bc pharmacare clopidogrel azithromycin and rapid heart beat provera and clomid fertility treatment uk acyclovir for cold sores metronidazole sa buntis fluconazole pret ko difference between ciprotab and ciprofloxacin is it possible to buy viagra over the counter in europe cytotec cuatro semanas como se descubrio cytotec can premarin cause insomnia misoprostol 250 mg untuk menggugurkan use paypal to order bactrim mother son and viagra bupropion xl cost without insurance price of levaquin 500 mg in the philippines inderal 160 and water retention tablets switching patients from escitalopram to citalopram ondansetron price usa synthroid xpi reviews olanzapine 2.5 mg tab metronidazole tablets 400mg causes black stool side effects of prednisone chat room albumin and lasix diuresis metformin chloride sleepy after consuming can someone allergic to ancef take augmentin does amitriptyline have street value where to buy lamisil side spray ciprofloxacino no es penicilina quetiapine high can i take tylenol while taking augmentin ketoconazole 2 scalp solution arcolane usage weight loss after clomid viagra price in karachi cytotec funciona para abortar when you first start taking paxil ultrasound clomid remedio viagra zovirax price canada tamsulosin potassium levels lamisil at advanced orlistat capsules 120mg in hindi will milk wear off metronidazole azithromycin antihistamine together naproxen w902 street value augmentin 228mg for kids para que sirven lad padtillas montelukast sod de 10mg 10 mg femara success bactrim antibiotic used treat staph infection buy flagyl 500mg online how common is hair loss on accutane indomethacin 50 mg for migraines ovulation after last clomid pill obat ketoconazole cream khasiat hydrochlorothiazide shortness of breath como tomar la cytotec con seis semanas erowid grapefruit juice and gabapentin cost for olanzapine doxycycline hyclate treatment for ringworm symbicort and wellbutrin precio soles de voltaren en aerosol finasteride buy online uk much does cialis cost without insurance clomid et grossesse multiple enceinte buy viagra cheap prices cost of oral zyvox versus iv zyvox what is amoxicillin ctb famvir full prescribing information valtrex for warts uso metformina en embarazo azithromycin kosten in indonesie cialis price 10 mg in wallgreens or walmart difference between ciprofloxin ear and eye drops girls viagra buy one packet in india least cost viagra cyproheptadine prostate amoxicilline zwanger can i take benadryl and trazodone together colchicine online cheap 30 days on diflucan 100mg can i use ciprotab and doxycycline during my mesuration prazosin street vaule forzest guercmorteo australia microbac ofloxacino 400 mg avodart 0.5 mg softgel look xarelto cialis side effects antidepressant development protocol metoprolol used with lisinopril acyclovir poor bioavailability propranolol graves disease max dose tetracycline while taking erythromycin atorvastatin calcium side effects xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai mirtazapine on sale not eating while on prednisone digoxin injection price valtrex dosing for recurrent cold sores prednisone treatment carpal tunnel cymbalta to pristiq switch can viagra be covered canada levaquin bacterial spectrum where do i buy viagra on line in australia erythromycin pads for acne reviews is carvedilol a narcotic is zoloft a good medication for anxiety xenical price in rupees can i take sprintec and synthroid at same time amoxicillin trihydrate drug class does cialis make you bigger than normal can metronidazole 200 mg be taken by a pregnant woman cialis price. australia thyroxine ciprofloxacin dutasteride liver diflucan acne buy ivermectin online no prescription purchase depo provera why does the nhs not provide propecia metronidazole flagyl oral for yeast infections recommended use of viagra clomid side effects after ovulation can u put metronidazole in vagina thyroxine 0.3 mg is biotech ciprofloxan for uring infections buy zithromax 1g oral atorvastatin 10mg efectos secundarios what is accutane 20mg amoxicillin 500 und sport is buspirone good for panic attacks prednisone withdrawal depression anxiety can i use a ventolin inhaler when pregnant lu code for wellbutrin celebrex en francais lisinopril 30 mg efectos secundarios glucophage and pregnancy category what time of the day should one take clomid does lisinopril cause fluid retention black box warning took 1000 mg of amoxicillin at the same time doxycycline otc levitra bankadresse sleep room can u get pregnant wen adminstering clomid tablets what is gabapentin cap 300mg used for topiramate for tourettes propecia 5mg wellbutrin tiredness colchicine 1mg price can i take excedrine with augmentin 875 i want to buy kamagra in uk using paypal clomid pregnitude bupropion xl vs xr levothyroxine 75 mcg tablet price example of a prednisone taper for poison ivy does malaria medication affect flagyl orlistat daily dosage erythromycin cream uk how muchdo viagra cost how much antibiotics can a ten month old consume eli lilly and olanzapineolanzapine and depot medication la pecora allegra roma capannelle diflucan contraceptive pill can you buy synthroid online viagra 50mg price costco valacyclovir price australia cuanto vale cytotec en panama bactrim ds trade name in pakistan metronidazole dosage treat bv lasix injetavel bula pdf how often should a 16 month old have amoxicillin grapefruit seed extract and synthroid prednisone how safe is it why does acyclovir ointment cost so much aternative au flagyl wie gut wirkt propecia stores that sell viagra in australia flagyl tablet price in pakistan 10 mg pfizer norvasc inactive ingredients what is mobicip safe browser carvedilol6.25mg tablet para k es can i take cephalexin for a sore throat parlodel with clomid does zoloft work on anxiety cialis can coconut oil be taken with clopidogrel more about biotech ciprofloxacin piroxicam of contradication did generic lexapro came out fluvoxamine 200 mg escitalopram fda approval can u take levitra after surgery ventolin buhar makinesi fiyati tadalafil from cipla ltd kamagra aus indien erfahrung zovirax 1g lexapro 5 years hair loss weight loss with topiramate flagyl muscle pain flagyl for vaginal infection walmart kamagra dublin pastillas singulair montelukast 5 mg buy viagra uk pay money after delivery does wellbutrin make you feel dizzy metoprolol succinate indication for left bundle block how to lose weight with metformin buy generic buspar sitem farmakokinetik metformin bupropion hcl xl and alcohol valacyclovir 1 gm vs 500 seroquel xr and skin rash spironolactone male fertility 18 mg strattera too strong viagra pills for sale in subang jaya transmitting herpes on valtrex propecia preventative jak brac diltiazem hydrochloride use of augmentin 625 lyrica versus gabapentin neurontin lower back pain wellbutrin generic 681 prazosin recreational value one time prednisone dose cytotec forums philippines cialis generic jelly tamoxifen prevent cancer can i crushndiflucan phenergan tablets over counter nz spironolactone easy bruising frankfurt where to get cialis clomid and tamox pct buy generic bactrim no prescription maxair vs proventil is meloxicam 15 mg used for sinus what age would you need cialis can you take 2 kamagra oral jelly walmart levitra 20mg prices valtrex and ativan propecia price and dose tab cabergoline 0.25 mg estradiol 60 mg aldactone and cortisol levels nature thyroid vs synthroid cost walmart prices cialis 5mg seroquel patentablauf gabapentin reduce dosage coupons for strattera 80g mirtazapine side effects australia flagyl prescription canada levitra odt 10 vs levitra 20 efficacy propecia 3 months uk lexapro to help with tramadol withdrawal symptoms terbinafine plus mankind avodart dosage instructions flagyl yaz doxycycline and propranolol online forum nolvadex from the uk metformin fornidd for pcos apakah xenical berbahaya xeloda 2500 mg spironolactone male breast growth order olanzapine eciwlcodkedefe walgreens lipitor montelukast sodium oral granules 4mg nexium 20mg sr viagra for sale usa indomethacin teva 4030 it ok to take nyquil while taking levofloxacin when does regrowth on finasteride start does generic wellbutrin xl cause weight gain doxycycline facial ringworm priligy costo en venezuela proscar idealo can doxycycline cause yellow teeth zithromax 25mg can fluconazole tablet cure candidiasis infection. meloxicam para perros costo propecia for sale uk famciclovir pronounce effects of cipro lower back pain propranolol lek pharmacopoeia propranolol pdf vibramycin capsules action urdu duloxetine free trial st martin buying viagra pakistanis for benicar generic ed now kamagra jel ima u beogradu u potassium supplement and lasix evista 60 mg generico are cipro and levaquin the same will misoprostol cause a miscarriage zofran uk buy amoxil 400 mg chewable celexa versus zoloft anxiety correct dosage viagra first week on lexapro amoxicillin trihydrate 500 mg strep throat lynoral 1 mg celebrex and viagra xenical no prescription australia obat apa flagyl forte metronidazole 20mg lexapro vs 10mg flagyl treatment for fishes cymbalta narcolepsy desyrel 75 mg dosage schedule for prednisone blister pack mobile banking mobicash metronidazole fish food uk is bedwetting a side effect of zoloft desogestrel 0.03 mg ethinyl estradiol 0.15 mg can you crush buspar allegra odontologia tatuape leer the mystery of allegra does united pay for viagra azithromycin dosing for cellulitis maxalt side effects neck pain se necesita receta para la viagra paura del cialis taking lexapro with zyrtec antibiotic is safe thrice a day how long to take paxil can you buy cialis without a script 875mg twice a day of amoxicillin to cure bv clopidogrel bisulphate indian manufacturer diflucan liquit babies thrush metformin and acv for ifg aquarium pharmaceuticals e.m. erythromycin can metronidazole table be used for a yeast infection cramping on clomid day 20 plavix bruising treatment 20mg accutane 3 times a week cephalexin erythema multiforme zyprexa annual sales viagra college men difference between ciprotab and ciproflaxin how long before doxycycline works for acne how do i withdraw from lexapro viagra kaufen in walmart metoprolol tartrate vs succinate propranolol anxiety long term viagra respiratory can bactrim treat chlamydia can tadalafil controls ejaculation accutane sports como usar cytotec paso a paso temazepam quetiapine interaction uk wellbutrin works well fluconazole affect period buy amoxicillin canada azithromycin can b used in lymphadenopathy walgreens pharmcy how much is plavix doxycycline ambroxol uses 36 horas tadalafil 20 mg vardenafil tablets buy mixing cialis with black ant metronidazole inhalation can i take benadryl with amlodipine besylate can i buy ivermectin over the counter dog levothyroxine sodium maximum dosage mirtazapine 30 mg to 45mg wellbutrin xl vs effexor xr za jak dlouho zabere augmentin is terazosin a generic for avodart online cialis no prescription canada estradiol hormon folikularna faza thyroxine breast milk production doxycycline price costco apakah amoxicillin bisa mengobati jerawat can you snort clonidine generic lexapro and muscle aches adalat xl 3 seroquel 100mg high can i buy lipitor from canada can lexapro make anxiety worse

Bioethical Questions Addressed in Vatican Released "Dignitas Personae"

An interview with Father Thomas Berg LC, executive director of the Westchester Institute for Ethics and the Human Person and member of the Ethics Committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board.
by Colin Fagnan, LC | Source:

Dignitas Personae (“The Dignity of the Person”), document released by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith with the approval of the Holy Father, reaffirms the Vatican’s position on multiple bioethical topics which include human cloning, in vitro fertilization and more recently, embryonic stem cell research. The ongoing scientific research on such topics continues to produce new moral questions which for the most part, do not immediately provide quick easy answers.   

The precursor to Dignitas Personae (DP) was Donum Vitae (The Gift of Life) which the same congregation published in 1987 and sparked debate in some quarters of the Church, particularly because of the document’s “restrictions” on certain alternative means of procreation  such as invitro-fertilization. DP will not substitute Donum Vitae nor does it introduce any new core principles; the new Instruction seems intended rather to serve as a compliment to the 1987 document.

With the release of this new Instruction as a backdrop, I recently interviewed Father Thomas Berg LC, executive director of the Westchester Institute for Ethics and the Human Person and member of the Ethics Committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board. Fr. Berg is directly involved with bioethics issues and collaborates with leading experts in the field of both science and morality.

1) Before we address the Instruction, what can you tell us of your involvement in the bioethics debate in North America?
Here at the Westchester Institute, our central purpose to is address very thorny moral problems by bringing together some of the finest specialists in ethics, moral theology and related disciplines to address the problem and hopefully move the debate forward. Many of these problems of course are to be found in the realm of bioethics. We have worked for the past four years evaluating and promoting alternatives to embryo-destructive stem cell research (such as Altered Nuclear Transfer and Direct Cell Reprogramming), we have explored the issue of ‘embryo rescue’ from a Catholic perspective as a possible solution to the dilemma of surplus and unwanted, frozen IVF embryos; we have explored such questions as the use of condoms to prevent the spread of the AIDS virus, as well as the still controversial question of brain death. I also serve on the ethics committee of the Empire State Stem Cell Board which oversees $600 million in New York state funding for stem cell research. I also collaborate closely with members of the President’s Council on Bioethics, the National Catholic Bioethics Center and the United States Catholic Conference.

2) How does your work with the Westchester Institute contribute to the ongoing research on bioethics?
I’ll answer with one example.  Both times that President Bush used his veto power to halt bills in Congress that would have increased federal funding for embryo destructive research, he did so on the premise that there are ethically acceptable and scientifically endorsed alternatives either available or in the making.  His hand was strengthened by the fact these alternatives were on the horizon. They were on the horizon (and on the White House radar) largely due to the efforts of Dr. William Hurlbut of Stanford University and member of the President’s Council on Bioethics.  Dr. Hurlbut’s ability to influence the situation was, in turn, largely strengthened by our work as an Institute in getting a large number of ethicists and moral theologians in the know and on board in supporting and at least conditionally endorsing some of these alternatives. I think we had a real impact on the Bush policy and indirectly on public opinion about stem cell research.

3) What do you think the Magisterium is trying to communicate to the public through Dignitas Personae? Is the document very explicit in addressing many issues in bioethics?
The Church wants to first of all reaffirm the principles already established in the previous Instruction, also from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, published in 1987, Donum Vitae, a document which in its time did the same thing, namely, addressing several issues bearing on the dignity of nascent human life and conjugal love.  The new instruction, Dignitas Personae, is something of an update. With it, the Church has shown that she is very forward looking on these matters and abreast of the most recent developments. Through DP, the Church wants to offer faithful Catholics a point of reference around which to form their consciences on these delicate and complex matters such as In Vitro Fertilization, Emergency Contraception, Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD), Gene Therapy, and a host of other issues mentioned in the document.

4) In your opinion, what is the most significant topic addressed by the Church with this important document?
I would say there are two teachings that are most prominent. The first is that the human embryo is to be treated as, and given the respect due to, a human person from the first moment of conception. The other is the reaffirmation of the dignity of human procreation and its proper place within marriage and its proper source, namely, the marital act of a husband and wife.

5) Will Dignitas Personae be overall well received by North American Catholics? Do you think its population as a whole is open to what this document offers as a message?
If they read it thoughtfully and with an open mind, yes. Even better if they were to take the time to study it carefully, and also to re-read and study the previous Instruction Donum Vitae.  Unfortunately, I fear these Catholics will be a minority. Many Catholics will largely remain ignorant of the document, and many will struggle to understand the Church’s teaching that recourse to in vitro fertilization is morally illicit. But that is not the fault of the document or the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. It is simply a reminder of the dire need we have in the Church today for adult catechesis.  Adult Catholics need to have the reasons behind these various moral norms explained to them, and explained well and convincingly. Today, that is still a very tall order. There are not enough well prepared, adult catechists to go around. So this remains a huge challenge for the Church as we continue on into the 21st century.

6) It seems to be the case that many people are simply out of touch with what the Catholic Church is teaching on the topic of bioethics; many were not aware, especially among the younger generation, of any previous document addressing the issue (such as Donum Vitae, not to mention Humanae Vitae  the Church’s 1968 teaching on contraception). Do you think Dignitas Personae is relevant to the lives of people today? Even to young people?

Yes, absolutely. But again, this Instruction will refer them back to the previous Instruction Donum Vitae and I think most people who never looked at that document will want to go back and read and study it.  The younger the readers, the more “relevant” these documents become because for younger persons bioethical issues are as ordinary as baseball, the Internet or text messaging. They are also much more familiar with biology and biotech than older folks, so yes, this will be of interest to them.

7) Many Catholics were hoping that DP would give a clear answer on the question of whether so-called ‘embryo rescue’ is licit, meaning whether, for example, a married couple could attempt to thaw and then implant in the wife’s womb one or more unwanted embryos in frozen storage at an IVF clinic, perhaps even with the intention of adopting the embryos later. Did DP clarify this question?
Suprisingly, no, DP is unclear in its answer in this regard. It addresses the question in number 19. The long and the short of it is that the document would appear to lean in the direction of considering embryo-rescue illicit, but it falls short of stating that clearly.  It does state, however, that a couple attempting to transfer embryos merely as a solution for their infertility would be acting illicitly.  In this, it seems, the document sees a violation of the goods of marriage. The yet unresolved question is whether embryo adoption, pursued simply with the intent of rescuing unwanted embryos, is in itself illicit for similar reasons. The document does not address this and we will need further clarification on this from the CDF is some other form.

We can be sure that continued medical and scientific breakthroughs in biotechnology will occasion more instructions from Rome similar to DP. These instructions are of vital importance in order to give reasons for the Church’s teaching on the sanctity of life and marriage, and offer guidance to Catholics who want to inform their consciences in accord with those teachings. 

In these months following its release in North America, DP has not played a major role in the public square and it remains to be seen what impact it will have, if any, on bioethical debates. It’s still not clear precisely when the Vatican will unveil its next instruction on the bioethics issue, but it will undoubtedly keep a close watch on any new developments from under the microscope.

Contact the author through: 

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular