tetracycline tqeovertoz discount que concecuencias trae el misoprostol 200mg clopidogrel with or without omeprazole nip tuck allegra caldarello soundtrack baixan.com is outdated cialis bad clomid vs hcg pct hopemedicalinstitute.org buy prednisone online for dogs will the higher dose of cialis work better how much does lisinopril reduce blood pressure can amoxicillin treat genital herpes wbstaffing.pl aldactone baownbeuv without prescription propecia and finasteride in india metronidazole 250 mg pret ile-au-tresor.net lipitor tangelos wellbutrin no desire to drink njxdxx.com phenergan 7 month old baby will metronidazole cure chlamydia accutane after 10 weeks how to get off 30 mg of cymbalta generic singulair us category of norfloxacin with metronidazole suspension does a bigger cialis dose produce a better erection sampon nizoral impotriva caderii parului differenza finasteride dutasteride nolvadex get rid gyno batkomuhendislik.com xeloda 500mg tablets pil legitimate suppliers of viagra australia cyproheptadine sedative cd rom pasquale cipro neto amlodipine sandoz eco 10 webtodesigns.co where can you buy viagra over the counter in victoria taking clomid with folic acid what does zoloft do yahoo rule of 2 for prednisone wellbutrin sr drug classification alternative for linezolid directions on how dogs should take prednisone hortexpo.com levitra brand price is viagra on the 4 dollar plan at walmart metformina para las verrugas streetstylesinfo.com protonix viagra metformin sr zanza is it safe to take allegra when pregnant para que es meloxicam 7.5mg bactrim side effcts acid reflux orlistat def 50 phenergan 10mg for babies below 6 month how long does fluconazole 150 mg stay in your system finasteride 5 mg prospecto indikasi chloramphenicol salep mata gabapentin for carpal tunnel pain taking levothyroxine with contraceptive pill market name for orlistat 120 is nexium effective long term woodmizer.net.pl propecia keskustelu doxycycline how long do side effects last upset stomach viagra what to expect mycontradictions.com noiseshop.mx zovirax rx using nail polish whie tkng lamisil tablets blog.fiberwire.ca metronidazole and chlamidia trachomatis valtrex vs acyclovir in pregnancy is neurontin used to treat fibromyalgia overdose symptom synthroid cost acyclovir without insurance can you take synthroid with other medications vizioescort.com vardenafil leukemia autogiant.com beccapronchick.com rizatriptan ingredients conjugated estrogens turkce anlami misoprostol abortion price generic zoloft 100mg side effects efeksamping amlodipine besylate iheartjonahbees.net can you take nolvadex and clomid at the same time side effect nexium weight gain decadron for game fowl can two year old toddlers take trazodone para que sirve el medicamento diflucan 150 mg ultimas noticias sobre el costa allegra wellbutrin dosage and smoking cessation can i take benydryl with buspar and citalopram is amoxicillin and clavulanate gluten free danazol danocrine zoloft weight gain breastfeeding will amoxicillin treat stds price bupropion sr men that take premarin lamisil 1 pie de atleta fruehstuecks-club.net viagra erfaringer tamiflu and erythromycin bupropion sr alcohol montelukast evening effect tamoxifen breast mri nonallergic ampicillin rash counterfeit viagra pills celebrex 400 mg twice daily zoloft life expectancy amoxicillin 500mg mining urdu buy zithromax 2mg on line lamisil jock itch dermgel review what should you not take with prednisone ic metoprolol succ er 25 mg if you take 2 pills of cialis what happens bactrim helicobacter pylori mice estradiol a rak jajnika will doxycycline work against the depo shot can u take con rx sinus with paxil irtech.com.pl men taking clomid increase chances of twins buy 1g zithromax how long does prednisone take to work for rash how much are gabapentin worth in the uk rach 300mg birth control after fluconazole aciclovir comprimidos generico pre make viagra work well blue force viagra arizonaequinerehab.com intrathecal baclofen and constipation get rid lexapro side effects metoprolol er 50 mg en espanol healthylifestyleart.com doxycycline hyclate loss of appetite metspirit.com necesito receta para comprar cytotec en ensenada zoloft with methadone does erythromycin affect microgynon jazz 500mg zithromax pill lasix jcode amitriptyline fiber substitute medication for tetracycline does cipro cure salmonella eeroaarnio.cz flagyl one day dose reviews hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg side effects how long does azithromycin get absorbed by the body viagra overnight delivery saturday lamisil cost london drugs zofran injection dosage a comprehensive view arizonaequinerehab.com cipro for cats uti periactin 4 mg dosage finasteride pill shape asiliahomehealth.com centergaz.pl enterobacter metronidazole accutane not working 4 months viagra ohne rezept abholen diflucan and chlamydia wineworldseries.com nizoral ketoconazole side effects ibizaglobalradio.com lasix safe in pregnancy were to buy topiramate to stop craving in uk viagra lo prado trazodone 25 mg withdrawal anti inflammatoire celebrex 200mg prometrium 3 weeks pregnant lisinopril 2.5mg tab internl lb itaessienchrisandco.com can clomid cause heartburn when amoxicillin does not work can bactrim cause gastritis harbifilmizle.com hoxtonradio.com nizoral shampoo baldness treatment clomipramine increased anxiety metronidazole 500 mg dosing tamoxifen schedule in australia asthma, prednisone, and decongestant informacion sobre medicamento zovirax viagra ohne rezept kaufen forum mooboos.com clomid action quitting seroquel xr cold turkey cialis neuropathie muscle and joint pain celexa momandfitness.com warchiwach.pl strattera causing hoarseness and sorethroat perte de poids sous zyprexa proscar cost vizioescort.com paroxetine hcl 15mg if levothyroxine not working 21editore.com comprar cialis en andorra worldtravelandtourservices.com wellbutrin side effects grinding teeth infokurye.com wellbutrin 100mg sr balkan-area.com erythromycin for severe acne ella 22 cytotec viagra kullandim forum nexium vs prevacid cost prednisone acetate dogs causing loss of hair shawniverse.com clomid uk pharmacy carrepairmanualdoc.com h-o-s.co.uk tamoxifen cream is drinking while on accutane bad sildenafil citrate oral gel patents do you have to take paxil at the same time everyday tamoxifen vs femara online levitra prescription publicator.cz atarax 25 mg muadili acyclovir salep untuk goede ervaring paroxetine best deal on cialis 20mg is amoxicillin penicillin woodmizer.org.pl kimlearningcenter.com eeroaarnio.cz wast.org.uk problems with metoprolol tartrate centergaz.pl atorvastatin calcium generic vs lipitor thuoc acyclovir stada 5g viagra statictics dutasteride uruguay cost of nexium florida kamagra gold suppliers in united states ile-au-tresor.net tadalafil tablet india clomid 50mg multiples prednisone and muscle mass uses of metronidazole 500 mg mebletmd.pl how long does bactrim have shelf life nexium 40 mg tablet nedir left cephalexin out of refrigerator arizonaequinerehab.com metformin and fatigue 1judaica.com digoxin 1.25 mg iv push bollywoodinformer.com celebrex complaints gophercount.com flagyl and marijuana hillsboroughcountyfair.com can trazodone cause colitis buspar to get off ativan albuterol mdi inhaler brands 1judaica.com nizoral cream walmart does clonidine liquid work immediately levofloxacin mims augmentin dosage for toothache brand names of amoxicillin trihydrate neurontin while breastfeeding side effects for infants can i take phenergan at 8 weeks pregnant pharmacia 200 gr celecoxib colchicine 500 mg dosage infusedstudios.ca efectos adversos del avodart california-employment-lawyers.com male yeast infection treatment diflucan buy augmentin xr online 8haotejia.com doxycycline hyclate treat gonorrhea antidote for metoprolol kasiat dexamethasone zithromax suspension powder how to mix it with water is ciprofloxacin okay to consume alcohol with it metformin hcl males me pee light mehmetaliguven.com ketoconazole soap uk side effects of flagyl oral hopemedicaleducation.com side effects of lexapro anxiety azithromycin gonorrhea symptoms napabusinessadvantage.com variamedia.com.pl sarasotacojail.com backboneitgroup.com viagra eliminate headaches mild antidepressents for young adults medco price plavix zovirax first outbreak order cozaar western-showline.de axellerata.com can taking levitra cause permanent tinnitus metronidazole norfloxacin combination mooboos.com clomiphene 40 mg ritalin benzos and zoloft banganderson.co.uk dosage of sildenafil can i take abilify and prozac together castinternational.org clomid and stroke risk painful rash on back after prednisone levitra turkey mytime99.com myghsy.com zovirax peds dose can i buy metronidazole in boots buspar cost walmart dosis de ivermectina en perros con sarna sarcoptica amitriptyline 2 baclofen 2 cream hedleyenterprises.co.uk azithromycin 500 mg para que sirve nizoral cost canada profipermanentmakeup.cz buspar increased urination mayo clinic bluechamberorchestra.com wrse-modelling.org.uk can i drive while taking seroquel trying to conceive clomid nizoral shampoo good for rashes strattera adhd forum furosemide effect on kidneys amitriptyline patient information leaflet hopemedicalinstitute.org propranolol 80 mg slow release gabapentin product label clomid et ovaire polykystique cymbalta 500 flomax blood glucose levels generic cialis softtabs mail order fda warns about dangerous chinese diet pills nexium with other medications webster.sasakistrategies.com cipro xl 1000 mg used tamiflu and erythromycin do high doses of remeron cause drowsiness kimlearningcenter.com para que es clopidogrel 75 mgs depo provera takes 6 months cialis 20 mg vs 10 mg michaelgahler.de albuterol nebulizer treatments causes diarrhea buying viagra in the dominican republic levitra wirkt nicht is viagra available in sri lanka publicator.cz mikezielinski.com is amoxillin work in thyroid infection product monograph of innovator zithromax 40 mg generixc levitra can i take aleve, celebrex and coumadin warfarin 4.5 paxil made me lose weight teva amoxicillin 500mg que antibiotic tomo p cura peneumunia prednisone bad for dogs weaning off of escitalopram anxiety di ung thuoc amoxicillin can you take lexapro and adderall at the same time best time to take metoprolol propranolol and muscle weakness ventolin co ile godzin buy generic cymbalta online no prescription cost of flagyl in canada interaction between vardenafil and nexium ciprofloxacin 500 dosierung w3asia.com buy valacyclovir hcl will augmentin 875 help.uti nexium dr oz como comprar femara balkan-area.com duloxetine dr 30 mg aneyron.com haldol zyprexa combination blackisbusiness.info diflucan per cfer perdoret huaxzw.com does acyclovir cream treats for condom allergy soldextam dexamethasone 0.5 mg adalah hydrochlorothiazide vs pamabrom can you take two allegra d pills in ine day aveage cost of prednisone without insurance ciprofloxacin 750 mg dose id-protect.org paxil withdrawal drowsiness does amoxicillin make you tired astakaryaindotama.com association-secours-sante.cm chewable viagra 100 mg zithromax 3 year old how much amoxicillin should a 12 year old take propiedades de cialis 20 mg buy cheap arimidex estrace hysterectomy amoxicillin for uti how long prices of amoxicillin kamagra 100ml reviews can zoloft and klonopin effect menstrual periods ciprofloxacin dexamethasone eye ear drops meblebrzozowe24.pl cebuweb.tk orlistat da dor de cabe mylan paroxetine 10 mg side effects flagyl toothache side effects prednisone effects duration nicetouristanbul.com hopemedicaleducation.com 1819wine.com fluconazole south africa puedo tomar alcohol y aciclovir tamoxifen pneumonitis meblebrzozowe24.pl allopurinol 100 mg tablet cialis e plaunac antidepressant dropping things newhollandcommunications.de pret la cialis strattera 10 mg atomoxetine 25 im-still-learning.com anorexia de allegra versace moduretic 20 mg can you get high off neurontin within how many months interval can you take flagyl cialis super viagra zovirax generic equivalent mister-button.com amoxicillin 500 in der schwangerschaft metro2034.pl canadian brand viagra antibiotic cream singapore cellulitis can i stop lisinopril while taking cialis botanicals viacore orlistat cialis in the morning or night buscar diovan hct 160mg 12.5mg en caraca valacyclovir price in south africa clopidogrel y lactancia 283858.net hoe stoppen met cymbalta whether it is effective cialis initial reaction to zoloft keflex for cat scratch fever does viagra help premature ejeculation what sinus bacteria does septra kill acyclovir 200 mg metronidazole dogs constipated will diflucan cure candida zyprexa velotab 1mg claritin metoprolol interaction metronidazole use inlactating breast abscess hoxtonradio.com lexapro weight gain forums how long.does.zovirax.take.to cure never an outbreak low cost montelukast and levocetrizine tablet buy nexium 20 mg dapoxetina priligy funziona is spironolactone safe long term 10 vs 20 mg lexapro medicosefectivos.net nightanddaysoireeanimation.com muslim-academy.com what is olanzapine easypharm for nightanddaysoireeanimation.com can you get high off seroquel 100 albuterol 0.083 neb nephron need a nebulizer microzide 80 mg is it safe for males to have 100 mg of clomid a day amoxilina bd stay erect witnout cialis vollemaan.org nijkerkerveen.com alternative to flagyl for pets vermogensbeheer.net can you take nexium and bentyl together sildenafil em gel how long does viagra ladt hollisterlancasterlaw.com viagra venta chile metronidazole to treat candidiasis montelukast pastillas precio en benavides doxycycline infertility female buy online pfizer viagra accept paypal adverse effects of zoloft on dogs charis247.org uzdrowisko-ewa.pl levothyroxine or t3 can dogs take bactrim ds bluechamberorchestra.com how long does cialis take to work and how long nizoral et cancer de la prostate

Easter Evidence

The skepticism and suspicion of the past four decades is giving way to an acceptance that Christ's resurrection is the only explanation that makes sense.
by Tim Drake | Source: NCRegister.com

SAN DIEGO — If the so-called “Jesus Family Tomb” proves anything, it’s that efforts to discount the resurrection continue. It’s a mystery that remains a stumbling block for many.

Last month, the Discovery Channel aired James Cameron’s documentary on the “Jesus Family Tomb,” claiming the discovery of a tomb with ossuaries bearing the names of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, and “Judah son of Jesus.”

Scholars and archaeologists disproved Cameron’s findings, saying that the text on the Mary Magdalene ossuary actually read “Mary and Martha,” and that the tomb was more than likely the tomb of St. Paul’s friend, another Jesus, who was also known as Justus, son of Joseph. Following the revelation, Discovery pulled its planned repeat of the program.

Yet, according to several Catholic theologians and apologists, there’s a new trend in Scripture scholarship. That trend is away from the skepticism and suspicion of the past four decades toward an acceptance of the Gospels and toward the fact that Christ’s resurrection is the only explanation that makes sense.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that “the mystery of Christ’s resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified, as the New Testament bears witness” (CCC 639).

Pope Benedict XVI has said as much.

“I trust the Gospels,” he wrote in the introduction to his forthcoming book on Christ, Jesus of Nazareth: From the Baptism in the Jordan to the Transfiguration.

“Being a Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event,” he said in his first encyclical letter, Deus Caritas Est (God Is Love).

Protestants often turn to other sources for proof. The popular Evangelical speaker and author Josh McDowell writes about the significance of the moved stone and the grave clothes.

That’s natural, says Steve Ray, an Evangelical convert to the Catholic faith.

“In the Catholic world, we trust in the authority of the Church,” he said. “Evangelicals are always looking for facts. If all you have is the book, you’re constantly trying to prove that the book is true. We believe when the Church told us that Christ rose from the dead, the Church is the voice of Christ in the world today, and we can trust it. It’s a whole different methodology because of what we see as our source of authority.”

“What puzzles the world, and its wise philosophers and fanciful pagan poets, about the priests and people of the Catholic Church is that they still behave as if they were messengers,” wrote the British Catholic convert G.K. Chesterton in The Everlasting Man. “A messenger does not dream about what his message might be, or argue about what it probably would be; he delivers it as it is.”

“The Church would never use things like the Shroud of Turin or the gravestone to try to prove the resurrection,” said Michael Barber, professor of theology at John Paul the Great Catholic University in San Diego, Calif. “There is a distinction between public and private revelation. The shroud is not part of the deposit of faith.”

Instead, Catholics rely on the authority of the Church, the Biblical evidence, and tradition that has been passed on.

“The compelling evidence for me is the unanimous testimony of all the apostles and even a former persecutor like St. Paul,” said Brant Pitre, assistant professor of theology at Our Lady of Holy Cross College in New Orleans. “There was no debate in the first century over whether Jesus was resurrected or not.”

Scholars say that the witnesses to Christ’s resurrection are compelling for a variety of reasons.

“People will seldom die even for what they know to be true. Twelve men don’t give up their lives for a lie,” said Ray, who recently returned from France, where he was filming his “Footprints of God” series at the amphitheater in Lyon, the site of a persecution in A.D. 177. “The martyrs of Lyon underwent two days of torture and all they would say is, ‘I am a Christian.’ They knew the resurrection was true and didn’t question it.”

Barber also highlighted the diversity of sources and how they include different details as well as passages that do not paint the disciples in the best light.

“In the Road to Emmaus story, they write that they didn’t recognize him,” said Barber. “Our Biblical accounts are our best evidence.”

Several of the scholars pointed to 1 Corinthians, where Paul states that Christ appeared to 500 people.

“Some want to shy away from the Gospels because they say they were written later,” explained Barber. “If you want to believe that they were written later, then why wouldn’t the Gospels have made use of this piece of evidence from 1 Corinthians?” asked Barber.

Barber also pointed to two non-Christian sources that make reference to Christ. The first is Tacitus. The second is the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, who, noted Barber, actually mentions the resurrection.

“In Antiquities of the Jews, Book 18, Chapter 3, paragraph 3, Josephus references Jesus’ resurrection,” said Barber. “The problem is that most scholars think it’s a later Christian addition to Josephus. We don’t have his original work.”

Recent Scholarship

Belief in resurrection was not completely foreign to Judaism.

“A belief in the resurrection of the dead is a major element of traditional Judaism,” said Jon Levenson, professor of Jewish studies at Harvard. “According to the Mishnah, the first rabbinic law code, belief that God would resurrect the dead is an obligation, not an option, for Jews.”

But, as Barber pointed out, such a belief was only found in one segment of Judaism at the time of Christ.

“The Pharisees believed in resurrection; the Sadducees didn’t,” said Barber. “But along with that belief was that with the resurrection would come the dawning of the restoration of the Davidic kingdom.”

Barber also points to the fact that Christ’s resurrection is not the only resurrection attested to in the Gospels.

He referenced the resurrections of Lazarus and Jairus’ daughter.

And in the Gospel of Matthew (27:52-53), when Jesus dies, “tombs were opened, and the bodies of many saints who had fallen asleep were raised. And coming forth from their tombs after his resurrection, they entered the holy city and appeared to many.”

“The fundamental conviction in a scientific age with our post-enlightenment views is that these things didn’t happen,” said Barber. “People have determined that any source that talks about resurrection is unreliable and rule it out. What kind of science is that? You don’t just dispense with evidence that you don’t like.

“Many scholars are now recognizing that one should not so easily dismiss the reliability of the Gospel of John,” added Barber. “Some have compared the Gospel of John with the Pauline epistles and found numerous points of contact, so it’s very plausible that John’s Gospel may have been written earlier than previously thought by many historical critical scholars.”

Gone are the days where the Jesus Seminar dominated. The Jesus Seminar is a research team of New Testament scholars founded in 1985 by the late Robert Funk and ex-priest John Dominic Crossan to use historical methods to determine what Jesus may or may not have said or done. The seminar’s reconstruction of Jesus portrayed him as a wandering sage who did not found a religion or rise from the dead.

According to Barber, there’s an alignment of scholars in support of the original Gospel texts.

“The dominant strain in mainstream Biblical scholarship is from those who are convinced that the Gospels are indeed reliable,” said Barber. He cited the work of N.T. Wright, Craig Evans, Craig Blomberg and Richard Bauckham as some examples.

“These people are not on the fringes. They are in the mainstream,” said Barber. “At the Society of Biblical Literature gathering in Atlanta last year, Eerdmans Books sold out of all of Wright’s book before the three-day conference was over.”

“In The Resurrection of the Son of God, Wright argues that the bodily resurrection of Jesus is the best historical explanation for what happened, given the evidence,” said Pitre. “Whenever others posit alternative scenarios, such as that the body was stolen or that people only saw his spirit, you have to discount all kinds of evidence from the Gospel. Those alternatives lack evidence to back them up.”

Skeptics discount the resurrection, said Catholic apologist Dave Armstrong, because no one saw the event itself. Yet, Armstrong pointed out, “not many people witness murders, either, but we manage to scrounge up enough evidence to punish murderers. Nobody witnessed the Big Bang or the whole process of macroevolution, but atheists and agnostics have no trouble believing in those things.”

Finally, all of the scholars agreed that Christ’s resurrection ran counter to Jewish monotheism. Therefore, they wonder, how else can you account for the rise of Christianity aside from the resurrection?

“Look at all the data from the Gospels and the eyewitnesses, and there is no other way to account for the rise of Christianity than the rising of Jesus from the tomb on the third day,” said Barber. “There’s no other way to make sense of the data we have.”

No matter what evidence we have, noted Barber, we’ll always come up short.

“The resurrection is a mystery. We can’t demonstrate the mysteries of faith empirically. We don’t know all the details, we just know the tomb was empty,” said Barber. “The mysteries go beyond reason.”

Tim Drake writes from St. Joseph, Minnesota.
April 8-14, 2007 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Published by: Daniel Largy
Date: 2009-01-01 10:00:00
Thank you, for the excellant article about the validity of the resurrection of Jesus.Would any Biblical Scholar like to refute the mis-information found in the book titled " Hidden Contradictions in the Bible?

Published by: Daniel Largy
Date: 2009-01-01 10:00:00
Thank you, for the excellant article about the validity of the resurrection of Jesus.Would any Biblical Scholar like to refute the mis-information found in the book titled " Hidden Contradictions in the Bible?

Published by: Daniel Largy
Date: 2009-01-01 10:00:00
Thank you, for the excellant article about the validity of the resurrection of Jesus.Would any Biblical Scholar like to refute the mis-information found in the book titled " Hidden Contradictions in the Bible?

Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular