order viagra international ships how long for bactrim to work chizeaphockey.com clozaril standard nursing care plan estradiol valerate injection 200 mg price misoprostol bleeding 3 weeks atarax project 46 can i buy night naproxen over the counter antidote for levaquin extravasation sichtwandel.ch plavix na recept schwanderins.com cyproheptadine 4 mg cats side effects cost of generic combination of flomax and avodart orkiestra.zen.indelso.pl duromine and metformin fertility success apakaz.org obat dexamethasone 05 does prazosin get you high cytotec seguro social costa rica lineofoslo.no nasminc.com 250 mg metronidazole buy online can gabapentin tablet be used with diclofenac tablet prnc.tv drug generic generic viagra can flagyl and voltaren suppositories be used together buy flagyl cream khasiat tetracycline hcl como usar cytotec con 4 semanas de embarazo seenonstage.pl dapoxetine hydrochloride for sale belly fat and ms gabapentin mifepristone and misoprostol trade name in bangladesh ryman.pl sildenafil citrate tablets vegah extra 120 prozac and zoloft dosage equivalency can you give azithromycin with zantac contoh gambar obat cytotec asli can you take flagyl for upper respiratory infection buy 30mg roche roaccutane online where can i get xenical capsule to buy in ghana micardis hct 12.5 mg huntofalifetime.org cytotec 4 months furosemide diuspec for pregnant does my cialis voucher void prescription doxycycline hyclate capsule 175 mg difference between revatio and vaigra what mg zoloft is compatable to lexapro 20mg levitra cheap to buy lipitor 40 mg pakistan price chrisandradeforcongress.com what helps levitra work better bactrim class action cytotec dosis para aborto peru medicine doxepin hydrochloride capsules ip thesoundalarm.com can you get high off phenergan is arrow meloxicam safe to use during pregnancy lactose dans diovan chamber.md viagra online fedex topix cytotec in u.a.e. brownhousephoto.com gabapentin 100mg dosage lemurialifecoaching.com cardura doxazosinum xl 4 mg how soon after one dose of diflucan can i take second siwe.be misoprostol quero comprar do you need a doctors prescription for cialis in canada is rizatriptan discontinued narrative.in 37.5 zoloft when does propecia go off patent ciprofloxacin 500 mg prospect clomiphene vs clomid for men can i take augmentin 500 mg while pregnant glucophage 850 mg.100 film tb phenergan promethazine hcl in pakistan buy nortriptyline 10mg uk theweddingdolls.co.uk tamsulosin hydro o4mg cap gratisdiscotecas.com lexapro 2 weeks where can i buy cytotec in malaysia can 7.5mg mirtazapine cause nasal congestion accutane clear after a week apa manfaat obat ciprofloxacin 500 m sertraline hcl 50 mg how does make you feel prednisone 6 day pack 5 mg how to take it california-employment-lawyers.com amoxil 500 mg can. it cause a miscarriage misoprostol sin receta enbusa adderal and baclofen and celxa how long do side effects of buspar last jwalkny.com fehmierduran.com amaryl flex 500mg what s d dose fr amoxicillin for gingival abscess topamax and diabetes metronidazole with pud a45 antibiotics wat r some of the illness it cures serophene 3. zyklustag lanoxin vien nen 025 mg where to buy erythromycin cream in philippines baby exposed to two weeks of accutane mobilestoreoperators.com sildenafil price in india diflucan 150 gms planificationprojets.com is quetiapine an ssri zmax antibiotic price in bangladesh elavil sore throat 50 mg why no grapefruit juice with synthroid doxycycline 75 mg acne blakesgourmet.com thearcofnovatrust.com plavix contraindications is old viagra still effective after orgasim do you stay hard with levitra price lexapro prescription why take flomax at bedtime does neurontin help cyclothymia meth gabapentin mifepristone and misoprostol buy online 1.esomeprazole 40mg. tab manufacturer in india compound ketoconazole untuk voltaren retard pomada faz mal quem amamenta difference between augmentin 625 and augmentin 625 duo price of thyroxine tablet in pk schwanderinsurance.com harga voltaren tablet coumadin and pickled beets metronidazole cures oral thrush does lisinopril change menstral flow where can i buy atenolol online azithromycin and clindamycin used together amlodipine 30 mg zoloft vs cipralex side effects cytotec dan mefirex can you get azithromycin for fish tbr.pl theburgeradventure.com can you get hyperstimulation on clomid zofran pregnancy category australia clomid dosage men sildenafil australia paypal accutane and blackheads horners.org.uk proper dose of prednisone for dogs clomid 50mg success rate with endometriosis brownhousephoto.com daisylcreations.com fungsi tetracycline uptodate metformin for pcos km-kh.com can acos antibiotic be substitute by fimoxyl when taking buspar will you lose weight adalat gits 60 mg levitra generic australia metronidazole to treat vaginal boil diovan valsartan 80 mg lemurialifecoaching.com metformin 500mg er tab teva ketoconazole cream scrotum accutane no birth control what to do if 5 mg daily cialis does not work lexapro alcohol paresthesia olmesartan 160 mg accidentally gave double dose of prednisone thisisjacobriddle.com amoxicillin plus in veterinary maxalt 500 sublingual doxycycline for dogs and vomiting strattera off label dosing nomyc fluconazole 150 mg mirtazapine 7.5 depression lisinopril and aspirin together denimandlace.ca citalopram hydrobromide 20 mg high buy lasix drug prozac yan etkileri terbinafine pills no prescription does plavix cause stomach problems gabapentin actavis uk reviews bentuk obat azithromycin ciprofloxacin after vasectomy wordsalamode.com biotech ciprofolixin accidentally took amlodipine walterbruck.de can you take fluconazole and levitra together can misoprostol be bought over the counter in cork para que sirve midol l d 250mg naproxeno sodico cual es la alergia terbinafine hcl 250 mg buspirone for cats for sale propecia 8 years aturan pakai acyclovir syrup adalah anastrozole 1mg side effects sertraline 25 mg is it enough bayrakogullari.com ub.edu.pl viagra pay with paypal lamisil cream vs lotrimin metronidazole pills for cysts how do i beat nausea when taking amoxicillin trihydrate is bloating a symptom of taking metronidazole how much water do i mix with 500mg amoxicillin am1320.com cheap cialis cost advantagegolfcars.com denimandlace.ca boredstop.com does norvasc cause cough meccanicanova.com conjugated linoleic acid buy online ikoa-f.com can glucophage xr be taken in mornings why is famciclovir so expensive diflucan raskauden aikana 93 3109 amoxicillin dosage irbesartan 75 cytotec 200g conto seria la dosis para abortar de misoprostol lexapro and cymbalta taken together pandahomecare.com gratisdiscotecas.com un cytotec de 400 mg puede hacer un aborto irbesartan bitter google ro levitra xenical 84 tablet fiyat how do i insert flagyl gel allergic reaction metronidazole 500mg oeufspolis.com ketoconazole shampoo pharmacokinetics in the elderly nortriptyline 20 mg albuterol nebulizer 2 year old webworksandgraphics.com augmentin fara reteta in uk anti biotics ciprogen 500mg plavix 10 mg thuoc lamisil cream 5g metronidazole buy canada escitalopram recreationally is off patent viagra available in uk syrup flagyl paediatric dosing cheap plavix to buy tablet atarax 25 montelukast sodium bp monograph discount coupons for montelukast 10 mg bdxmen.com escitalopram oxalate available in pakistan where to buy atarax in singapore caprofloxacin ciprodac 250 weingutkohl.de floraphotographs.com how much does fluoxetine cost can clomid give you amenorrhea thuoc doxycycline 200mg per qka perdoret augmentin diflucan dosage for systemic yeast infection farizol metronidazole 500 mg obat untuk apa amoxicillin trihydrate 500mg for chlamydia clomid treatment but no period singulair 10mg montelukast singulair 5 mg pret compensat bellesthailand.com bethubsportsblog.com will valacyclovir hcl show up in a drug screen tips for taking 1g azithromycin kamagra 100mg reputable site bigdaddyssigns.com levofloxacin obat que efectos secundarios de amlodipine besylate 10mg tab revue-pto.com taking non prescribed amoxicillin terbinafine hcl 250 mg price lexapro buy line lisinopril react with carvedilol rf5.org anaheimangelsjersey.com azithromycin 1gm pak powder uses duloxetine available australia course of diflucan 150 mg metoprololsucc red 23.75 bemylight.org diovan hct price cvs sinequan 3mg daisylcreations.com can you take cialis while on testosterone harga nizoral ketoconazole zovirax buy cheap para q sirve cytotec pastilla y consecuencias levitra 20 mg side effects doxycycline price in ksa cobre2013.cl shampoos that tingle nexium virtualsem.com neurontin 300 mg effects fever pcos clomid redzigaismu.lv citalopram 20 mg side effects. back pain relief weaning of lexapro and dealing with nausea cobre2013.cl hhpz.org can allegra 180 mg be cut viagra ranbaxy malaysia does voltaren 75 mg help with opiate withdrawals nizoral price walmart how long does levofloxacin stay in the body can you buy zithromax for chlamydia over the counter gkris.com quetiapine 50 mg tablets side effects does proventil have steriod in it cheap kamagra polo lifebychristian.com sevban.com how much is medroxyprogesterone in shillings csn u take ambien with flomax can green tea help with weight while taking remeron andrzejbieda.com 555fs.com taking wellbutrin and concerta together balding buy propecia paypal twospy.com wellbutrin 600 mg a day how long does erection last with viagra waterfrontalehouse.com thecottonfilm.com termitepestsolutions.com who manufacturers micardis in india gabapentin 100mg seenonstage.pl buildingsonfire.com pct with nolvadex clomid and hcg 14 weeks on 20mg accutane tinea versicolor lamisil cuantas cytotec debo tomar a los 5 meses de embarazo isoptin nedir can i take phenergan after i took keflex antibiotic ciprofloxacin 250 good for insects bites aturan minum fluconazole prednisone 10mg pack 21 direction albuterol for .083 no prescription beton-sapustasi.com pharmacy johor bahru viagra tricyclic antidepressants price dischem aatif.lu webafest.com.au clomid timing and twins fluoxetine 20 mg y 40 mg que diferiencia hay synthesis of montelukast side effects of wellbutrin headrush does generic rizatriptan come in dissolvable tablet client.ilmatic.pl kikkaskitchen.com can you smoke cigarettes while on celexa how effective is lamisil pills desogestrel 75 cura acne acyclovir 200 mg dosage topiramate cost walmart can i cut my cipro dose from 500 to 250 arroyograndecc.com precio captopril 25 mg acyclovir 400 mg treatment for cold sores km-kh.com norvasc 5mg price south africans does xenical really work myofascial pain and gabapentin stop micardis doxycycline 200 mg per day acne levothyroxine sodium 100 mg zithromax 100 mg sachet propranolol sa 60 mg for anxiety flagyl suspension taken with buscopan mobic 30 mg per day can you inject indocin 100mg suppositories naproxen 440 mg can bactrim make you gain weight clomipramine urdu how long can prednisone side effects last on 6 day dose nfhrindia.org manfaat metformin hcl untuk program hamil cialis masturbation calendarfly.com can you get high on gabapentin 50 mg aml.ca montelukast price in india flagyl 500 mg ne ise yarar uk viagra london brand viagra prices tadalafil oral film azithromycin 1 g online do boots in dublin sell viagra levitra online usa augmentin 400 dosage for tonsillitis for toddlers mecanismo de accion de premarin clubdeayudaauditiva.com wilbraham.com can i buy metronidazole 500 mg at walmart dose valtrex fever blister female viagra available in indore naproxeno 250 mg what is it for ringworm returned after diflucan chocolat vs viagra lisinopril 10 mg price how often ahould u take 20mg cialis iaspm2013.espora.es interaction of doxycycline with ciprotab tn punkfiction.com mhc-s.com has anyone erer taken cialis and viagra at the sametime dangers of taking too much cialis when drink clomid do you ovulate same day can you take losartan with hydrochlorothiazide dctourguideonline.com moms who got pregnant with clomid 50 in s a levitra 100 mg ivermectin sale wellbutrin happy pill generic sinequan preatoni.ae ncsdsample2.docbro.com can you start with 2.5 mg lexapro and slowly increase celibar.pl does dapoxetine work obat telinga chloramphenicol vibrancetech.net venta de misoprostol en farmacas de merida yucatan hansrajcollege.info poison ivy prednisone 5 day taper dosage gabapentin recreational use erowid cheap cialis sale apa ciprofloaxin can ondansetron odt work as an antacid warfarin 5 mg tab zyd fluoxetine day 9 seroquel price vs tramadol prices levothyroxine 88 mg purchase veofinancial.com doxycycline cost per dose in philippines 1001.org effects of quetiapine sandoz with pristiq mitsuifinearts.com how long does gabapentin take to work how much is ciprotab sold in nigeria premarin nasal drops and fertility can u buy cialis pills over the counter in germany launchpoker.com fungsi diflucan fluconazole 150mg buy propranolol online no prescription uk what,happens when you take 1200 mg of neurontin bisenconsulting.com dexamethasone athlete fluconazole for infants green poop horners.org.uk webbrowsers.lv liceoagnoletti.it iranstrick-tiregroup.com cuanto sale el misoprostol en farmacias san pablo wellbutrin no prescription bactrim 1 amp lexapro price without insurance viagra purchase prescription cost for propecia at costco happyknits.com bengbeng.de can premarin be crushed street value for remeron phenergan compatibility wpodrozy.eu prednisone 20 mg for humans huntofalifetime.org buspirone hcl 5mg causing irritability viagra discount overnight bigdaddyssigns.com wedlok.com artcontact.ge para que acyclovir ointment hasiat ketoconazole dctourguideonline.com order levaquin online no prescription how hard an erection with cialis nifedipine causing weight gain drug addicts on pain meds and zofran get more high buy nolvadex as pct seenonstage.pl buy viagra for cheap xenical 1 month no effect el benicar produce disfuncion erectil does quetiapine make hydrocodone stay in the urine metformin without food side effects nolvadex 50mg berenboom.com carpetandfloors.co.uk shop and compare charles linskaill viagra buy nexium online cheap metoprolol tartrate.for what a medicine

California Reviews Prop. 8

Marriage proponents expect good news after court hearing.
by Sue Ellin Browder | Source: NCRegister.com

SAN FRANCISCO — Same-sex “marriage” has been on a seesaw in California. First, voters voted to protect the definition of marriage. Then, the state Supreme Court redefined marriage to include same-sex couples. Next, in Proposition 8, voters reestablished marriage’s traditional definition. The pro-marriage amendment passed last fall.

In a hearing here March 5, California Supreme Court justices seemed strongly inclined to uphold Proposition 8.

But the justices also seemed reluctant to nullify the 18,000 or so same-sex “marriages” that took place between May (when the court ruled same-sex couples could “marry”) and November (when voters passed Prop. 8).

Kenneth Starr, dean of the Pepperdine University School of Law in Malibu and Whitewater prosecutor, represented ProtectMarriage.com, the coalition that sponsored the initiative. During the three-hour hearing, he argued the amendment was legally approved by the majority of voters and it would be a miscarriage of justice for the court to overturn the results of a fair election.

The California Catholic Conference is a member of the ProtectMarriage.com coalition.

Also arguing at the hearing were lawyers for two groups of same-sex couples challenging the initiative for the city of San Francisco and for California Attorney General Jerry Brown. They maintained that Proposition 8 is not a constitutional amendment but instead an improper revision that fundamentally alters the structure of government by depriving a minority of access to a right.

Attorney Shannon Minter of the National Center for Lesbian Rights argued in court that marriage is a “fundamental right.” He said denying same-sex couples the right to marry puts them “in a second-class status” and “marks them as second-class citizens.”

Proposition 8, approved by more than 52% of voters, restored the 14-word definition of marriage that the Supreme Court had ruled unconstitutional in a 4-3 decision last May: “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.”

Starr said the principle at stake is not the wisdom of the voters’ decision to amend the state Constitution to limit marriage to a man and a woman but whether the Constitution gives the electorate the power to vote such a definition into law.

He argued that there have been no cases that have come before the court to question that right and that the seven justices weighing Proposition 8 must not deviate.

“We’re asking you to stay the course and not chart a new course,” said Starr.

But questions raised by the bench strongly suggested the justices saw the key question in this case to be whether or not the people of California have a right to change their own constitution.

The court will render a decision within 90 days of the hearing.

Two justices who were part of a 4-3 majority in last year’s ruling giving homosexuals the civil right to “marry” — Chief Justice Ronald George and Justice Joyce Kennard — both made strong statements indicating the people of California have a right to change their own constitution, whether the court likes what they do or not.

George said California’s Constitution has been amended more than 500 times and asked, “Isn’t that the system we have to live with” until or unless it’s changed?

He pointed to a case in which the state Supreme Court threw out the death penalty and the people of California overrode the court to reinstate it.

Kennard said that in her view this case involved “a very different issue” from the one in May and made it clear she was not ready to “willy-nilly disregard the will of the people.”

Several justices pointed out that allowing Prop. 8 to stand does nothing to take away the “panoply” or “bundle” of legal rights same-sex couples enjoy in California.

Arguing on behalf of Attorney General Jerry Brown that Prop. 8 should be overturned, Deputy State Attorney General Christopher Krueger said the majority does not have “unbridled power” to take away an “inalienable right” from the minority. He called the Prop. 8 amendment “draconian.”

But Kennard asked Krueger, “What about the inalienable right of the people to amend the Constitution as the people see fit?”

Arguments presented on behalf of Brown’s office, strongly based on cases dating back to the mid-1800s, were referred to by the court as “very novel” and even “quaint.”

Interim ‘Marriages’

What to do about the 18,000 interim “marriages” was another question in the case. Carol Hogan, a spokeswoman for the California Catholic Conference, the bishops’ office of public policy in Sacramento, who attended the hearings, called them “problematic, because it creates two classes of people.” She said letting those unions stand leaves “a tension in the law that at some point will come back to them. You can’t have two classes of people.”

Charles LiMandri, Thomas More Law Center’s West Coast director, predicted the 18,000 unions, if left intact, won’t have “a significant impact on the culture,” at least not in California.

Estimating that one-third of those “marriages” involved couples from other states that don’t recognize their licenses and observing that same-sex relationships “tend to last just a couple years,” LiMandri said, “You’re going to have probably on the order of about 5,000 of those ‘marriages’ left five years from now. In a state the size of California — 36 million or so — that’s not going to have much of an impact.”

As for the outcome of the case, Joe Infranco, an Alliance Defense Fund lawyer working on the Prop. 8 issue, said his group is “confident the justices are going to recognize the democratic process and do the right thing.”

William Duncan, attorney with the Marriage Law Foundation in Lehi, Utah, concurred. “I’m optimistic the court will rule in favor of Prop. 8 and step away from the brink of saying that the judges themselves are the ones who have the final say on this issue.”

Elizabeth Gill, staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California, believed the right thing would be for the court to strike down Prop. 8. “The court has a solemn responsibility to enforce our state Constitution and to protect the rights of all people, regardless of popular opinion,” Gill said.

But Carol Hogan said the hearing “went very well for our side.”

The law is clearly on our side,” she said. “So we’re cautiously optimistic.”

Considering the justices’ statements in court, LiMandri said, “I think we won.”

If Prop. 8 stands, same-sex “marriage” activists “will now focus on New England,” LiMandri predicted. “But without a major state like California, this will knock them back on their agenda, if not for a generation, at least a decade.”

Catholic News Service contributed to this article. Sue Ellin Browder writes from Willits, California.
March 22-28, 2009 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular