisone buy clomipramine for dogs why does viagra do cialis da 28 compresse wellbutrin with lexapro jitters lexapro dosage for kids gsk levitra thailand no supplements like viagra gabapentin 600 opiate withdrawls bijwerkingen van glucophage can female viagra is to seduce a girl what is a short term dose of prednisone price of propecia brand pamelor generic equivalent los efectos secundarios de lipitor 5 mg rizatriptan sneezing telmisartan usp 33 monograph street price for zyprexa zithromax good for uti singulair discount card programs metformin for bipolar disorder taking cialis 30 days how many days till it works side effects of swallowing albuterol fda approval for metformin xenical retirada mercado kegunaan amoxilin aldactone weight gain side effects are sildenafil actavis as good as viagra grapefruit juice erectile dysfunction cephalexin and metronidazole together fda black box warning meloxicam dexamethasone 6 day pack zoloft 100mg vs 50mg how much does nexium cost over the counter maa ki adalat by narinder chanchal abortion pills cytotec topix potenzmittel cialis what happens when you stop taking metformin for a month amoxil indonesia hives after stopping wellbutrin will viagra get through customs treating side effects of ciprotab gabapentin grupo terapeutico wellbutrin 300 mg at one time is it ok to take cipro while pregnant gulf indomethacin 25mg 5mg of lexapro enough nizoral shampoo price in sri lanka what happens when a girls drink viagra is 50mg sertraline a high dose does gabapentin trigger ana amoxicillin und doxepin precio evista mexico como se debe tomar nexium overnight delivery viagra usa celecoxib heartburn quanto custa o misoprostol no paraguai stronger than cialis dog staph cephalexin allegra 24 hour 90 count metronidazole fresenius 500mg used for dexamethasone 60 mg over counter substitute prednisone diffuse hair loss finasteride 80 mg of accutane paroxetine hcl 20 mg price cipro seizure threshold revatio mexico prices nexium apotheken umschau what is the mode of administration for nifedipine bupropion er 150 mg purchase propecia online no prescription clomid ovulation calendar delsym wellbutrin interaction viagra sale quezon city amoxil 1g kaina does buspar cause urinary problems premarin cream and nursing metformin xl 500 wellbutrin and the la use of glucophage 500 mg does doxycycline work for boils la viagra se vende sin receta clomid und nolvadex baclofen price in phil esomeprazole no prescription ketoconazole untuk kucing does celebrex contain blood thinners can u take prozac and zoloft together what is medroxyprogesterone 10mg used for baclofen lek does too much synthroid cause headaches terbinafine hcl 10mg does doxycycline hyclate 100 mg contain penicillin how long can i keep augmentin zovirax cream generic name buy nexium online emedoutlet metronidazole dog drowsiness augmentin side effects dehydration cialis dergboadre uses plavix no insurance weight gain after coming off zoloft albuterol mdi gas does clomid help ovarian cysts finishing accutane side effects principio activo de linezolid can you inject baclofen 10 mg lipitor patent expiry australia msms amoxicillin spektrum dietary guidelines for warfarin overdose clomiphene manny ramirez if i am using flagyl 400 urine colour change or not valtrex dosage genital herpes recurrence norvasc efecte secundare topiramate off patent cialis kaufen paypal when can you get pregnant after taking clomid abilify me and my depression can i buy nexium 40 mg over the counter now in ireland nursing responsibilites of lasix dissolution error metoprolol tapering off prednisone 10mg daily cialis 5mg buy xenical prix france can you take ibuprofen and methocarbamol together imagenes de las gragea cyrux o misoprostol wellbutrin and diabetes cialis vs tadafil does medicaid in florida cover linezolid atal bihari in apki adalat albuterol 4 times a day atorvastatin substitutes isoptin 40 w ci?…??y side effects of glucophage 500 mg uric acid il viagra a cosa serve take amoxicillin with milk lisinopril api price in india azithromycin does for 1 year old nizoral tablet harga azithromycin 500 mg 4 pills at once medroxyprogesterone 2.5 mg tab azithromycin 500 dose for sore throat methocarbamol dosage canine recharger mobicarte internet orange nizoral boots uk topamax hallucinations side effects cialis and extenze lasix end stage renal disease does plavix have black box warning half life of 1g single dose of azithromycin test de grossesse clomid metformina via administra? terbinafine for toddlers zyprexa 40 mg dosage 875 mg amoxicillin dosage is that high viagra generics philippines diflucan treatment prostate infection metronidazole absest tooth can men take fluconazole tablet usp cuanta dosis de cytotec puedo usar si no hace efecto effects of depo provera after stopping ketamine gabapentin cream bupropion xl cost walmart uk propecia buy steroid arimadex husband low sperm count clomid fungsi obat dexamethasone tablet long term bactrim therapy how to drink xenical is it safe to take green tea and augmentin allopurinol potassium can you drink wine while taking wellbutrin diuretic hydrochlorothiazide v lasix future side effects of accutane free viagra pills can i buy azithromycin in birmingham uk diference cialis and viagra prezzo carburante cipro amitriptyline nhs metoprolol er succinate 25 mg benefit in knee surgery propecia right me posologia moduretic pasti lamisil cost australia what is naprosyn sr 750 used for best price for sildenafil generic viagra albuterol in copd linezolid 1200 mg how much gabapentin for opiate withdrawal tamoxifen en ontlasting y urinate frequently when on prednisone tabs lisinopril hctz side effects sunlight will topamax cause weight loss when does viagra work after you take it revatio kosten isotretinoin varige bivirkninger cost singulair insurance taking flagyl and eatinh yogurt at the same time generic viagra pill things to know before taking clomid como comprar cialis contrareembolso jak szybko dziala zoloft cialis half pill get out ur system baclofen belgie mobicity galaxy note 10.1 levitradoes it really works acetato de ciproterona pelo sus does accutane make acne worse beginning poison ivy prednisone dosage taper schedule cialis pump switch from fluoxetine to duloxetine do you have to take cialis every day for it to work compare generic viagra price buy clomid in philippines strattera day night zoloft side effects blood in stool tardive dyskinesia zyprexa lawsuit online viagra paypal premarine .625 tablets for transgender use nizoral ketoconazole in target diflucan over the counter in uk singulair 10 mg overdose metformin y el tamoxifen generic viagra for cheap ciprofloxacin with birth control pills dutasteride allergie ofloxacin ear drops side effects amoxicillin and prednisone std metoprolol toprol xl conversion ivermectin dosage pigs bactrim 800 mg dosage for uti rx meloxicam and hydrocodone bloeding na clomid what can you take for hirsutism while on tamoxifen propranolol and klonopin 40mg of propranolol during clonazepam withdrawals viagra para hombres de 30 zoloft gastroschisis inderal veterinary azithromycin dura 500mg pille lithium seroquel kombination erythromycin algae pertustat 500 antibiotic for sorethroat length of therapy for valley fever fluconazole tamoxifen 100mg fertility drugs celexa patient assistance application costo voltaren fiale amoxicillin cure diarrhea amoxicillin liquid dosage 20 costs nyc wil acyclovir 400mg cure herpetic whitlow nifedipine sr onset action sertraline 100mg price uk duloxetine 60 mg capsules tetracycline fish humans seroquel xr dosage for ocd propecia how does it work lamisil cream on polished nails flomax by g tube lisinopril 5 mg weight gain on zoloft will azithromycin treat gingivitis ovulation days after taking clomid albuterol without sulfate viagra tablets for women in andhra qual o generico do bactrim do i take novadex and clomid 7 days a week nolvadex 20 mg for sale does avodart create estrogen how long after clomid will i ovulate abilify with kids amoxicillin toothache online uk viaggiare a cipro nord como se toma el celebrex reaction of taking nexium hp 7 pregnancy birth risks to taking zoloft dose dependant viagra aux herbes horn buy clomid legit how long does azithromax 2g stay in your system synthroid causing acid reflux buspar 5 mg for anxiety pueden tomar viagra las mujeres abilify und thc buy lexapro from canada synthroid 25 mcg weight loss does atenolol have acetaminophen in it neurontin 600 mg ?§entikli film tablet generic celebrex india cytotec 3 semanas de embarazo dosis duracan fluconazole 150mg yusimox amoxicillin crushed viagra for women doxepin hcl prices is robaxin as strong as soma bayan viagra resimleri celebrex used for viagra pills available in south africa nolvadex side effects numbness cialis alle erbe naturali gabapentin sciatica treatment desyrel 50 mg tablet muss man metformin vor einer op absetzen hacked by viagra neurontin hernia take metformin at night or morning for pregnancy allopurinol use can u take allegra with mucinex flomax kapsul 0.4 medroxyprogesterone acetate explain in hindi bupropion guanfacine dosis aciclovir dewasa what are thyroxine levels


“Don’t curse the Religious Peacemakers.”
by Mark Shea | Source:
As car fires (and nursery school fires, hospital fires and parish fires) still blaze in France, I’m reminded that recently, Pope Benedict XVI asked Muslim leaders to do something that many in the West have been clamoring for Muslim leaders to do: Make it very publicly clear that the kind of violence so prominent in the Islamic world is to be condemned and repudiated.

One person to respond to the Pope’s call was King Abdullah of Jordan, who issued a strong statement condemning the Bronze-Age fanaticism of so many of his co-religionists, and calling for Muslims of good will to actively oppose it. It was a real step forward, and in remarks of gratitude for the king’s willingness to work for peace, Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, Archbishop of Washington, D.C., said:

“A few months ago, when I was privileged to pray for you on another occasion in this capital city, I asked Allah, the compassionate and merciful Lord of all the world, to bless you, and to help you make your country a bridge across which all nations might walk in unity, fellowship and love. As I listened to your words today, I believe my prayer is being answered.”

He then briefly thanked the king for being a courageous voice of reform in the Islamic world and closed with this brief prayer.

“Your Majesty’s call and that of the Holy Father are in so many ways the same. May Allah, the merciful and compassionate, continue to guide your steps along this noble path. May he guide and protect you, your family and your beloved country and may peace and justice come to all lands and all peoples through your efforts, your vision and your courage. In the name of Allah, the merciful and compassionate God, we pray. Amen.”

The Catholic blogsophere (commonly known as “St. Blog’s parish”) promptly went nuts over this. Several members of St. Blog’s took it for granted that Cardinal McCarrick is an “apostate and hypocrite” and the worshipper of a “moon god.” “Diogenes,” a frequent poster on the Catholic World News “Off the Record” blog, took it as a foregone conclusion that this is grounds for dismissing the cardinal from office, and the baying hounds in the comment box growled their threats of excommunication, not only at the cardinal, but at the Holy Father himself.

Questions: Why would a successor to the apostles hide the fullness of the faith by praying as a non-Christian? In the Name of God the Father, Son & Holy Spirit, why has the Holy Father not accepted Cardinal McCarrick’s resignation?

As one member of St. Blog’s aptly summed up the mind of the tribunal:

“I don’t buy ... the Lumen Gentium version of things. We worship the Triune God, Moslems don’t. And the adherents of Islam refer to non-Moslems as ‘infidels.’ (See a good dictionary here; if one isn’t a Moslem, one is an infidel.) If I am an infidel, then I don’t share the same faith with these folks. How, then, can anyone say we worship the same God? And, please, don’t try that ‘God of Abraham’ stuff on me. That’s ecumenistic tripe (in my humble opinion).”

Here are a number of basic problems with this “Fire ... Aim ... Ready” approach to the Church’s teaching.

First, the “moon god” charge is what is known as the “genetic fallacy.” Catholics have to put up with this every time we are told “Easter” is a “pagan holiday” (because the word derives from Eostre, a pagan goddess). The reality is, whatever the obscure etymology of a word may be, the important thing is, “What does the word mean now?” Try it with the word “gay” and you’ll see what I mean.

In Arabic, “Allah” does not mean “moon god.” It means, “the one God of Abraham, merciful and compassionate Creator and judge of the world.” If it was idolatrous for Cardinal McCarrick to pray to Allah, then the entire Maronite Catholic Church is likewise idolatrous, because they have prayed to Allah in Arabic for centuries.

“But McCarrick was living out the ecumenical tripe of Vatican II, which tries to pretend that all religions are the same. It’s a complete departure with Tradition!”

As to Tradition, here is modernist indifferentist heretic Pope St. Gregory VII, burbling stupid ecumenical Vatican II tripe to the Muslim Sultan of Bougie in North Africa in 1076:

“Most certainly you and we ought to love each other in this way more than other races of men, because we believe and confess one God, albeit in different ways, who each day we praise and reverence as the Creator of all ages and the governor of this world.”

How could the good saint sound so much like Lumen Gentium? Because all he is doing, all St. Thomas does when he cites Muslims and pagans with approval, all the Church has ever done, is affirm what can be affirmed in common with non-Catholic religious and philosophical tradition, while being careful not to affirm what cannot be affirmed in common.

As Vatican II puts it, “The Catholic Church rejects nothing that is true and holy in these religions.” It does not therefore follow that the Church thinks all religions are alike.

“But Muslims deny that Jesus is Allah’s son!” And right here’s the problem.

For not just Muslims deny that God has a Son. Jews deny that Adonai has a Son too. So if we grab at the “Allah has no Son” trope to insist that Muslims worship a “false god,” we inevitably must also commit ourselves to the proposition that the Jews, too, are idolaters.

Now the vast majority of conservative Catholics retain enough sanity to reject this latter-day Marcionite theology. Most are cognizant of the long miserable history of anti-Semitism in the Church. Indeed, not a few of them say that Israel must be supported at all costs, precisely because they are allies in the war against radical Islamic terror. But because many Catholics view their faith through the lens of American politics, they find themselves in an acutely uncomfortable bind when they declare that Muslims, but not Jews, worship “another god” due to their rejection of Jesus as God’s Son.

For, of course, what really drives this discussion is the simple fact that Jews did not fly airplanes into the World Trade Center. Nor did they light up the suburbs of Paris with car fires. Muslims did.

So we would very much like the Church to please stop saying that monotheists who make us angry have something in common with us, but we grant the Church our permission to say, “Monotheists who do not make us angry are fellow worshippers of the one God.”

The obvious and overwhelming danger of this approach is that, in addition to being false, this keeps Jews safe from the charge of idolatry for exactly as long as Jews do not anger Christians. Basing our theology on a mood is a very bad way to proceed. And the proof of this is precisely the sorry history of Christian persecution of Jews, which not infrequently found false justification in the charge that Jews, in not believing in Jesus, could legitimately be called the worshipers of a false god.

All Vatican II (or Pope St. Gregory VII or Cardinal McCarrick) are doing is affirming what can be affirmed in common with Muslims. To say, “We have something in common,” is not to say, “We have everything in common.” However, to cry, “Apostate! Heretic!” at one who rightly affirms such commonality is to commit a sin of rash judgment.

Mark Shea is senior content editor for


Shopping Wars

Christmas Wins at Wal-Mart —
The Catholic League’s Bill Donohue fired the opening salvo of the annual battle over the word “Christmas” in holiday shopping. Wal-Mart apologized for banning the word.

American Girl Dolls Boycott — A Catholic school canceled a lucrative American Girl Fashion Show because of the doll company’s pro-abortion contributions.

‘Higher Law,’ 60 Years After Nuremberg — The Nazi war crimes trials in Nuremberg, Germany, still have lessons for today, 60 years after they opened.

Religion Class Is Hit or Miss in Cincinnati —
The Archdiocese of Cincinnati takes a passive approach to ensuring school children receive instruction that conforms to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Inperson Interview — The chief rabbi of Ireland, recently awarded a papal knighthood, said Christians must not feel forced to leave the Holy Land, “the land of their origins.”


Fired Pro-Abortion Teacher Files Complaints — The bishop of Sacramento, Calif., justified the firing of a Catholic school teacher for her cooperation with abortion-provider Planned Parenthood. But he said he could do nothing to reinstate a student who was dismissed from the school after her mother complained about the teacher.


Military Chaplains Find New Anti-Discrimination Policies Discriminatory — Some military chaplains believe that new guidelines are restricting their free speech when it comes to offering public prayers.


Media Watch — News from the Vatican


New Agency Perseveres With a Missionary Spirit — The Register speaks with Father Bernardo Cervellera, the head of Asia News and former director of the Vatican´s Fides missionary news service.


Media Watch — Keeping an eye on the news around the world.


Editorial — God’s Chosen People



Mark Shea, Don’t Curse the Religious Peacemakers

Joanna Bogle, Don’t Let Violence Stop the Debate

Fr. Andrew McNair, LC Dare to Be Civil This Thanksgiving


Mom Heard the Mission Bell — and Answered — In anticipation of the Dec. 3 feast of St. Francis Xavier, a tour of San Xavier del Bac Mission in Tucson, Ariz. By Lynanne Lasota.

Spirit & Life: Looking for simple but effective ways to witness Christ, Brother John Raymond thinks outside the box. The tabernacle box, that is.


We Need a Hero. Can Harry Fill the Bill? —
A review of a new movie by Steven D. Greydanus.

Weekly Video Picks by Steven D. Greydanus.

Weekly TV Picks by Daniel J. Engler.


‘Far From What Is Expected In a Christian Institution’ —
Why a Catholic high-school principal canceled the prom. By Dana Lorelle.

Campus Watch: Eye on higher ed.

Weekly Book Pick: John Burger recommends Opus Dei: An Objective Look Behind the Myths and Reality of the Most Controversial Force in the Catholic Church by John L. Allen Jr.


Giving Thanks By ‘Giving Back’ — This Thanksgiving Day, some hearty Catholic souls will exchange the family kitchen for the soup kitchen, serving the poor as a way to bring the Gospel to places where people might otherwise go hungry in more ways than one. By Joseph Pronechen.

Prolife Profile: Children of Hope, an apostolate of the Community of St. John, teaches children to adore Jesus really present in the Blessed Sacrament. By Veronica Wendt.

Fact of Life: All supervised activity and no unstructured playtime make Johnny a dull boy.

ProLife Victories: Hope in the headlines.

Umbert the Unborn

Baby Mugs

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular