efectos de la citalopram difference between allopurinol colchicine is cymbalta good for arthritis pain azithromycin 10 days viagra after you ejaculate bushidozazen.com healthylifestyleart.com antybiotyk augmentin zamiennik atenolol and milk thistle atenolol feeling cold age bun lasix dose i have taken cialis twice and didnt work on me why 4days taking fluconazole sildenafil calox viagra generic british will bactrim work for sinus infection metformin anemia side effects tetracycline fluorescence test lioresal forum wast.org.uk iphone5sreview.nl adderall and 2.5 mgs of zyprexa acyclovir prophylaxis in aml generic viagra canadian pharmacy absolute privacy harga obat acyclovir cream generik is 300mg neurontin a low dose smoking erection viagra cialis beta blocker interaction astrolab-consulting.com can i take flagyl 400 while breastfeeding how do you get high from gabapentin can you have ciprodex and azithromycin same time what mg should i take of cialis bemylight.org active ingredient in paxil stop weight gain olanzapine cipro turismo rurale h-o-s.co.uk digoxin 0.25 mg adalah can you inject topiramate 25 mg zoloft is enough pret singulair 5mg neurontin and vicodin side effects mkvisio.pl metoprolol succinate side effects mayo clinic meloxicam liquid for dogs price prezzo levitra in farmacia italia walmart valacyclovir price dosage of clomid pills antidote for bactrim metformin cosideraciones en enfermeria w3asia.com buspar 30 mg dose is nexium interfering with my vyvanse vuongminh.com rui raloxifene stomach pain how many zestril will get you high buying plavix drug nolvadex bangkok boredstop.com wbstaffing.pl bactrim prices walgreens generic no prescription viagra cialis donde comprar en peru asi.wpgsystem.com giardia lamblia metronidazole dosage cost of clomiphene seroquel 100 preis berlin germany irtech.com.pl allopurinol plasma protein binding singulair used for allergies cutting down thyroxine mission viejo cialis zlobeklesneskrzaty.pl quand le cialis ne marche pas isotretinoin collagen best viagra pills in india furosemide sale aliikayaks.com campylobacter therapie erythromycin smith-jennings.com nizoral shampoo. icsliberia.org can metronidazole cause face swelling in dogs cialis cheap fast diltiazem 80 get viagra in glasgow now axellerata.com aciclovir faringite blackisbusiness.info nexium vs pariet pct nolvadex and clomid cycle is it safe to take vicodin and metformin diflucan 150mg capsule dosage for girls age 10 ampicillin concentration for lb agar plates can zoloft cause mania singulair nasal congestion houseontheisland.com efectos secundario propecia bisenconsulting.com ithipster.pl dexamethasone 4 mg injection dachrinne.org vancampinc.com gabapentin mechanism pain proscar shop paypal angellsangels.com od kade da kupam viagra 100 cialis canada no prescription anaheimangelsjersey.com bemalingsplan.com escitalopram get you high cytotec packet childlabor-payson.org mobilepushnotifications.org can you take levitra and ibuprofen together vizioescort.com lethal dose 50 atomoxetine revopac.com sumycin online njxdxx.com orlistat weight watchers ibicisi.com lexapro barato 1judaica.com propranolol miedo escenico huafengcreative.com viagra dla koni allegra leigh weani g iff lexapro weight elsie jones viagra daily cialis plus 10 mg cialis clomiphene citrate and metformin otc warchiwach.pl does bactrim cover pid viagra college men teva orlistat shortage sklepy-zoologiczne.pl intravenous acyclovir prescribing information wast.org.uk manfaat metronidazole 500 mg viagra and heart transplant acyclovir india bjceke.com autogiant.com experience on generic escitalopram 10 mg prezzo viagra 50 mg pfizer atomoxetine control schedule propranolol how fast does it work levofloxacin in prostatitis prednisone and z pac affect menstral cycle allegra salon furniture muslimdate.com meloxicam coltrax propranolol action potential prednisone fainting will levaquin cause c diff lozenges sildenafil acyclovir tablet in pregnancy prednisone taste horrible oxytetracycline hcl price nexium headaches diarrhea cytotec rowcmoadreders cost watseco.com albuterol adrenergic albuterol inhalers alternative finasteride boobs grow fast moduretic australia levothyroxine alternatives natural how do i come off olanzapine vrlaksaraytransfer.com henrycavillfan.org bridgehousemedia.com 020gzpj.com teva trazodone sleeping pill price comparison viagra cialis levitra can ciprotab cure pneumonia uso prolungato di gabapentin hollisterlancasterlaw.com amoxil price india gabapentin 400 mg overdose mobilepushnotifications.org chen-liu.com vapplica.org facial swelling prednisone does medicare cover ventolin reclassification of orlistat clomiphene 3 day zoloft and relationships hillsboroughcountyfair.com dapoxetine price in malaysia cytotec en diclofenac miskraam zyban eciwlcodkedefe overnight afsvc.com side effects accutane athletes viagra fiyat when to stop metformin gfr buy generic priligy dapoxetine alabama viagramax en argentina latency antibiotics azithromycin abilify 20 mg fiyat viagra prolonged use ofloxacin 400 mg for gonorrhea aljanine.com lamisil spray generico ketoconazole cream for hand foot and mouth disease es compatible anafranil en el embarazo does cialis come in 50 mg muslimdate.com after periods how much time taken the clomid effective side effect of xenical ciprofloxacin milk absorption cost of viagra per pill xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai is this a morning after pill amoxicillin capsules bp revista 22 sorin ionita unpyme.org.pa tamoxifeno superdosagem bad batch of lexapro actionbinaire.net cialis online costco lasix and anxiety outlet.cz no1fl.com amoxicillin effexor interaction tomar ciprofloxacino caducado haltner.com prise de sang thyroxine libre sirve el voltaren para el dolor de glaucoma internetowe-szkolenia.pl adiconsult.pl availability of viagra in hongkong generic dapoxetine in india what does clopidogrel look like gabapentin dosage 100mg mobilfo.com can zithromax be prescribed twice for clamydia dexamethasone injection for dogs for back pain adalat sony att.com is digoxin 1.25 mg safe norvasc and cranberry juice flagyl tablet scandal dachrinne.org lexapro help with stress prozac 60 mg ocd plavix online from canada meastcompany.com henrycavillfan.org acyclovir tablets for herpes labialis nautilus principen seroquel xr twice day misoprostol hours after andiescafenapavalley.com cialis price quote walmart review lexapro user experiences lasix and dyazide en espanol doxycycline hyclate mood swings cipla fluconazole 150mg all about indomethacin meblebrzozowe24.pl cialis 20 mg para que es what is sildenafil citrate 50mg tab h-o-s.co.uk glucophage kalp imwithpete.net spa trim spa diet pill ibicisi.com can you overdose on amoxicillin caps 500mg etodolac 150 mg aciclovir sospensione costo albuterol premixed vials o que significa a palavra vigorando carrepairmanualdoc.com atomoxetine cancer can cialis make you last longer stomach upset from doxycycline metformin and 100mg clomid erythromycin 250 mg 3 times a day allegra and oj buy celecoxib canada hbm.org.pl can 3 year old use proventil inhaler asra guidelines plavix uncn.org imipramine pamoate 100 mg capsules valtrex and oil of oregano ibizaglobalradio.com augmentin presentaciones venezuela lisinopril 60 horyniec.com.pl what is amoxicillin ctb omeprazole teval taken same time as inderal apa itu obat azithromycin 500mg compare viagra and cialis lasting after ejaculation mycities.com.au zyvox 600mg tab is atarax a maoi wellbutrin xl jackson tn uzdrowisko-ewa.pl plavix 75 mg best price montelukast la gi take one propecia every other day wbstaffing.pl naproxen 375 milligram tablets tamoxifen fibroid growth 2exhibitions.com can lexapro make anxiety worse bactrim for 7 days dexamethasone without food taking celexa and tylenol bactrim fatigue side effects heartsdirect.co.uk que es el medicamento disulfiram tab lasix duration of effects celexa taken with amoxicillin allegra d 24 hr coupons augmentin e zerinol cuantos kilos se pierden tomando orlistat prednisone causing pneumonia kamagra 150 nlotus.com hywt.com is bactrim good for throat infection what kind of drug is viagra pain after ejaculation on cialis indapamide electrolyte imbalance buy zithromax 1g oral late ovulation clomid pcos can trazodone be taken with zoloft diacereina meloxicam spanish fluconazole uk price vegan and on coumadin diet how many cialis should i take when vegera sildenafil 100 mg how long does it take for erythromycin 500mg to work lexapro generic information zoloft pregnancy dosage nicetouristanbul.com what is metoprolol for blood pressure para sirve pastilla metoprolol satterfieldusa.com inderal and hastings-print.co.uk can i take amoxicillin for urinary infection sertraline seasonal affective disorder does cal ifornia medical cover lexapro older black men erection bemylight.org balkan-area.com propecia increase dosage nightanddaysoireeanimation.com florida-info.cz azithromycin pills look like bdxmen.com doxazosin mesylate combined with tenormin versace allegra stay better albuterol inhaler and tylenol allegra ab 360 thyroxine hereisthebestin reviews plavix tabletten can estrace and birth control cause a period seroquel sports cymbalta in diabetic neuropathy acyclovir side effects webmd hastings-print.co.uk robaxin and insomnia does levaquin affect birth control amoxicillin rocky mountain spotted fever dog spaccio di viagra is ranbaxy viagra legitimate beribak.com cytotec 2da dosis insideinsights.net overdose phenergan symptoms baby 18 months old levitra free samples las cruces septra with keflex lisinopril hctz lethal dose jethroshouse.co.uk taking cialis first time risks of clomid use herbal erection pills at clicks in south africa generic viagra uk kamagra tablets what if i stop taking finasteride tablets which is stronger clarithromycin or azithromycin how many gram of trazodone to fall asleep xenical price in south star drug para que sirve elduloxetine hcl dr 30 mg cap generic rizatriptan w3asia.com xhamster louisville naturalpathic erectile dysfunction synthroid overdose in pregnancy websitedesignportcharlotte.com how to get pregnant while on metformin fluconazole and zithromax when and what time i can take viagra abilify apotheek phenergan dose for dogs lamisil oral course costco pharmacy cost of flomax .4mg lamisil at for jock itch quitting nexium forum can flagyl and septrim cure yeast infection plavix 75 mg price in ranchi side effects of nexium hp7 black stool ejaculation problems while on viagra nazilliescortbayan.com muslimdate.com can drink amoxicillin 875 mg ilosone t?pico solu??o como usar zoloft hilft quem ja tomou tamoxifeno hsv acyclovir dosing strattera in ireland can you take claritin while taking celexa does metronidazole cause a rash ghb alkohol doxepin interaction between levothyroxine and warfarin antibiotics over the counter in okc ok upd315.com side effects of herceptin and tamoxifen inderal 80 nebenwirkungen synthroid and t3 levels phenergan 10mg safe to use for sleeping difficulty cialis 5mg price new zealand tamoxifen vs generic propecia nizoral minoxidil taking diet pill newhollandcommunications.de mobilepushnotifications.org naprosyn 375 price metronidazole over the counter tablets at walmart dosage for generic viagra omidazole and ofloxacin antibiotics linezolid safety lactation azithromycin fridge cialis dosage use eeroaarnio.cz imipramine 10 mg tab can you take amoxicillin with soda kamagra 100 bijwerkingen oral tetracycline for impetigo beccapronchick.com cseafaculty.org healthylifestyleart.com strattera medication for depression metformin ohne insulinresistenz pco millteksport.pl muslim-academy.com lexapro helpful with alcohol addiction zoloft to cymbalta accutane reviews for rosacea why does soma neurontin interact so strongly amantadine gabapentin cytotec effet secondaire for breastfeeding cost of plavix n turkey actuaryhub.com coupons for allegra d 24 uniquesarawak.com no1fl.com what if i throw up after taking zofran doxycycline leptospirosis treatment dog boredstop.com tab tadalafil 2g erh?hter augendruck viagra taking plavix with aspirin cuato balen cada pastilla cytotec para un aborrto levocitirizine montelukast tablets used for cialis 20mg lilly deutschland shot of levaquin variamedia.com.pl cytotec vajinal kullanimi nasil afekchess.com cialis what is it supposed to do for the men informatyk-szczecin.com.pl wellbutrin mouth side effects uniquesarawak.com avophotonics.com dachrinne.org vibramycin og neomycin can you mix amoxicillin with prednisone which herb is counterindicated with flagyl atenolol losartan mode of action how long does it take bactrim to leave your system cheap proventil how does cresor interact with diltiazem hcl er vollemaan.org aleskons.ru neurontin bipolar dosage cialis coupons 20 mg nizoral cream in india mobilepushnotifications.org metformin alcohol warning audiomaximus.com viagra controindicazioni pressione alta azithromycin and ureaplasma urealyticum wellbutrin sr dosages where to buy levitra 1judaica.com zovirax saft windpocken can i take vicodin with minipress

The Clone Killers

California claim fuels stem-cell debate.
by Tom McFeely | Source:
LA JOLLA, Calif. — Dr. Samuel Wood, head of a research team that says it has succeeded in creating human clones for use in embryonic stem-cell research, believes he’s a “highly ethical” scientist.

Pope Benedict XVI has a very different assessment of the morality of Wood’s research.

In an address Jan. 31 to participants in the annual plenary session of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Jan. 31, the Pope denounced cloning and embryonic stem-cell research.

“When human beings in the weakest and most defenseless stage of their existence are selected, abandoned, killed or used as pure ‘biological matter,’” said the Holy Father, “how can it be denied that they are no longer being treated as ‘someone’ but as ‘something,’ thus placing the very concept of human dignity in doubt?”

According to pro-life bioethicists, the criticism directed at Wood’s research highlights the advantages of the groundbreaking new “direct reprogramming” technique of creating stem cells from skin cells donated by adults.

“With reprogramming you have a cost-effective, scientifically simple way of doing the same thing that would be pursued with human cloning,” said Legionary Father Thomas Berg, who is a member of the ethics committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board, which oversees $600 million in research funding. “There is simply no need for that.”

Wood is a fertility specialist and chief executive officer of La Jolla-based Stemagen, a private stem-cell research and development company.

In a Jan. 29 interview with the Register, Wood confirmed his research team had created several human clones using the “somatic cell nuclear transfer” technique used to clone some species of animals. No one has previously succeeded in cloning humans.

Wood said Stemagen “has made progress beyond what we’ve reported” in creating stem-cell lines from the cloned embryos, but said it will take several months of additional testing to verify that the company has produced stem-cell lines that are viable for research purposes.

Wood said he had “no ethical concerns” about creating human clones and killing them in order to harvest their stem cells.

Cloned embryos created through nuclear transfer — and early-stage embryos that develop naturally through the process of fertilization — are only “potential human life,” Wood argued. Since only about 10%-20% of naturally fertilized eggs manage to survive to birth anyway, he said, “no one can look at a given embryo and say that it could lead to a live birth.”

According to Wood, this “potential life” is not of equal value to the suffering caused to millions of people suffering from diseases like Alzheimer’s and muscular dystrophy that might be cured by therapies derived from stem-cell research.

Unlike embryos, those disease victims are individuals “with uncontroversially defined human life,” Wood said.

“It’s simple for me,” he said. “A cloned embryo that may never be able to lead to a live birth is so secondary to the reality of what these people go through.”

Why It’s Wrong
Princeton law professor Robert George, co-author of the new book Embryo: A Defense of Human Life, says Wood’s arguments are comprehensively unsound.

Wood’s assertion that a life is “uncontroversially” human after birth, and is only “potential” life during its earliest embryonic stage of development “is simply arbitrary,” said George, who is a member of the President’s Council for Bioethics.

From the time of its creation as an embryo, George said, science has established that a human individual retains a constant biological identity as it progresses in successive stages of development to birth and eventually to adulthood.

And the fact that many embryos die before birth is irrelevant to their intrinsic humanity, George said.
He noted that in some parts of the world with high infant mortality, 30% to 40% of babies die before becoming toddlers.

“Would we then conclude that because of a naturally high death rate, that infants aren’t human persons with dignity?” said George. “Your ability to survive isn’t what makes you a human being.”

George said Wood’s argument about the suffering of victims of diseases is similarly flawed.

If it’s legitimate to kill an embryo to provide medical treatment for more developmentally advanced individuals who are “uncontroversially” accepted as human persons, George said it can also be argued that it’s permissible to kill newborn infants — who lack adult consciousness and other adult capacities — in order to harvest their organs for transplantation.

“Logically, his argument just won’t work,” said George. “It can be applied at any stage of development, as long as somebody is going to make the status of some human individual ‘controversial.’”

Furthermore, George said Wood’s argument about the relative value of embryonic life vs. the suffering of disease victims is completely unscientific.

“He has no expertise in this area,” George said. “These claims about value are not scientific claims. … These are claims that require philosophical or religious or some other non-scientific justification.”

The Alternative
In November, teams of researchers in Japan and Wisconsin announced that they had succeeded in “reprogramming” adult skin cells into becoming stem cells with the same “pluripotent” capacity as embryonic stem cells to form all tissues in the human body.

Wood said the FDA would never approve therapies utilizing cells created with the reprogramming technique employed by the Japanese and Wisconsin researchers, because it involves the introduction into the cells of small amounts of viral genetic material that could produce cancers.

However, he conceded that if researchers “can find a way around those scientific barriers, then I think that’s probably what people would do — it’s a lot simpler to do than any techniques that involve embryos.”

Other medical researchers said that alternative techniques already exist to induce the direct reprogramming of adult cells into pluri-potent stem cells without using the potentially carcinogenic viral material.

“These concerns can almost certainly be addressed using currently available scientific technologies, “Maureen Condic, associate professor of neurobiology and anatomy at the University of Utah, said in November after the direct reprogramming research findings were announced.

But Father Berg predicts some researchers will press onward with human cloning in order to conduct various kinds of life-destroying experiments on the embryos they create, despite the availability of alternative approaches.

(CNS contributed to this story.) Tom McFeely is based in Victoria, British Columbia.
Source: National Catholic Register - February 10-16, 2008 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular