zoloft dilated pupils rwmeierlaw.com how do you know viagra is working is mobic a cox 2 inhibitor 3.000 meloxicam 15mg cardizem drip titration protocol 4 mic theorientalhotels.com kamagra gel fur frauen forum pungsi obat nizoral accord quetiapine xr 200 mg used for insomnia berenboom.com accutane 20 mg day 5 what is flagyl 400mg side effects accutane 5 months or 6 months how to maintain an erection can you sell baclofen 10 mg whats better for withdrawls gabapentin or orphenadrine erythromycin gel ireland can i take cytomel and wellbutrin buy cipro online no prescription aturan minum glucophage xr harga salap ketoconazole montelukast levocetirizine hydrochloride and fertility daisylcreations.com joining the defence force and lexapro yogaindailylife.org can antidepressants make you bloated where to get viagra coventry doxycycline how much is it in south africa can quetiapine be crushed for a buzz atorvastatin generic for cholesterol can i take clomid after eating apple what is doxycycline hyclate used to treat does fluconazole dosage for leaky gut can i take rizatriptan benzoate after taking ibuprofen safe to take remeron and ketamine together cytotec 20mg co tac dung gi prednisone taper guidelines and withdrawal study escitalopram 5mg viagra price in pakistan faisalabad fexofenadine 180 mg twice daily mirtazapine for anxiety and intrusive thoughts businesscreditpro.com anastrozole 30mg kamagra oral jelly cape town levofloxacina bula hhpz.org tadalafil 60 mg online buy hydrochlorothiazide canada bactrim or amoxicillin no prescription schwanderins.com efecto srcundario de dexamethasone 4 mg tablet dctourguideonline.com coupon for singulair chewable virtualsem.com rantical.com dctourguideonline.com thumbuy.com how fast will metronidazole work for dog newworldfoods.ca difference between prednisone and dexamethasone cost of generic diovan 320 from cigna home delivery how much price of injection amoxicillin of augmentin venlafaxine quetiapine prolactin aleskons.ru how to redusd erection of my hasband sildenafil 1a pharma 50 mg tabletten discount coupon for zyprexa stdennischurch.org cuantas dosis de cytotec para 14 semanas de embarazo so-sc.org onlywebs.us 1001.org lamisil oral how long to start alcohol prednisone for dogs without prescription horners.org.uk can you get high off of naproxen amoxicillin 500 mg exp. date du hw can i collect female viagra tab. in delhi what does ondansetron 4mg orraly dispersible cost efek samping cordarone injeksi viagra 50mg price uk beribak.com hhpz.org atorvastatin calcium patent expiration andrijastepic.renianstudio.com quanto custa o famvir e o valtrex generic cialis soft viagra paano ang pag inom ng cytotec is metoprolol tartrate an ace inhibitor side effects paroxetine 40 mg liver function can i take 5mg cialis evey other day can i take amoxicillin for white spots in tonsils kmmvin.eu paano ang paggamit ng provera curam antibiotics for cats avodart precio mexico can cideine affect levothyroxine gothamistllc.com tadalafil 20 mg mightyrabbitstudios.com how much gabapentin 600 mg to get high stinging sensations from amoxicillin pink tablets groganstudios.com 15 mg dose od prednisone do i get a moon face pediatric dosing of augmentin 600 suspension much does serophene cost buspirone 5 mg engorda cipla co misoprostol tablets bactrim at walmart tac dung cua cua amoxicillin 400 mg can i buy mifeprex and cytotec over the counter how is liquid amoxil supplied 7 days diet pills in mercury drugstore saan sa quiapo makakabili ng cytotec skin yellow on plavix umbraarms.com wellbutrin and topamax alcohol deltasone 20 mg side effects ascbelfast.com doxycycline 100mg tablets too much gabapentin waterfrontalehouse.com shingles valtrex 21 famciclovir com-tur.com redzigaismu.lv zithromax 250 mg how to take cheapest viagra canada webbrowsers.lv cialis 5mg canada can neurontin get you high oratane isotretinoin au biotech ciprofloxacin for uti centergaz.pl while taking levofloxacin 500 sore throat what to do content-catalyst.com kegunaan obat farmoten 25 mg captopril price for plavix for cats lasix 500 mg tabletten is it safe to cut finasteride in half canada viagra prescription 2nd round diflucan prednisone class action lawsuits how much is 800 mg gabapentin on the streets bactrimforte product 283858.com erectile dysfunction pills commercial in india how many mg of prednisone should i take for poison ivy arroyograndecc.com what does metronidazole do after abortion is it okay to cut the pill valtrex in half amoxicillin 500mg capsules mal di gola lamisil cost generic philippines how to make my dog to eat flagyl orlistat pregnancy fungsi ketoconazole cream bactrim costo mexico azithromycin price zmax philippines happyknits.com celexa and muscle spasms ftortho.net difference between seroquel 200 and 300 nasminc.com ondansetron 10 mg deserteichler.com meloxicam para perros costo waterfrontalehouse.com is it safe to use albuterol inhaler with lung cancer 1001.org cyproheptadine 2mg 5ml syrup ce sunt furosemidele how metalazone is better than torsemide getting high from prazosin hcl how to make tadalafil para que sirve el lamisil anti fugal niagarajazzfestival.com how clomid works to get pregnant sertraline guaifenesin interaction amoxicillin mg for testicle pain bactrim forte dosage for gonorrhea can you inject indomethacin 50 mg get high digital escitalopram coupon can u take fluconazole 150mg two days in a row trazodone hcl 150 mg tablet overdose zoloft milligrams for adhd on south beach diet can i lose with taking remeron flagyl sup obat apa ya how is naproxen per pill monikagawor.pl gabapentin for oxycodone withdrawal wordsalamode.com estradiol level 41 wordsalamode.com mylan fluconazole drinking alcohol mistoprosol in kenya without prescription finasteride manufacturers europe dexamethasone sodium phosphate horse treatment plan does great west life cover cialis misoprostol taken without mifepristone golfnewmexico.com doxycycline 30s weingutkohl.de haciendahotel-oldtown.com sevban.com cordarone effets secondaires hypotention voltaren 500mg mobic compatability antihistamine ic citalopram hr fluconazole synthesis glucophage cardiac catheterization businesscreditpro.com can u get high off metoprolol c 75 chatwebromanesc.info mrsa treatment bactrim dialysis firsttimetravels.com nexium hp7 dose will amoxicillin cure abscess in baby tooth on the shelf cytotec whats the difference between prolix and prednisone mightyrabbitstudios.com does cymbalta cause dilated pupils good man exceed viagra and cialis amoxil drip cytotec in bulacan lexapro generic antidepressant buy arimidex canada no prescription can you take penicillin then switch to septra para que es la misoprostol antes del iud louielouie.net price of diltiazem in india citalopram 20 mg high prazosin 5mg generic doxycycline 200 mg side effects propecia vs finasteride seroquel and tramadol taken together how mny days should i give bactrim for staph what is the proper dosage of zyprexa can you get high off cialis phenergan 90ml can doxepin make you gain weight tetracycline hydrochloride staph infect augmentin 600 suspension dosage amoxicillin for 6 months splitting 20 mg dose of celexa glucophage 500 for weight loss njlegdistrict3.com how much is ciprofloxacin in mercury drug taking clomid and viagra effexor vs lexapro yound adults flagyl ampul doses avastan.pl lisinopril side effects peripheral neuropathy is estradiol level 41 low brand name sildenafil generic west bengal zum.no what is clonidine used for hcl 0.1mg stopping avodart serophene gnc ncodingnerd.com fish antibiotics azithromycin how to take clomid 50mg twin pregnancy galantamine hydrobromide 8 mg tab rf5.org client.ilmatic.pl doxycycline hyclate how long does it take to work flagyl 500 mg ne ise yarar what color is liquid doxycycline floryakurye.com.tr buy diltiazem cream kamagra gel vo aptekite vo makedonija salep acyclovir harganya mobilestoreoperators.com furosemide 40mg tab iaspm2013.espora.es generic lexapro in australia olanzapine 2.5 mg half life theorientalhotels.com adipex and buspar hhpz.org warfarin price increase daisylcreations.com is augmentin stronger than amoxicillin waterfrontalehouse.com can you take fluconazole and claritin cytotec pfizer price in indha coparmex.org.mx naltrexone et wellbutrin poids diovan 320 25 mg side effects newworldfoods.ca how much propecia cost nizoral cream 40g arroyograndecc.com atenolol recciones secundarias nolvadex without cycle photoloco.com avvsagradafamilia.net firsttimetravels.com amoxicillin 500mg tooth infection shall i double dose interaction remeron and transdermal estradiol buspar 718 price propecia usa celexa alcohol and high triglycerides 100mg viagra dosage robertjszmidt.pl photoloco.com lexapro canada no prescription flagyl course early period will viagra help 70 year olds amoxicillin 7 days ear infection can valtrex cause bladder infection can remeron decrease nausea of lexapro amoxicillin 1000 mg brown spotting while on flagyl tamsulosin 0.4 mg does it get u stoned can ciprofloxacn be taken with tamoxifen asiliahomehealth.com thebestkindofdifferent.com mirtazapine in kenya azithromycin tablets usp 250 mg for chlamydia am1320.com advantagegolfcars.com augmentin duo 625 tablets refrigerator ywdtx.com theisod.org viagra dhe perdorimi i saj seroquel 300 milligrams celexa dosage anxiety tablets cialis side effects ketoconazole 200 mg side effects singulair de laboratorio msd valacyclovir 1gm staph infection doxepin baclofen valacyclovir 4 times a day is wellbutrin better than zoloft generic plavix india how eggs does 100mg of clomid buy orlistat 120mg uk prolonged qt ciproflox ir azithromycin suitable for acne where can i buy generics of micardis in philippines levaquin lawsuit.colitis can i buy cytotec over the counter in south africa hiw much zoloft for a 13 year old managedent.ca artitself.com what hinders viagra from working best veofinancial.com ciprocort ear drops for infants can i take gabapentin with escitalopram and clonazepam inj septran action waterfrontalehouse.com fosamax side effects uk montelukast oral drops bactrim antibiotic blister pazarlamacadisi.com provera medroxyprogesterone acetate 10mg obat apa will 25mg of elavil aid in sleep furosemide diuretic metronidazole is safe in7th month pregnancy flagyl philippines pruce cytotec citomegalovirus IMAJJI.COM punkfiction.com price lisinopril india price alendronate sodium 70 mg cialis 30 day free trial coupon long ciprofloxacin eye drops side effects last busy-autokary-wynajem.pl can antidepressants cause dermatitis olanzapine withdrawal and constipation ciprofloxacin 7 days peniien xeloda yorumlar strep throat zithromax dosage solucortef conversion to prednisone augmentin syrup online alcohol and metronidazole gel is it safe to masterbate when metronidazole vaginal gel best price on viagra walmart vodoun.org gothamistllc.com coumadin 10 mg 28 tablet kurierbranzowy.eu thepointofcare.com zestril 2.5 mg grandlakehistory.org ikoa-f.com eude.es buy flagyl online cheap edgewaterstudio.com uasa.co.za discount coupon for singulair levites vardenafil hc1 tablets orlistat 90 mg how much dosage of albuterol for a woman difference between azithromycin and roxithromycin.com centros de venta libre de cytotec en nicaragua thepointofcare.com isotretinoin capsules india best company flagyl pill and pregnancy how long do you take prednisone after last chemo celexa and zertec together make you very tired bupropion celexa marijuana active in glucophage kegunaan levaquin how mich is viagra peso animaswellbeing.com cytotec sangrado 2 dias is camber finasteride as good as propecia nizoral cream cost remeron 45 mg for sleep serviciosarcom.com how much is valtrex tricare order sertraline afdoor.com gonorrhea treatment in men zithromax not pregnant prometrium nausea rf5.org theisod.org is levitra safe to take with prednisone how long does 1 gram of azithromycin gonorrhea how to write a prescription for albuterol inhaler dunnacupuncture.com theisod.org prometrium 100mg can you take advil with 100 mg celebrex where can u get misoprostol in pakistan amoxil 500 for dogs side effects clonidine every 4 to 6 hours twospy.com negatives of topamax alergia al ciprofloxacin effects of viagra on eyesite vapril 12 5 captopril how many milligrams of azithromycin to cure chlamydia cardura 2 mg tablet can generic diovan make your thyroid sore what is the diference between anastrozole and tamoxifin nitroglycerin .4 sl martinus-schule-baesweiler.de presyo ng nizoral cream sa mercury drugs in philippines taken broken nexium 20mg tablet sekerpinarosgb.com harsa.se buy montelukast tablets naproxen cost per pill wordsalamode.com cordarone 200 mg side effects in 19 years should take viagra 100g sampiyonhaliyikama.com atarax para bebe de 6 meses can i lose weight on 25 mg of synthroid amoxicillin and amitriptyline side effects zyvox 600 mg patent expiry syptoms of nms lexapro lamicdal que precio tienen las pastillas cytotec en mexicali is it safe to take a vardenafil tablets 20 mg nitroglycerin 2.6 mg best brand name and rate 1001.org levaquin 500 mg dosage sinus infection generic for lexapro canada levofloxacin brand of mankind natural replacement for glucophage gkris.com buy viagra levitra alternative lavitra gambar obat olanzapine clopidogrel zentiva side effects how much are neurontins worth on the street 283858.net theitrecruiters.com arilarotokiralama.com verapamilo 160 mg efectos secundarios tac dung thuoc mobic meloxicam 7.5mg horners.org.uk bactrim outlawed ciprofloxacin and augmentin for throat learninc.org kalmicetine 250 chloramphenicol st johns wort vs lexapro antibiotics for syphilis cipro prednisone causing tummy cramps 10 weeks pregnant ciprodac 250 used for naprosyn 750mg brand name cordarone150 action champions-league-news.com xenical 84 capsules periactin tablet in india is 400 mg of prometrium too much coparmex.org.mx gastroparese and dose erythromycine torsemide 100 mg clindamycin vs metronidazole dental abscess newworldfoods.ca lipitor monitoring parameters content-catalyst.com westwoodhomesinc.com stories1st.org can i take diflucan with adderall trazodone 300 mg high bupropion generic price ir

Gift or Gaffe?

Why Bush Gave Benedict a Walking Stick
DALLAS — A walking stick is the unlikely center of a debate about political protocol, theological precision and news-marketing as a corporal work of mercy.

President Bush gave the odd, carved walking stick to Pope Benedict XVI on June 9 on a visit to Rome. In some quarters, the gift became a laughingstock. 

As a post on one Catholic blog put it, “You go all the way to Rome and you give the Pope a stick! Mr. Bush, has America nothing better to offer?”

But stick supporters point out that the staff, inscribed with the Ten Commandments, was one of several gifts of state the president presented to Pope Benedict that day. And the fact that the president gave it to the Pope may have kept a former homeless man and his wife off the streets and in their rented apartment.

First, the case against the stick.

Detractors point out that not only was the stick homely, but the version of the Decalogue carved into it was the Protestant one. Bush seemed to commit a further faux pas when he forgot to address the Pope with the usual honorific, “Your Holiness,” and used “sir” instead.

The Pope did not seem fazed by the choice of words — or offended that the president did not come bearing something more precious than a cane.

“The Ten Commandments?” he asked curiously. 

“The Ten Commandments, yes, sir,” President Bush responded.

One critic called it “an embarrassing breach of protocol.” 

“Protestants don’t necessarily recognize the Pope as ‘his holiness,’ but George Bush wasn’t there representing himself. He was there representing the United States,” said Frank Flinn, a professor of religious studies and a practicing Catholic at Washington University in St. Louis.

Furthermore, Flinn said, any gift featuring the Ten Commandments should have included the version used by the Pope and most Catholics.

“This gets the president involved in a religious controversy,” he said. “More appropriate would have been a nice copy of the United States Constitution. When the president gets into the business of distributing the Ten Commandments, it raises the question, ‘Which version should he use?’”

But others say the walking stick may be the most thoughtful, heartfelt gift a president has given to a head of state.

“I think this gift is better than what President Lyndon B. Johnson gave to Pope Paul VI, which was a statue of Lyndon B. Johnson,” said Jimmy Akin, head apologist for Catholic Answers, a San Diego-based Catholic apologetics organization.

Akin also said he understands why Bush referred to the Holy Father as “sir,” and he doesn’t think it reflected disrespect.

“As someone who grew up in Texas, I know that it’s drilled into you to call everyone either ‘sir’ or ‘ma’am.’ So even if it’s not proper protocol, it’s the kind of thing that can slip out without thinking about it,” Akin said.
As for the Protestant version of the Decalogue, Akin agreed Bush could have done better.

“It was a nice gift, but it would have been nicer if it were inscribed with the version of the Ten Commandments that the Pope uses,” Akin said. “It doesn’t make the gift offensive, and I’m sure the Holy Father received it in the spirit it was intended — the spirit of good will and an appreciation that the ability of people in impoverished conditions can contribute to society.”

Why a Stick?

The stick was designed and carved by Roosevelt Wilkerson, a man who lived on the streets of Dallas with his wife until a good friend of George and Laura Bush discovered his craft and began helping him sell the carvings, known as Moses Sticks.

Susan Nowlin, of Dallas, was the “big sister” of Laura Bush at a Southern Methodist University sorority. She and her husband, Edwin Nowlin, are frequent guests at the White House, and Nowlin has given Bush two of Wilkerson’s Moses Sticks.

Nowlin met Wilkerson in 1997 at a craft class at her church, First Presbyterian of Dallas, and later decided she wanted to buy one of his sticks. She asked around, and ended up tracking Wilkerson down by shouting his name in a rough area of southeast Dallas.

Nowlin and Wilkerson struck up a friendship, and she agreed to try selling the sticks. They devised a plan in which Wilkerson would carve sticks, Nowlin would sell them for $75 each, and proceeds would help Wilkerson and his wife rent an efficiency apartment and get off the street.

The first stick Nowlin bought was given to her pastor. Subsequently, she gave a stick to then-Gov. Bush because she knew he cared about the homeless and the poor — and the Ten Commandments. Greeting Nowlin for a luncheon at the governor’s mansion, Laura Bush told her that Gov. Bush considered his Moses Stick “the greatest gift ever.”

“Later, President Bush told me: ‘I have to admit, when I first saw it I thought it was a fishing pole,’” Nowlin said.

Homeless to Celebrity

In preparing for the Vatican visit, Bush contacted Nowlin about acquiring a stick so the White House protocol office could review it as a possible gift for Pope Benedict XVI.

Wilkerson and his wife haven’t been homeless for most of the past 10 years because of the Moses Sticks, but Nowlin says it hasn’t been easy. Sometimes, sales have been slow.

“I needed to sell at least seven sticks a month, if they were to stay off the street,” Nowlin said. “When orders were slow, Roosevelt and I would pray. We would just pray and pray and pray and the orders would come in.”
As a result of the president’s gift to the Pope, Nowlin said she and Wilkerson can’t keep up. She has raised the price of the sticks to $100, but says she could probably charge $1,000 or more and still have a backlog of orders.

Nowlin said Wilkerson remains a shy, soft-spoken man who doesn’t want publicity. She said a CNN crew showed up at his apartment recently and confronted him with cameras while his false teeth were out.

“He was very upset, and was in tears over it,” Nowlin said. “He’s a very simple man who has been given a simple purpose in life. People want him to say something about all of this, and he doesn’t know what to say. He doesn’t want to disappoint them.”

Wilkerson and his wife have long melded into the crowd at St. Paul United Methodist Church, the oldest black church in Dallas. When they walked in June 10, the pastor announced from the pulpit that a “celebrity” was in the congregation, telling the story of a Moses Stick carved by Wilkerson making its way to the president and Pope.

“The entire congregation gave them a standing ovation,” Nowlin said.

Nowlin said Wilkerson is honored to have carved a stick for the Pope. However, she said he’s so shy about the publicity that he and his wife have temporarily left their home to stay with friends of the Nowlins.

The New York Museum of Folk Art has inquired about displaying Wilkerson’s work, and Nowlin said people are calling and writing with requests for different versions of the Ten Commandments on a stick.

“One man called this morning and said he needed the Fourth Commandment to say ‘remember the Sabbath’ which is on the stick, but he wanted it to also say ‘and keep it holy.’ I told him there’s no more room on the stick. We are not doing multiple varieties of the Ten Commandments. We just can’t manage that,” Nowlin said.
Akin said Catholics, Jews and Protestants use slightly different Hebrew-to-English translations of the Ten Commandments, but he said none of the differences are substantive. The biggest difference between the Protestant and Catholic versions, Akin said, involves grouping. Catholics combine into the First Commandment what Protestants separate into the First and Second Commandments. Likewise, Protestants combine into the 10th Commandment what Catholics break out into the Ninth and 10th.

“Historically there have been three different schemes, but the Church doesn’t dogmatically favor one over the other,” Akin said. “These differences, and some of the abbreviations that are common, mostly reflect practical considerations.”

Wayne Laugesen is based in Boulder, Colorado.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular