generic clomipramine for dogs efectos misoprostol aborto buspirone hcl 5 mg tab misoprostol embarazo temprano maksud fluconazole para que sirve la pastilla premarin glucophage 850 mg zayiflatirmi how many flagyl must i take daily antibiotics for swollen gums generic names amoxicillin and birth control clomiphene para sale embara venta de viagra en almeria gabapentin 600 mg for nerve pain bactrim in nasal side effects amoxicillin 500mg for pregnancy women topamax wellbutrin and marijuana amlodipin vs viagra para que sirce el ciprofloxacino how much is valtrex in south africa schizophrenia forum zyprexa disulfiram howdotofound canada do viagra soft tabs work generic lexapro at walmart does mobic affect mood service client mobicarte orange tel pre?o valtrex 500 cytotec induction protocol clomid wann eisprung proscar gebruik cuantos mg tiene un misoprostol en argentina patent expiration dates for lipitor is 10mg prednisone 3times a day is good for acute gout menikini allegra 500 c reviews cheap online viagra canada ampicillin sulbactam 3g topamax dosage size premarin side effects australia el viagra sirve para mujeres telmisartan ukpar celexa wellbutrin neurontin amoxicillin impurity standard bp lichen planus can it be cured with metronidazole cabergoline gewichtstoename flagyl 400 bd gabapentin 1 2 viagra generic free amitriptyline while breastfeeding hydroxyzine 25 mg pill levothyroxine 0.025 mg tab long term use of lexapro tablete singulair how much is the cost baclofen drug card dostinex e peso lexapro buy cheap 60 mg prednisone side effects thomas hale zoloft bars in viagra triangle chicago furosemide 40mg tablet should it be taken with warfarin where can i get amoxicillin uk rizatriptan 20 mg furosemide in infusione continua plavix indocin sr 75 mg capsule neurontin gebrauchsinformation diltiazem 45 mg where can i purchase cialis in cape town levothyroxine and heat intolerance valtrex online pharmacy no prescription quand commencer le clomid what is doxycycline used for in dogs cialis yong gong chemical formula of prednisone buy mirtazapine for dogs what is prometrium 100mg used for viagra for men over 80 will taking doxepin show up in iron test when to take a pregnancy test on clomid how to tell if tamoxifen is fake color nizoral shampoo scalp fluid escitalopram get you high manfaat obat danocrine 200 metronidazole and doxycycline wl affect a contraceptive tadacip oder tadalis celecoxib 400 mg para abortar buy lisinopril online decadron dose pack dosage6 day does olanzapine keep you calm what should progesterone levels be on day 21 on clomid can abilify be used recreationally glucophage 500 xr cena does 5 mg cialis on demand work benicar hct 20 12.5 mg para que sirve how long for olanzapine odt to kick in que es ciprofloxacino normon 500 allergic to keflex alternative glucophage and fertmomid missed a period with paxil withdrawal singulair reactii adverse lasix injection is used to treat what when did abilify go generic xenical orlistat price philippines in mercury drug valtrex suppressive therapy side effects luvox seroquel ocd can women take mens viagra lamisil cream for sale nizoral glabrata propecia e alopecia areata generic version of singulair amitriptyline price increase patent information on tadalafil flexeril and cymbalta drug interaction who is a candidate for viagra how long does the zombie effect from lexapro last flagyl injection price shot of prednisone side effects buy lamisil tablets side effects australia price on 5mg cialis harga cytotec di singapura para que sirve olanzapine tablets is my levothyroxine doage too low propecia after 2 years fluconazole tablet ip 150 mg use doxycycline action trade and generic name nexium aciphex better precio de viagra en farmacias sin receta does viagra make you keep your erection last longer zithromax and levora decrease effectiveness adalat cr mims next day air levitra can you take excedrin with ciprofloxacin hydrochloride cheap alternative to augmentin can you buy lamisil cream over the counter in ontario wellbutrin as a street drug how long does diflucan work for o que e exame de estradiol viagra del doctor simi order ampicillin baownbeuv does flagyl act as morning after pill does flagyl make birth control less effective diet pill rapid slim sx normal thyroxine level newborn metformin no prescription strattera 80 mg not working on me lexapro side effect increased anxiety el ventolin altera a los ni?os clomid to increase progesterone estrace 0 5 nifedipine epilepsy bactrim 200 40 ne i?§in kullan?±l?±r iipara que sirve el. atorvastatin cost of tab. augmentin 375 can six month old get albuterol breathing treatments ciprodex generic alternative trazodone 25 mg withdrawal levofloxacin ppt cialis tablets cost cialis brand cheap xenical in caada how does zetaclear compare to terbinafine accutane wearing makeup cold sore acyclovir pills voltaren retard can it treat shingle tadalafil taken by a normal person nsg responsiblities for buspirone injection levothyroxine aching joints does tetracycline come in liquid form levofloxacin urinary infection rui raloxifene stomach pain stayhard viagra ventolin euro buspar safe with melatonin prednisone dose 60 lb dog can an overdoseof lisinopril10mg kill you kaufen levitra online fluconazole dosage for dogs 150 mg safe levothyroxine cause high blood pressure telmisartan chlorthalidone 40 mg tablet prednisone side effects scalp coupon reponse mobicarte orange face still oily on accutane azithromycin doses pediatric girl fucked by viagra man terbinafine online no prescription does cipro cause female to urinate when using cialis can you hold off on premature warning window buy viagra now glucophage side effects gout allegra 80 mg bula propecia online in australia doxycycline 100 mg antibiotics anafranil 75 mg bagimlilik yaparmi mylan verapamil sr 240 mg 25mg sertraline chest pain do i need prescription for terbinafine tablets antianginal effect of metoprolol buy clomid use klonopin and concerta celexa interactions cymbalta emicrania does levitra make you cum harder austell amoxicillin 500 treating yeast infections can i take fluconazole in the morning cipro 500 mg dosage instructions premarin side effects weight loss para q sirve el viagra yahoo dosificacion bupropion terbinafine riv how long after taking cialis 10 mg does it take to work atomoxetine buy online cost of decadron eyedrops in rsa xenical 120 mg safe citalopram lexapro in liver cirrhosis kamagra oral jelly milano apa kegunaan obat orlistat 120 mg ivermectin 1 10 ml bactrim ds cellulitis dose accidental double dose glimepiride dapoxetine viagra purchase is it okat to cut raloxifene hcl 60 mg tablet in half can i take imodium and amoxicillin together buspar hcl 7.5 recreational use where can i buy dapoxetine hydrochloride metronidazole 500mg iv drug comp. that makes tamsulosin beckman coulter allegra x 15r centrifuge achat de cialis generique mail order doxycycline hyclate no insurance hilft metformin 1000 abnehmen cialis generic buy cheap doxycycline tablets for sale lamisil 1 una aplicacion a dose of flagyl tablets typhoid takes how many days coming off seroquel side effects buy arimidex will 2g of zithromax treat chlamydia clomid and zoloft together erythromycin estate use in pregnancy erythromycin tablets 500mg box price in pak nexium cpr 40 mg clomid length of luteal phase is cialis 20mg safe for high blood pressure patients price of provera in mercury drug where to buy in calgary viagra valacyclovir 1 gm how long with it take to heal zovirax crema 10 g metformin 850 mg preisvergleich atarax 25 mg tablet nedir zovirax drogist baclofen pill tv 4096 is its also consider a flexeril forgot to take lexapro side effects zofran odt generic name que funcion tiene la viagra de cuantas semanas se puede tomar cytotec allopurinol generique equivalent can i use diflucn when taking neurontin for lyme finasteride new study levaquin cause lupus accutane diagram staph aureus sensitive to erythromycin what happens if u take two celexa can you take levofloxacin and amoxicillin together taking finasteride with levitra what are the contraindications of lasix how much cialis should one take water retention ciprofloxacin prednisone 20mg tablets for ear infection doxycycline side effects rapid heart beat accutane 20 mg price in pakistan buspar 45 valtrex bula pdf meloxicam cat oral acyclovir dosage in meningitis dr fred levin chicago baclofen amoxicillin 1 gram how much is amoxicillin liquid in canada walgreen diflucan one wellbutrin sr 200mg information does ofloxacin treat swimmers ear aldactone en dermatologia generic fosamax cipro magnesium oil herpes treatment acyclovir price doxycycline philippines doxycycline 500mg dosage urinary tract topamax common cold cuabtas pastas de cytotec hay q tomar con cuatro meses septra and bactrim are the same clomid and tilted uterus how much do ondansetron odt 4 mg value micardis plus 80 12.5mg foglio illustrativo clinical pharmacology of fluconazole cialis mit paypal einzahlen arimidex 1 mg every other day prednisone step down pack after kidney transplant no prescription order viagra online is it safe to take amlodipine besylate and labetalol gabapentin for irritable bowel syndrome whats the street price of elavil will cialis give y o u a bloody nose off label uses for gabapentin dosis levofloxacin untuk gonore prednisone over the counter mexico does amitriptyline cause diabetes augmentin 375 mg cause raised temperature side effects kan man k?pa viagra receptfritt p? apoteket can i drink alcohol with buspirone nizoral for body discoloration cvs and walgreens viagra prices azithromycin tablets rx list phenergan bowel obstruction amoxicillin 500mg ok for 11 year old viagra sale mastercard cara memakan cytotec how does clomid tablet or box look like is 2 tabs of 5 mg lisinopril same as 10 mg cialis can an ohio pa prescribe virus viagra mac raloxifene teva acquista rosacea en doxycycline azithromycin bad for pregnancy atorvastatin 20 mg tablet price 7.5 mg prednisone in dogs glimepiride 37 46 if i have appendicitis will ondansetron make it worse wellbutrin and mylan bupropion xl are they the same amitriptyline and type 1 diabetes strattera lightheadedness a most invigorating draught huffpostenalapril vs lisinopril mix nitroglycerin and hydrocortisone cream inderal and vertigo can flagyl be used to wash sperm lyrica to neurontin beneficios de tomar xenical can i take allegra d before bed lamictal celexa combination how much is zovirax without insurance at walmart viagra vertigini cialis tablets cost cost of cialis versus viagra ventolin hfa free trial azithromycin otc how much does azithromycin 250 mg 6 tabs cost at target how fast can you push zofran antibiotic levofloxacin overuse fluconazole dosage for intestinal candida metronidazole disulfiram reaction buy 12mg ivermectin tablets cytotec at 5 weeks nexium online drugstore will medco pay for finasteride phenergan codeine syrup online bupropion hcl xl memory loss misoprostol abortion can i take dolac ketorolaco how much celexa does it take to kill you doxycycline hyclate 100mg capsules price increase what can i expect if i take propecia viagra alclimax oxycodone celebrex rash from isotretinoin membedakan obat cialis asli dengan palsu sildenafil almaximo fuck viagra girls best viagra tablets name phenergan suppository buy australia cytotec compra bogota does clonidine show on a drug test hormona estradiol e2 lipitor sore back generic viagra 20 mg two forms of.metoprolol can micardis plus cause post nasal drip lasix windel avodart generic price metronidazole can you snort it

Easter Evidence

Scholars Now Tend to Believe the Resurrection
by TIM DRAKE | Source:
SAN DIEGO — If the so-called “Jesus Family Tomb” proves anything, it’s that efforts to discount the resurrection continue. It’s a mystery that remains a stumbling block for many.

Last month, the Discovery Channel aired James Cameron’s documentary on the “Jesus Family Tomb,” claiming the discovery of a tomb with ossuaries bearing the names of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, and “Judah son of Jesus.”

Scholars and archaeologists disproved Cameron’s findings, saying that the text on the Mary Magdalene ossuary actually read “Mary and Martha,” and that the tomb was more than likely the tomb of St. Paul’s friend, another Jesus, who was also known as Justus, son of Joseph. Following the revelation, Discovery pulled its planned repeat of the program.

Yet, according to several Catholic theologians and apologists, there’s a new trend in Scripture scholarship. That trend is away from the skepticism and suspicion of the past four decades toward an acceptance of the Gospels and toward the fact that Christ’s resurrection is the only explanation that makes sense.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that “the mystery of Christ’s resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified, as the New Testament bears witness” (CCC 639).

Pope Benedict XVI has said as much.

“I trust the Gospels,” he wrote in the introduction to his forthcoming book on Christ, Jesus of Nazareth: From the Baptism in the Jordan to the Transfiguration.

“Being a Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event,” he said in his first encyclical letter, Deus Caritas Est (God Is Love).

Protestants often turn to other sources for proof. The popular Evangelical speaker and author Josh McDowell writes about the significance of the moved stone and the grave clothes.

That’s natural, says Steve Ray, an Evangelical convert to the Catholic faith.

“In the Catholic world, we trust in the authority of the Church,” he said. “Evangelicals are always looking for facts. If all you have is the book, you’re constantly trying to prove that the book is true. We believe when the Church told us that Christ rose from the dead, the Church is the voice of Christ in the world today, and we can trust it. It’s a whole different methodology because of what we see as our source of authority.”

“What puzzles the world, and its wise philosophers and fanciful pagan poets, about the priests and people of the Catholic Church is that they still behave as if they were messengers,” wrote the British Catholic convert G.K. Chesterton in The Everlasting Man. “A messenger does not dream about what his message might be, or argue about what it probably would be; he delivers it as it is.”

“The Church would never use things like the Shroud of Turin or the gravestone to try to prove the resurrection,” said Michael Barber, professor of theology at John Paul the Great Catholic University in San Diego, Calif. “There is a distinction between public and private revelation. The shroud is not part of the deposit of faith.”

Instead, Catholics rely on the authority of the Church, the Biblical evidence, and tradition that has been passed on.

“The compelling evidence for me is the unanimous testimony of all the apostles and even a former persecutor like St. Paul,” said Brant Pitre, assistant professor of theology at Our Lady of Holy Cross College in New Orleans. “There was no debate in the first century over whether Jesus was resurrected or not.”

Scholars say that the witnesses to Christ’s resurrection are compelling for a variety of reasons.

“People will seldom die even for what they know to be true. Twelve men don’t give up their lives for a lie,” said Ray, who recently returned from France, where he was filming his “Footprints of God” series at the amphitheater in Lyon, the site of a persecution in A.D. 177. “The martyrs of Lyon underwent two days of torture and all they would say is, ‘I am a Christian.’ They knew the resurrection was true and didn’t question it.”

Barber also highlighted the diversity of sources and how they include different details as well as passages that do not paint the disciples in the best light.

“In the Road to Emmaus story, they write that they didn’t recognize him,” said Barber. “Our Biblical accounts are our best evidence.”

Several of the scholars pointed to 1 Corinthians, where Paul states that Christ appeared to 500 people.

“Some want to shy away from the Gospels because they say they were written later,” explained Barber. “If you want to believe that they were written later, then why wouldn’t the Gospels have made use of this piece of evidence from 1 Corinthians?” asked Barber.

Barber also pointed to two non-Christian sources that make reference to Christ. The first is Tacitus. The second is the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, who, noted Barber, actually mentions the resurrection.

“In Antiquities of the Jews, Book 18, Chapter 3, paragraph 3, Josephus references Jesus’ resurrection,” said Barber. “The problem is that most scholars think it’s a later Christian addition to Josephus. We don’t have his original work.”

Recent Scholarship

Belief in resurrection was not completely foreign to Judaism.

“A belief in the resurrection of the dead is a major element of traditional Judaism,” said Jon Levenson, professor of Jewish studies at Harvard. “According to the Mishnah, the first rabbinic law code, belief that God would resurrect the dead is an obligation, not an option, for Jews.”

But, as Barber pointed out, such a belief was only found in one segment of Judaism at the time of Christ.

“The Pharisees believed in resurrection; the Sadducees didn’t,” said Barber. “But along with that belief was that with the resurrection would come the dawning of the restoration of the Davidic kingdom.”
Barber also points to the fact that Christ’s resurrection is not the only resurrection attested to in the Gospels.

He referenced the resurrections of Lazarus and Jairus’ daughter.

And in the Gospel of Matthew (27:52-53), when Jesus dies, “tombs were opened, and the bodies of many saints who had fallen asleep were raised. And coming forth from their tombs after his resurrection, they entered the holy city and appeared to many.”

“The fundamental conviction in a scientific age with our post-enlightenment views is that these things didn’t happen,” said Barber. “People have determined that any source that talks about resurrection is unreliable and rule it out. What kind of science is that? You don’t just dispense with evidence that you don’t like.

“Many scholars are now recognizing that one should not so easily dismiss the reliability of the Gospel of John,” added Barber. “Some have compared the Gospel of John with the Pauline epistles and found numerous points of contact, so it’s very plausible that John’s Gospel may have been written earlier than previously thought by many historical critical scholars.”

Gone are the days where the Jesus Seminar dominated. The Jesus Seminar is a research team of New Testament scholars founded in 1985 by the late Robert Funk and ex-priest John Dominic Crossan to use historical methods to determine what Jesus may or may not have said or done. The seminar’s reconstruction of Jesus portrayed him as a wandering sage who did not found a religion or rise from the dead.

According to Barber, there’s an alignment of scholars in support of the original Gospel texts.

“The dominant strain in mainstream Biblical scholarship is from those who are convinced that the Gospels are indeed reliable,” said Barber. He cited the work of N.T. Wright, Craig Evans, Craig Blomberg and Richard Bauckham as some examples.

“These people are not on the fringes. They are in the mainstream,” said Barber. “At the Society of Biblical Literature gathering in Atlanta last year, Eerdmans Books sold out of all of Wright’s book before the three-day conference was over.”

“In The Resurrection of the Son of God, Wright argues that the bodily resurrection of Jesus is the best historical explanation for what happened, given the evidence,” said Pitre. “Whenever others posit alternative scenarios, such as that the body was stolen or that people only saw his spirit, you have to discount all kinds of evidence from the Gospel. Those alternatives lack evidence to back them up.”

Skeptics discount the resurrection, said Catholic apologist Dave Armstrong, because no one saw the event itself. Yet, Armstrong pointed out, “not many people witness murders, either, but we manage to scrounge up enough evidence to punish murderers. Nobody witnessed the Big Bang or the whole process of macroevolution, but atheists and agnostics have no trouble believing in those things.”

Finally, all of the scholars agreed that Christ’s resurrection ran counter to Jewish monotheism. Therefore, they wonder, how else can you account for the rise of Christianity aside from the resurrection?

“Look at all the data from the Gospels and the eyewitnesses, and there is no other way to account for the rise of Christianity than the rising of Jesus from the tomb on the third day,” said Barber. “There’s no other way to make sense of the data we have.”

No matter what evidence we have, noted Barber, we’ll always come up short.

“The resurrection is a mystery. We can’t demonstrate the mysteries of faith empirically. We don’t know all the details, we just know the tomb was empty,” said Barber. “The mysteries go beyond reason.”

Tim Drake writes from St. Joseph, Minnesota.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular